Life is Not a Race, 1st to the Grave Does Not Win
A neighborhood street in SW Portland that could be anywhere

Life is Not a Race, 1st to the Grave Does Not Win

Speed limits, enforcement, speed management, photo radar - all are very emotional topics. I have not brought them up at the holiday dinner table but they likely land in the category of politics, religion, money and family drama. When the National Committee on Uniform Traffic Control Devices took up the setting of speed limits earlier this year, it elicited a flood of responses, opinions and perceptions. Why is that?

Is it because virtually everyone has driven over the speed limit at some point in their lives and not been caught so, like in the NBA with traveling we do not expect to be called on it? Is "getting there" of such importance that a few seconds/minutes of travel time justifies the behavior? Is it that we believe the speed limits are not more than suggestions created to try and trap poor unfortunate souls? Do we believe speed limits have no rhyme or reason - consistency - and therefore we act as arbiters to what is appropriate? Is it because we are not in our neighborhood or next to our house that all bets are off as to adherence to speed limits? Do we see on TV constant images of speeding on public streets (even in car advertisements)? Are we such free people that rules made by the kings and queens do not apply to our better judgement? Could the roads we drive be designed in such an incompatible way (wide, straight, flat, open) to the context of their environments that we cannot help ourselves but drive faster than the speed limit? My speeding is ok but yours is not! Given the cultural breadth of speeding there are far more questions that we assume or perceive than answer with facts. Even with the research AAA has done over the years, it only scratches the surface of the "why" question which holds the key to any meaningful solutions.

While we have data associating highway fatalities and serious injuries to speeding to the tune of nearly 10,000 fatalities a year in the USA, even this data provokes many questions of excessive speeding (how do you define this for different highway functions), context of land use/access/design to speeds and actual speed of crashes v. posted speeds. No one can consider 10,000 fatalities and numerous more serious injuries to be something that "just will never change". We are approaching 2020 - we have a decade of hope ahead of us. By partnerships of various organizations toward a common purpose (engineering, enforcement, insurance, judicial, education), funding of safety focused programs, advancements in vehicle technology and innovation in data analytics we, together, can make a difference. Focusing on answering questions with data and facts still has a long way to go to avoid the emotional responses ahead. We will have to fight through the barriers of inertia, tendency to rush to judgement, and "the way things are done"-narrative-driven perceptions that fail to delve into the "why" questions deep enough to understand the complexities of how we got here. Resolve to be open to various perspectives and committed to fact-based research that advances us closer to major reductions in highway fatalities. Shape Your Community.

Stephen D. Fry, P.E., M.S.

Transportation Engineer at GDOT

5 年

Randy McCourt? I know this next rant could cost me job opportunities, but I need to speak up about how I feel as a designer.? BEGIN RANT PART 1:? I think the problem is deeper.? The ways Americans react to speed limits, LEOs and judiciaries deal with violations, and our design policies are structured around them all indicate that there may an addiction problem.? I think we are addicted as a society, as a design/planning profession, and as individuals to high speeds.? Under this corollary, sitting in congestion is like when an addict goes through withdrawal due to being unable to afford the "next hit."? That is why many suddenly speed up at the max acceleration the first chance they get.? Also, what's the point of cruise control if you intentionally set it to be 10 mph over?? PART 2 BELOW

回复
David Schwegel, PE

Promoter and Designer of State-of-the-Art Transportation Systems that Maximize Passenger Throughput while Stimulating Economies and Preserving the Environment

5 年

So true. Although feel free to take High-Speed Rail www.ushsr.com. Here’s the irony. Although High-Speed Rail moves quite fast (upwards of 200 mph), the French and Japanese High Speed Rail Systems have carried billions of passengers over multiple decades without a passenger fatality.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Randy McCourt的更多文章

  • Eclipse 2024 – Getting Ready for 2045

    Eclipse 2024 – Getting Ready for 2045

    On Saturday August 12, 2045, starting at about 9:15 AM Pacific time in California and ending at about 1:30 PM Eastern…

  • Eclipse - Howe did it compare to 2017?

    Eclipse - Howe did it compare to 2017?

    A month ago, a total solar eclipse traversed North America from Texas to Maine. It was only seven years ago that we…

  • 2024 Eclipse - The Morning After

    2024 Eclipse - The Morning After

    So much attention is paid to the day of the eclipse, the spectacular event and traffic - then off to other news. From…

    1 条评论
  • 2024 Eclipse - Traffic Case Studies in Congestion

    2024 Eclipse - Traffic Case Studies in Congestion

    Eclipse traffic episode #2 focuses on five metro areas and the duration/pattern of congestion following the eclipse…

    1 条评论
  • 2024 Eclipse - "It's like 50 Super Bowls"

    2024 Eclipse - "It's like 50 Super Bowls"

    In the next few weeks I will highlight observations of the 2024 eclipse related traffic across the USA. This four-part…

    6 条评论
  • Slow Down - Really

    Slow Down - Really

    Since the earth has cooled, folks in neighborhoods have been trying to get people to slow down on their streets…

  • Save the Economy – Help Ukraine Now

    Save the Economy – Help Ukraine Now

    Transportation plays a pivotal role in worldwide energy consumption. In the United States it represents over a quarter…

    2 条评论
  • FTA Seeks Input on Equity Analysis

    FTA Seeks Input on Equity Analysis

    FTA issued a request for information in November on Title VI implementation. In their dozen questions a few focus on…

  • US DOT EV Charging Program - Seeking Comments

    US DOT EV Charging Program - Seeking Comments

    The US Department of Transportation just issued a request for information in the Federal Register for comments as they…

  • Believe it or Not - MUTCD in 18 Months

    Believe it or Not - MUTCD in 18 Months

    Last Friday (November 5) the House finally freed the transportation reauthorization and we have H.R.

    3 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了