Legal Structures for Startups: LLP vs. Private Limited vs. Partnership - Which is Best for Your Indian Startup?

Introduction

Startups are entrepreneurial ventures that aim to develop an innovative product or service under conditions of extreme uncertainty. Choosing the right legal structure is an important decision for startups in the initial stages. The most common legal structures used by startups in India are Limited Liability Partnership (LLP), Private Limited Company (Pvt Ltd) and Partnership Firm.

A Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) is a hybrid form of business entity that provides the flexibility of a partnership and the advantages of limited liability of a company at a low compliance cost. The LLP Act 2008 governs LLPs in India.

A Private Limited Company (Pvt Ltd) is a separate legal entity registered under the Companies Act 2013. The liability of members is limited to their extent of shareholding and personal assets of the members remain protected. A Pvt Ltd requires more compliance and mandatory auditing.

A Partnership Firm is an association of two or more individuals formed to carry out business activities for profit. It is governed by the Indian Partnership Act 1932. Liability of partners is unlimited and personal assets of partners can be used to settle debts.

In this article, we will take a closer look at LLPs, Pvt Ltd and Partnership firms to understand the key differences from an Indian startup perspective. The pros and cons of each structure are analyzed to help entrepreneurs make an informed decision when incorporating their venture.

LLP Overview

A Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) is a form of business organization that allows individual partners to benefit from limited liability while retaining operational flexibility of a partnership. Some key features of an LLP:

• Separate Legal Entity: An LLP is a separate legal entity from its partners. This means the liability of the partners is limited to their agreed contribution to the LLP. The personal assets of the partners are protected.
• Less Compliance: Compared to a private limited company, an LLP has lesser compliance requirements in terms of audit and annual filings. There is no requirement of compulsory audits or publication of financial statements.
• Flexible Ownership: There are no restrictions on the maximum number of partners in an LLP. New partners can be introduced and existing partners can exit without affecting the existence of the LLP. The Partnership Agreement governs the ownership structure.
• Tax Benefits: LLPs are taxed at a lower rate than private limited companies. The compliance requirements for taxes are also lesser.

For startups, opting for an LLP structure can make sense due to the flexibility and tax advantages offered. The key benefits are:

• Limited liability protection helps founders safeguard personal assets
• Less compliance burden compared to a private limited company
• Flexible ownership structure facilitates changes in partnership
• Lower tax rates compared to a private limited company

Overall, the features and advantages of an LLP make it an attractive option for startups looking for a business structure that combines flexibility of a partnership with limited liability benefits.

Pvt Ltd Company Overview

A private limited company or Pvt Ltd company is a type of business entity in India that provides limited liability protection to its shareholders while imposing certain restrictions. Here are some key features and advantages of a Pvt Ltd company for startups:

• Separate Legal Entity: A Pvt Ltd company is a separate legal entity from its shareholders. This helps protect the personal assets of the shareholders in case the company faces losses or legal issues.
• Limited Liability: The liability of the shareholders of a Pvt Ltd company is limited to their amount of paid-up share capital. Personal assets of the shareholders are protected.
• Perpetual Succession: A Pvt Ltd company continues to exist even if the original shareholders leave or pass away. This provides stability to the company.
• Easier Access to Funding: Pvt Ltd companies find it easier to attract investors and lenders for funding compared to sole proprietorships and partnerships.
• Tax Benefits: Pvt Ltd companies get certain tax exemptions and lower tax rates compared to other structures. Profits are taxed at a flat rate.
• Freely Transferable Ownership: Ownership in a Pvt Ltd company can be freely transferred through the sale of shares. This enables entry and exit of shareholders conveniently.
• Separate Property: A Pvt Ltd company can acquire, own and dispose of property in its own name. The company's property is separate from the shareholders' personal property.
• Limited Compliance: Compliance requirements for Pvt Ltd companies are simpler compared to public limited companies while providing key benefits of incorporation.
• Credibility: Pvt Ltd structure enhances the credibility and reputation of a business compared to being a proprietorship or partnership firm.

Overall, the Pvt Ltd structure offers the right mix of limited liability, perpetual existence, easier access to capital and credibility for startups while keeping compliance and regulatory requirements simple and economical.

Partnership Overview

A partnership firm is governed by the Indian Partnership Act, 1932. It is formed by an agreement between two or more individuals who agree to do business together and share profits as per the partnership deed.

Some key features and advantages of a partnership for startups include:

• Easy to establish: A partnership firm can be created through a partnership agreement. No separate registration is required except for filing of Form A with the Registrar. This makes it easy and fast to set up.
• Minimal compliance: Compared to a company, a partnership needs to comply with very few regulations under the Partnership Act. There are no requirements of auditing accounts, holding board meetings, passing board resolutions etc.
• Flexible profit-sharing: Partners can agree on any profit-sharing ratio among themselves through the partnership deed. The ratio can be changed through mutual agreement.
• Unlimited ability to raise capital: There is no limit on the number of partners in a partnership firm. This allows raising more capital as needed by inducting more partners.
• Low taxes: Partnership firms enjoy a distinct tax advantage over companies. The firm is not taxed on its profits, only the partners have to pay individual taxes on their share of profit. This reduces the overall tax outflow.
• Limited liability of partners: The liability of partners is limited to their capital contribution. Personal assets of partners are not at risk, except in case of fraud. This reduces financial risk for partners.
• Easy closure: A partnership firm can be dissolved more easily compared to a company. The firm can be dissolved by mutual consent of partners or as per the terms of the partnership deed.

Overall, the flexibility, easy compliance requirements and tax advantages make the partnership structure well suited for startups in the early stages. It allows founders to test ideas quickly with minimal regulatory hassles.

LLP vs Pvt Ltd vs Partnership

When choosing a legal structure for a startup in India, the main options are LLP, Private Limited Company, and Partnership Firm. Here is a comparative analysis of the key differences between these three structures:

i. Ownership and Management

• LLP - Owned by partners with equal or differential share. Management is decentralized with partners responsible for day-to-day operations.
• Private Limited - Owned by shareholders through shares distribution. Management is centralized with Board of Directors.
• Partnership Firm - Owned by partners with equal or differential share. Management is decentralized with partners responsible for operations.

ii. Liability

• LLP - Limited liability for partners up to their capital contribution. Personal assets of partners are protected.
• Private Limited - Limited liability for shareholders up to the value of shares held. Personal assets of shareholders are protected.
• Partnership Firm - Unlimited liability for partners. Partners are personally liable for debts and liabilities of the firm.

iii. Capital Contribution

• LLP - No minimum capital contribution required. Partners contribute as per LLP Agreement.
• Private Limited - Minimum capital of Rs 1 lakh required at the time of registration.
• Partnership Firm - No minimum capital requirement. Contribution as per Partnership Deed.

iv. Taxation

• LLP - Pass through taxation. Profits are taxed in hands of partners.
• Private Limited - Separate legal entity, so taxed on standalone basis.
• Partnership Firm - Pass through taxation. Profits distributed to partners and taxed in their hands.

v. Compliance Requirements

• LLP - Moderate compliance load. Needs to file LLP Annual Returns and LLP Agreement.
• Private Limited - High compliance load with multiple filings like DIR-3, MGT-7, AOC-4 etc.
• Partnership Firm - Low compliance requirements. Only need to file for PAN and ITR.

vi. Ease of Operations

• LLP - High operational flexibility. Less restrictions on business activities.
• Private Limited - More restrictions under Company Act. Board processes add complexity.
• Partnership Firm - Operationally simple. Partners have flexibility in business operations.

So in summary, LLP offers the combined benefits of separate legal entity status with pass through taxation. It provides limited liability protection with operational flexibility. For most startups, LLP offers the right mix of features.

Taxation

The taxation structure differs for LLPs, private limited companies, and partnerships in India. This is an important consideration when choosing the legal structure for a startup.

i. LLP Taxation

• LLPs are taxed as a separate legal entity, similar to a private limited company.
• LLPs have to compulsorily file income tax returns irrespective of income levels.
• The income tax rate for LLPs is 30%.
• LLPs have to pay Alternate Minimum Tax (AMT) if the tax payable is less than 18.5% of adjusted total income.
• Distributions from the LLP to partners are exempt from dividend distribution tax. The partners have to pay taxes on their share of income.

ii. Private Limited Company Taxation

• Private limited companies are taxed as separate legal entities.
• The base corporate income tax rate is 25% for companies with turnover up to Rs. 250 crores.
• Companies have to pay Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) if the income tax payable is less than 15% of book profits.
• Dividend distribution tax of 15% is applicable on dividends paid to shareholders over Rs. 10 lakhs per annum.

iii. Partnership Taxation

• Partnerships are not taxed as separate legal entities. The income is taxed in the hands of the partners.
• There is no tax levied on the firm. The partners have to pay tax on their share of income at applicable rates.
• Partners can claim interest paid to partners as deductions to compute taxable income.
• There is no dividend distribution tax. Profits can be divided among partners without additional tax.

So in summary, LLPs and private limited companies face double taxation on income, while partnerships avoid entity-level taxes. LLPs have an edge with lower income tax rates compared to private limited companies. Partnerships offer the most tax-efficient structure.

Compliance

Regulatory compliance is an important consideration when choosing between an LLP, Private Limited Company, or Partnership for a startup in India. Here's an overview of the key compliance requirements for each structure:

i. LLP Compliance

• LLPs need to file an annual return within 60 days of the end of the financial year. This includes basic details about the LLP like registered office address, partners' details, turnover, etc.
• An LLP also needs to file financial statements in the prescribed format annually. This includes a Statement of Account and Solvency and balance sheet.
• Any changes in partners or registered office address need to be intimated to the Registrar within 30 days.
• LLPs are required to maintain proper books of accounts audited by a practicing Chartered Accountant.
• The audit needs to be completed within 6 months of the financial year end.
• LLPs also need to obtain a Tax Deduction Account Number (TAN) and Goods and Services Tax Identification Number (GSTIN) for taxation purposes.

ii. Private Limited Company Compliance

• Private limited companies need to conduct board meetings at least 4 times a year and an Annual General Meeting (AGM) annually. Minutes need to be documented.
• They need to file their annual return within 60 days of the AGM. This contains details of directors, shareholders, share capital, registered office etc.
• Financial statements need to be filed annually within 30 days of the AGM. This includes balance sheet and profit/loss statement.
• Any changes to directors, address, share capital etc. need to be filed within 30 days.
• Private limited companies also need to maintain statutory registers and proper books of accounts audited annually.
• Like LLPs, private limited companies need to obtain TAN and GSTIN.

iii. Partnership Firm Compliance

• Partnership firms need to file for a GSTIN if their turnover exceeds the threshold limit.
• They need to file annual income tax returns in ITR-5 by the due date.
• Partnership deeds need to be registered for firms involved in real estate transactions.
• Any change in partners needs to be intimated to the Registrar.
• Proper books of accounts audited by a CA are mandatory. The audit needs to be completed within 6 months of year-end.

So in summary, LLPs and private limited companies have more stringent compliance requirements compared to partnership firms. LLPs have slightly lower compliance burden than private limited companies.

Foreign Investment

Attracting foreign investment is an important consideration for many startups in India. The legal structure can impact the ease and rules around foreign investment.

i. LLPs

LLPs allow foreign direct investment (FDI) under the automatic route in sectors where 100% FDI is allowed. There are no capitalization requirements. The foreign partner can freely transfer their capital and profits outside India.

ii. Private Limited Companies

Private limited companies also allow 100% FDI under the automatic route in most sectors. FDI up to 49% is permitted in certain regulated sectors under the government route. Minimum capitalization norms may apply in some cases. Foreign investors can repatriate funds outside India.

iii. Partnerships

FDI in partnerships is more restrictive. FDI is allowed only in certain sectors like power, non-banking finance, pharma, airports, telecom etc. Approvals from FIPB and RBI are required in most cases. Capital restrictions may also apply. Repatriation of funds needs RBI approval.

So for startups looking for maximum flexibility in attracting foreign capital, LLPs and private limited companies are preferable over partnerships. The automatic route makes FDI easier compared to regulated sectors in private limited companies. LLPs have the least restrictions when it comes to foreign investment.

Winding Up Process

Winding up a business entity like an LLP, Private Limited or Partnership Firm is an important consideration from legal and compliance perspective. Here's an overview of the winding up process for each:

a. LLP

• LLPs may be wound up voluntarily when the partners decide to dissolve the LLP, or compulsorily by the tribunal.
• To voluntarily wind up an LLP, the partners need to file an application with the Registrar along with required statements and affidavits. The Registrar will then publish a notice to invite objections.
• If no objections are received, the Registrar passes an order dissolving the LLP. The partners will settle the accounts and distribute assets as per agreement.
• The winding up process is relatively simpler compared to a private limited company. There are fewer procedural requirements.

b. Private Limited Company

• A private limited company may be wound up voluntarily by shareholders' consent, or compulsorily by the Tribunal.
• Voluntary winding up requires approval of 3/4th shareholders. Detailed application is filed with ROC along with audited accounts.
• Liquidator is appointed to sell assets and settle liabilities. Shareholders get residual assets per their entitlement.
• Compulsory winding up is initiated by Tribunal upon petition by creditors or shareholders. Official liquidator takes over assets.
• Winding up process is more complex with stringent compliance requirements.

c. Partnership Firm

• Dissolution of a partnership firm may happen on mutual consent of partners, as per partnership deed, or as per court order.
• The partners need to settle accounts, pay off liabilities and distribute residual assets as per profit/loss sharing ratio.
• If differences arise, the partnership deed governs dissolution process. Further disputes may need court intervention.
• Winding up is relatively easier compared to LLP and private limited company. Compliance requirements are lower.

Conclusion

When choosing the ideal legal structure for a startup in India, it's important to consider the taxation, compliance requirements, foreign investment eligibility, and winding up process for each type of entity.

LLPs offer a flexible structure with relatively low compliance burdens, but have limitations on foreign investment. Private limited companies allow foreign investment and have more fundraising options through equity issuance, but require higher compliance standards. Partnerships are the simplest structure with minimal compliance, but offer unlimited liability for partners.

For most tech startups in India today, a private limited company is likely the best choice. The fundraising flexibility and ability to attract foreign investment makes the additional compliance worthwhile. However, an LLP may be preferable for bootstrapped startups looking to minimize regulatory burdens in the early stages.

Ultimately there is no one-size-fits-all solution. Evaluate your specific startup's needs and long-term goals, and choose the legal structure that provides the right mix of liability protection, fundraising ability, tax efficiency, and ease of operations. Be prepared to evolve the structure over time as the business grows. With careful planning, any of these entities can provide a solid legal foundation for an Indian startup.

Subscribe this newsletter and follow Legal Suvidha? and First Unicorn ?? ? to get more updates about exciting startups where you can invest and if you are a startup having a great vision/mission and solving a big problem connect with us for funding opportunities.

?

If you are planning to launch your Startup, read my Free e-book here: https://growsocio.com/product/e-book-launch-like-a-pro-the-mvp-method-for-startup-success/