Leo Tolstoy's "Three Questions" and Its Relevance to Planning Large-Scale Transformations

Leo Tolstoy’s short story “The Three Questions” is a profound exploration of human wisdom, focusing on three essential questions that anyone seeking to live a meaningful life must answer. These questions—What is the right time to act? Who is the most important person? and What is the most important thing to do?—hold timeless relevance not only in personal life but also in the professional realm, particularly for consultants guiding large-scale transformations.

Consultants play a critical role in navigating complex change processes in organizations. They must manage multiple stakeholders, align strategies, mitigate risks, and deliver sustainable results. Tolstoy’s story offers valuable insights into how consultants can approach transformation with clarity, foresight, and purpose. By examining each of the three questions, we can uncover practical strategies for success.

1. What is the right time to act?

In Tolstoy’s story, the protagonist seeks to understand when the right moment to act is. The answer he receives is simple: "Now."

For consultants managing large-scale transformations, timing is everything. Large projects often require a careful assessment of the landscape—ensuring the right conditions are in place before moving forward. The "right time" isn’t always when everything looks perfect, but when the organization is ready to embrace change.

For consultants, this means:

• Readiness Assessment: Assessing the organization's readiness for change, both in terms of culture and infrastructure. Recognizing when key stakeholders are aligned or when more groundwork is needed to prepare the company.
• Risk Management: Knowing when to act decisively and when to wait. In transformations, premature action can lead to resistance or failure, while waiting too long can cause missed opportunities.
• Leveraging Momentum: Identifying windows of opportunity, such as during market shifts or technological advancements, that may propel the transformation. Acting at the right moment can accelerate change and create buy-in from leadership and employees.

Tolstoy’s principle—acting in the present moment—is a reminder that transformation doesn’t wait for perfect conditions; rather, it requires boldness and confidence in moving forward.

2. Who is the most important person?

The second question asks, Who is the most important person? The answer in the story: “The one you are with.”

In the context of consulting and large-scale transformations, this question emphasizes the significance of relationships. Transformation efforts depend not only on systems, processes, and strategies but also on the people involved. Consultants must prioritize relationships with stakeholders—whether they are senior executives, middle managers, or front-line employees.

This insight translates into several key practices:

• Stakeholder Engagement: Understanding the needs, concerns, and aspirations of different stakeholders is essential. Whether it's executives who need to be convinced of the value of change, or employees who need to be supported through the transition, each person matters. Building trust and clear communication with everyone involved ensures smoother progress.
• Empathy and Support: Transformation often requires people to change the way they work, think, or behave. By focusing on the individuals in the organization and supporting them through the emotional and practical aspects of change, consultants can drive greater adoption of the new strategies and technologies.
• Influence and Leadership: The most important person is often the one with the power to influence others. Identifying change champions within the organization who can support the transformation is a critical step. These individuals can rally others and help move the project forward, ensuring widespread buy-in and participation.

Tolstoy’s answer underscores the importance of focusing on the people who are directly involved, fostering human connection, and understanding that leadership comes from the people around you.

3. What is the most important thing to do?

Finally, Tolstoy’s protagonist asks, What is the most important thing to do? The response is simple yet profound: “The thing you are doing.”

For consultants, this translates to focusing on the task at hand with unwavering attention and dedication. When managing large-scale transformations, it’s easy to get distracted by the numerous elements that need to be addressed. However, success depends on focusing on the current moment—solving the immediate challenges that present themselves while keeping the broader vision in mind.

Key takeaways for consultants include:

• Task Prioritization: When leading transformations, consultants must prioritize actions based on their immediate impact. Doing the right thing at the right time is essential. This may mean focusing on a critical process redesign or working with a team to overcome resistance to a new system.
• Execution Over Perfection: Transformation initiatives are rarely straightforward. It’s important for consultants to focus on execution rather than getting bogged down by perfectionism. The ability to adapt, iterate, and pivot in response to new information or challenges is key to long-term success.
• Sustained Focus: Transformation is often a long and demanding journey. Consultants must stay committed to seeing projects through from start to finish. This means staying laser-focused on the work, engaging with the team, and ensuring progress, even in the face of setbacks.

Applying Tolstoy’s Wisdom to Consulting

Tolstoy’s Three Questions are more than just philosophical musings—they offer actionable insights for consultants working on large-scale organizational transformations. The answers to these three questions offer a clear framework for how consultants can approach complex change initiatives:

1. Act when the time is right: Assess readiness and seize the moment.
2. Value people: Focus on building strong relationships with those around you.
3. Focus on the task at hand: Prioritize, execute, and maintain sustained focus.

By embracing these principles, consultants can enhance their approach to large-scale transformations, ensuring they are not only effective in the work they do but also in the lasting impact they leave on the organizations they serve. Just as Tolstoy’s story teaches us that wisdom can be found in the simplicity of the present moment, consultants can find success by centering their efforts around timing, people, and purpose.

?