The Leather Jacket: How the Crowd Shapes Our Choices

When I was younger, I wanted a leather biker jacket. It wasn’t trendy, none of my friends had one, and I didn’t even own a bike—but I wanted it anyway. In Mansfield, where I lived, the club scene had its own unspoken dress code. You needed black trousers and shoes, but beyond that, most men made the same choice: a Ben Sherman shirt.

That was the style. It wasn’t enforced, but it was clear: if you wanted to blend in and belong, you wore one. And most people did.

I chose not to wear the shirt. Not because I wanted to rebel, but because I didn’t feel the need to follow the crowd. But looking back, I can see how powerful that collective identity was. The Ben Sherman shirt wasn’t just clothing—it was a signal, a way to say, “I’m part of this group.”

This isn’t just a story about a leather jacket. It’s about how people make choices—why they often stick to the safety of the crowd, and how understanding this behavior can transform your marketing.

Lesson 1: People Crave Belonging

The Ben Sherman shirt wasn’t popular because it was the best shirt on the market. It was popular because it was a symbol. Wearing it meant you belonged, you fit in, and you weren’t going to stand out in a way that might draw judgment or exclusion.

• Marketing Insight: People buy products that help them feel part of a group, whether it’s a fashion trend, a community, or a shared lifestyle.
• Action: Position your brand as a way for customers to connect with others who share their values or style.

Think about brands like Starbucks. Buying a Starbucks coffee isn’t just about the drink—it’s about participating in a shared culture of convenience, quality, and belonging.

Lesson 2: Crowds Create Comfort

Most people feel safer when they stick with what’s familiar. In Mansfield, you could be confident that wearing a Ben Sherman shirt was the “right” choice—it was tried and tested by the crowd.

• Marketing Insight: Customers often choose brands or products that feel safe because others have already validated them.
• Action: Use social proof to reassure potential customers. Highlight testimonials, reviews, and the popularity of your product to show that others trust it.

For example, Amazon leverages customer reviews to great effect, turning crowd validation into a key decision-making factor.

Lesson 3: Trends Shape Identity

While the Ben Sherman shirt was a choice, it also became a uniform in its own right, defining the identity of the crowd. People didn’t just wear it—they wore what it represented: belonging, reliability, and style.

• Marketing Insight: Trends are powerful because they give people an identity to align with.
• Action: Align your product with a lifestyle or movement. Make it more than just a product—make it a statement about who your customers are.

Apple’s branding achieves this brilliantly. Owning an iPhone isn’t just practical—it’s a way to say you’re part of a forward-thinking, innovative group.

Lesson 4: Risk Aversion Drives Decisions

For most people, the fear of standing out or being judged is stronger than the desire to be different. In Mansfield, wearing something outside the norm could make you feel awkward or out of place, so the safer option was to follow the trend.

• Marketing Insight: Customers often avoid taking risks with their choices. They gravitate toward what feels predictable and socially accepted.
• Action: Highlight the reliability and ease of choosing your product. Show that it’s a decision they won’t regret.

Think about how Volvo markets safety. It’s not flashy or trend-setting—it’s about reassuring customers that their choice is solid and dependable.

Takeaway: Marketing to the Crowd

The Ben Sherman shirt wasn’t just a shirt—it was a way to fit in. Most people don’t buy to stand out; they buy to stay safe, to belong, and to align with a group identity.

As a marketer, it’s your job to recognize this need and tap into it. Are you creating a product or service that feels safe and aligned with a larger identity? Are you making it easy for people to see themselves as part of a group by choosing you?

Because when it comes to the masses, it’s not just about what you sell—it’s about how your brand makes people feel like they belong.

Message, let's talk about growing your business.