The Likeability Penalty: How I Paid the Price for Confidence

The Likeability Penalty: How I Paid the Price for Confidence

Manipulative. Intimidating. Bossy.

Those three words hit me like the snap of a taut rubber band against bare skin. Sharp. Unjust. Wounding.

They felt untrue. They felt unfair.

I’ve always prided myself on being empathetic, flexible, and approachable. So, when I heard those words attached to my name, I couldn’t understand how they fit. But then, it hit me—I was experiencing the double bind.

The double bind is a harsh reality for women in corporate America. It’s the phenomenon that makes being both liked and respected - a near-impossible balancing act for women.

You see, when women don’t conform to traditional gender stereotypes—when we’re confident, assertive, or unapologetic—we’re judged as less likable. And that judgment can be career-defining.

Let me give you an example: When I showed up in meetings as knowledgeable and firm in my stance, when I advocated for my team or a vision I truly believed in, I was called “intimidating.” But my male counterparts? They could show up twice as bullish and still be admired. Respected. Even liked.

The very traits that made me an effective leader were the ones working against me in the court of public opinion.

When men are assertive, they’re admired. When women are, we’re “too much.” Confident women get labeled as “intimidating.” Strong women are called “bossy.” And the bias isn’t just from men—we’re all guilty of it.

And the kicker? This bias isn’t just perpetuated by men.

Women, too, internalize and reinforce these standards. It’s woven into the very fabric of how we’re conditioned to view authority, leadership, and success.

This post isn’t about solutions—at least not today. I’m not here to give you the “three steps to overcome likeability bias.” Because let’s be honest: the burden shouldn’t fall solely on women to navigate an unjust system.

Today is about awareness. It’s about naming the bias, calling it out, and refusing to normalize it.

To the woman climbing the ladder, staying true to her convictions, trusting her skills and expertise—and being labeled intimidating instead of respected—I see you.

You’re not the problem. The system is.

And to everyone else? Do better. Challenge your assumptions. Reflect on the labels you’re quick to assign. Advocate for women whose confidence and competence deserve recognition, not critique.

Because change starts with awareness. And it grows with action.

What’s your take? Let’s have the conversation.


genderbias #womeninleadership #doublebind #likeabilitybias #corporateamerica #womensupportingwomen #leadershipbias #breakthebias #equalopportunity #womenempowerment

Molly Muir

Operational Excellence Leader┆COO & Chief of Staff┆Architecting intelligent "run the business" operations

2 个月

I'm sure I gave myself whiplash throughout my career, being told that I was intimidating and unapproachable by one person, then being told I did not have "executive-presence" when I tried to be more open.

Cortney Jonas Burnos

AI-Powered Innovation Leader | Transcom | VP, AI & Digital | Tech Evangelist | McKinsey Alumni

2 个月

So absolutely (frustratingly) spot on! As leaders, how do we advocate for our teams and our platforms in this environment without being a b word? (Yes, I mean bossy!!)

Kristi Straw, MBA ?? Advisor to Visionary Executives

Top 1% LinkedIn Thought Leader | 3x Award-Winning Leadership & Sales Strategist | Bestselling Author | Keynote Speaker | Creator of UNICORN Leader? | CHIEF

2 个月

This one's a banger!! ???? And yes, Corporate America - DO BETTER!!! It's not our job to "help you" feel comfortable working alongside strong, competent women. And hate to say it - but white women? Yeah, they've been particularly harmful to other women on the rise -( the data even proves it, for those who want to argue).

Rick Kloete

Talent Matchmaker Building Futures One Leader at a time, Career Support for Owners & HR Professionals to fill Key Roles Quickly & Successfully Navigate Career Transition | Compensation Analysis

2 个月

Erica, I'd love to discuss this further. Your article makes a good point that resonates with most all of us that have been around male and female bosses. The source of the bias would be interesting to explore. Could the word system be replaced with culture, and my guess is that the level of bias is different based on age as well. It also could be influenced by your family of origin and it's makeup. Great topic, and thanks for elevating the awareness!

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Erica Anderson Rooney的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了