LEGAL ASPECTS: WHAT FRAUDULENT "FOREX TRADING" COMPANIES IN UGANDA DON’T WANT YOU TO KNOW
A few weeks ago, I interfaced with several Youthful Ugandans who lost money to fraudulent forex brokers. More youth within my circle do Forex trading in this country than those who invest in mainstream capital markets securities such as shares, bonds, ETFs, or even Unit trusts that the Capital Markets Authority approves. The internet and global interconnectivity have made Forex trading more accessible to youth than approved capital markets products.
Unlike the Capital Markets Authority of Kenya, which enacted regulations for Forex dealing and non-dealing brokers, in Uganda, our regulator, the Capital Markets Authority, has no such regulations on its books. However, the absence of these regulations in Uganda doesn't mean that there are no Global certification standards that these online Forex brokerages should follow.
In Africa, it's hard to find A-book servers operating in strict countries like South Africa with competent financial regulators. B book companies always run to fertile ground like Uganda, where people have little understanding of such business and governments don't ask for "liquidity providers" and large sums of money to act as capital buffers.
As you read this write-up, kindly distinguish between the business of a Forex bureau regulated by the Bank of Uganda and Forex trading. In forex trading, you are taking positions in the market for "investment purposes," either through spot contracts or derivatives. Most of these dealing/non-dealing Forex brokerages utilize something called "A Contract for Difference (CFD)," which is, is an agreement between a buyer and a seller in which the buyer agrees to pay the seller the difference between the current value of an asset and its value at the time the contract is entered into.
CFDs provide traders and investors with a chance to make gains from price fluctuations without having to possess the actual assets. The CFD's worth is solely based on the difference in price between when the trade begins and when it concludes, without considering the asset's fundamental value.
The Capital Markets Authority and not the Bank of Uganda should regulate trading activities where people take positions in a market. The business of a forex bureau doesn't invite the public to take positions in the market, but forex trading does. I should make this pre-emptive disclaimer to dispel any regulatory confusion that might arise from this write-up.
The word "brokerage" in the business of forex trading means that the company is supposed to broker business between the trader and the institution trader with access to the market. In this case, the institution may be a bank that files a trade. The brokerage company is paid a commission on every transaction the institution files.
Most online brokerages that target Ugandans lack access to the real market. Some of these companies may buy servers and access the real market. However, their accounts don't have genuine clients in the regular market system. This usually helps these companies manipulate price movements in their favor. They also play around with the design that sets the amount they pay back less than they receive. Most forex companies here don't have a "liquidity provider." The liquidity provider acts at both ends of currency transactions. He sells and buys a particular asset at specific prices. It means that he is making the market. These are usually companies independent of the online forex brokers.
Liquidity providers are fundamental for the success of electronic trading in today's financial market since they ensure a steady supply of liquidity. This indicator reflects how quickly an instrument turns into cash without fluctuating its price. Global forex trading certification standards require a liquidity provider. However, most forex brokerages targeting Ugandans online don't have them.
This is how most fraudulent online forex brokerages operate. They start by opening an offshore account in a country where they can set up robust IT systems. They obtain these servers at just $20,000. They then collect a lump sum of money from new traders to play subsisting clients by giving them some of the winning trades.
They always keep their financial books updated every midnight. With each new trading day, they decide how much profit and loss to distribute to their clients. For example, if the platform earns $100,000, the proprietors can distribute just $5000 to clients. They keep manipulating the market. Those with accounts with small deposits of about $200 up to $1000 lose out the most because these forex brokerages decide what to give back to their clients, regardless of market price movements.
These fraudulent brokerages always create demo servers that give them access to the market to manipulate prices. We have seen this with online brokerages at open prices and the New York session. They usually don't have a bank to file their trades.
Forex companies targeting Ugandans use their own money to operate without the backing of a liquidity provider. Recently, a youthful Ugandan attempted to sue a company that had failed to pay him 20000 dollars. Unfortunately, the company is an offshore entity with no office in Uganda. This creates jurisdiction issues in law, especially if you institute civil proceedings in Ugandan courts.
领英推荐
Globally, there are "A-book" brokerage companies and "B-book" companies in the forex markets. In Africa, it's hard to find A-book servers operating in strict countries like South Africa with competent financial regulators. B book companies always run to fertile ground like Uganda, where people have little understanding of such business and governments don't ask for "liquidity providers" and large sums of money to act as capital buffers.
I was recently involved in a legal transaction on behalf of a reputable company that declined to be a liquidity provider for several forex brokerage companies operating in Uganda. Most brokerages don't meet the necessary global certification requirements. When these brokerages fail to get reputable liquidity providers, they always use their companies' operational money or client's money, which is against global brokerage certification standards. This mode of operation, inadvertently or not, will make them trade against clients to keep in the market.
?
Conclusion.
This is how you can spot a fraudulent Forex Brokerage Company
?
1. They have no registered office within Uganda. They are typically domiciled offshore in a tax haven like in the Caribbean islands?
2. They will never declare bank statements, including filed trades and payups.
3. They usually have no liquidity providers (banks with security) since all operating costs are on them.
4. Their market movements are always different from the normal currency markets since they manipulate through their servers.
? ?
Psychology, Investment Banking, Financial Markets, Finance/Investments, Sustainability, Wealth, Technology & Entrepreneurship | CFA Candidate Level 1.
2 周Interesting talking points; yes, There are many opinions about Forex trading—some call it a game of luck, others see it as a high-risk venture, others call it a scam?!!! while a growing number recognize it as a serious profession. it’s important to understand that the FX market is real and one of the largest in the financial world. A %age of Ugandans have found success in Forex trading, and many more are entering the space. For those pursuing FX trading as a career or just starting out, choosing a well-regulated broker is critical. The credibility of a broker is determined by its regulation under top-tier authorities such as the Financial Conduct Authority, CySEC, CMA, FSCA, FSA (Seychelles), CBCS, FSC (Mauritius), and FSC (BVI). Brokers regulated by these bodies generally offer safer trading environments. Some of the well-regulated FX brokers include CMC Markets, IC Markets, IG, Pepperstone, and more. Success in fx trading is not just about choosing the right broker; it requires thorough market knowledge, risk management, and continuous learning. Without these, the market can hurt. Caution: Guys, this is not financial advice but rather my personal views. Always conduct your own research before making any trading decisions.
Finance/Agritech innovations/Agribusiness/ climate change / Agri-financing/ Food systems.
1 年How best can we handle this in Uganda?
Financial Markets | Financial Literacy & Education | M.Sc. Financial Management
1 年Thanks for this very detailed and insightful piece, Louis! I believe you can resonate with me when I say there is a critical need for financial literacy because several Ugandans are still very ignorant on matters of regulation, technicalities & operations of these derivatives instruments. It has become an important task of CFDs regulators to institute investor education as part of requirements for broker licences. This will also gradually remove bad actors from this industry! Thank you for being part of the good cause!
Full Stack Engineer at Athari crafting innovative tools for recruiters.
1 年nice
Public health specialist and Monitoring and evaluation.
1 年I've not seen you mention any of the brokers you feel are taking Ugandans money