Lifeguard Shortage's Real Cause

Everyone has heard of pool closures this summer due to understaffed pools and the lack of lifeguards. This was not a problem thirty years ago. Only in the past ten to fifteen years have communities been feeling the lifeguard squeeze. What happened?

Today, there aren't enough candidates for lifeguarding courses. There aren't enough people who can pass a test to become a lifeguard. Why? Because they can't swim. Swimming lessons no longer teach afraid people to swim. They teach them strokes. These are two completely different things. The public needs to understand.

How many people are afraid? Half of adults are afraid in pools. Two thirds are afraid in open water. It's unknown how many kids are afraid in water.

What is knowing how to swim? Is it doing freestyle? Breaststroke? What if someone can do freestyle but he panics in deep water? Can that person swim?

Let’s say you’re at a hotel. As you walk to the restaurant, you pass the pool where four people in the deep end are chatting and treading. When you return from your meal, they’re still in the same spot. Would you say these people can swim?

If a family rents a houseboat for a week and spends its afternoons in the middle of a lake jumping off the boat, playing tag, lounging on a raft, knocking each other off air mattresses, diving under water to get away from each other, would you say those people could swim? Even if they did no formal strokes?

If you have a friend who swims a mile three times a week in a four-foot-deep pool, but she can’t do it in deep water because she’d panic, can she swim? She can “swim,” but she can’t swim!

There was a time not long ago—two or three decades—when knowing how to swim meant you were safe in water over your head. You might know strokes, too. It was understood that if you weren’t comfortable in deep water, you couldn’t swim.

In the 1980s and 90s, when swim team coaches became the most influential purveyor of swimming lessons, (nothing against swim coaches) the main definition of “I can swim” changed from, “I’m safe in deep water” to “I can do freestyle.” Their new lessons didn’t allow time to teach students that they float or how the water works with their bodies. Lessons were more concerned with teaching kids how to go fast.

Adults are taught the same lessons as those given to kids. It's been like that for over a hundred years. This was never viable for adults who were afraid, now 124 million Americans. The instructional agencies thought that the failure of adults to learn to swim was due to students' not practicing enough. Agencies didn’t know their instructors were unequipped to work with adults' fear.

Swimming coaches didn’t anticipate a downside of their new curriculum. No one realized that there were now two definitions of "learn to swim." It had been "I'm safe in deep water." Suddenly it became, "I can do freestyle." Thus we have, "She can swim but she can't swim!"

It’s taken a few decades of living with the fallout of all of this to deduce that in the 1990s or so, many or most swimming lessons stopped teaching safety and stopped requiring safety to “pass the swim test.” Instead, they required mechanical skills. The ability to rest and be peaceful in deep water was not tested. People could pass the test if they were fidgety.

It's clear today that in an alarming number of people, safety was not learned.

What is the fallout?

? A shortage of lifeguards: there haven’t been enough people who could pass the pre-test to take the training to become a lifeguard. Therefore, the pool of guards is now insufficient.

? Virtually no change in the drowning rate in the past twenty-plus years. One might guess that the drowning rate would have increased noticeably in that time except for the valiant efforts of the new industry of Drowning Prevention which has prevented many deaths.

? Twenty and thirty-somethings who cling to the sides in deep water even though they took swimming lessons and their parents think they can swim.

? Adults and kids who think they can swim, but can’t. They try out for swim teams. They swim from the shallow end toward the deep end and suddenly head for the side at the dropoff. The coach says, “I thought you said you could swim.” The ‘swimmer’ says, “I can, until I get to deep water.” The coach says, “I’m sorry, but you don’t know how to swim.” What is more unsafe than a person who thinks they can swim but can't?

? Many adults who quit swimming lessons because lessons teach strokes instead of comfort in deep water. Many become discouraged and resign themselves to not swimming: “I guess swimming isn’t meant for me.”

? People who pass the common swim test without proving that they can rest in deep water; therefore, they haven’t demonstrated that they’re safe.

? Parents who can't swim thinking their kids are finished with swimming lessons even though the kids still can't swim.

? Many people who are afraid in water who believe they simply need to learn to tread water to be safe. This is not possible until they can swim. They are not taught this. Teachers don't know.

Every citizen needs to know how to be comfortable and safe in water, shallow and deep: to swim. They need all the ideas, explanations, skills, and steps that are essential to learning comfort and safety. When they’ve embodied them—when they can swim—they can go on to learning strokes without struggle.

Strokes provide swimming efficiency. Sure, students may want to be efficient eventually. But new learners aren't efficient. They're inefficient because first they must learn how the water works and establish their safety. Safety first, efficiency later. It turns out that it’s not movements in deep water that makes you safe: it’s the ability to remain still inside—to be calm doing nothing because the water holds you up and you're in control. If it doesn't, as for a small percentage of people, you can still be perfectly calm. One day, after swimming lessons are turned around, this will be the goal of all beginning swimming courses. After twenty years of that, our drowning rate will plummet and once again there will be an abundance of lifeguards.

—From the Preface of Conquer Your Fear of Water: A Revolutionary Way to Learn to Swim Without Ever Feeling Afraid by Melon Dash, 2022

Melon Dash is founder and CEO of Miracle Swimming School for Adults, Sarasota FL, established 1983. Bio at https://miracleswimming.com/about-melon/