Leadership Mistakes That Killed Empires—and Bankrupted Companies

The next few years will bring some of the most exciting—and challenging—changes we’ve seen in business. With AI, automation, shifting global supply chains, sustainability demands, and geopolitical shifts, today’s leaders are navigating a world of constant disruption.

As someone who values history, I find it both fascinating and a bit concerning how many of the leadership missteps of the past—resisting change, poor decision-making, overconfidence, and underestimating competition—are still playing out in major corporations today.

But history isn’t just about looking back; it’s about learning. The echoes of past leadership failures offer a powerful lens through which we can better understand today’s challenges and opportunities. By recognizing these patterns, we have a unique chance to lead with greater foresight, adaptability, and resilience.

Let’s take a journey through history and explore some of these lasting impressions—because the lessons of the past may be exactly what we need to shape the future.

Echoes of Leadership: Lessons from History and the Boardroom

History is littered with tales of leaders who stood at the precipice of change—some adapting, others resisting, and many falling into obscurity. The same patterns that led to the downfall of empires, kingdoms, and revolutionary movements can be seen reflected in the rise and fall of Fortune 500 companies. Leadership, whether on the battlefield or in the boardroom, is often tested not in moments of triumph but in the face of disruption.

Julius Caesar ignored the warnings of his impending assassination, believing himself untouchable—just as BlackBerry executives dismissed the growing shift to touchscreen smartphones. Marie Antoinette, famously out of touch with the struggles of her people, could be compared to Sears' failure to recognize the digital revolution sweeping retail. The great Mongol Empire, once an unstoppable force, fractured due to poor succession planning, much like the internal chaos that led to Yahoo’s decline.

The failures of history and business share a striking resemblance: leaders who were too arrogant to change, too stubborn to listen, too blind to competition, or too indecisive when action was required. From Kodak’s hesitation to embrace digital photography to the collapse of Lehman Brothers under reckless decision-making, these are not just business case studies—they are echoes of the past.

As we delve into the top leadership failures in modern business, we will explore their historical counterparts, drawing invaluable lessons that today’s business leaders must heed. The patterns are clear, the lessons timeless, and the stakes higher than ever. Will today’s executives learn from history, or are they doomed to repeat it?

Failure to Adapt to Market Changes

The Fall of the Ming Dynasty & Xerox – The Cost of Ignoring Innovation

In the 16th and 17th centuries, the Ming Dynasty ruled China with power and prestige. Its economy flourished, its military was formidable, and its culture thrived. But as the world changed, Ming leaders clung to old ways rather than embracing necessary reform. While European powers expanded their naval capabilities and embraced new trade routes, China turned inward, restricting commerce and dismissing technological advancements. Over time, this isolation made the empire vulnerable to economic stagnation, internal corruption, and external invasion. By 1644, the Ming Dynasty collapsed, replaced by the more adaptive Qing rulers.

A similar fate awaited Xerox, once the undisputed leader in the copier industry. In the 1970s, Xerox engineers at PARC (Palo Alto Research Center) invented groundbreaking technology, including the first personal computer, the graphical user interface (GUI), and the computer mouse. However, Xerox’s leadership dismissed these innovations, failing to see their potential beyond copy machines. Meanwhile, companies like Apple and Microsoft recognized the power of these innovations and capitalized on them, creating the modern computer revolution. By the time Xerox realized its mistake, it had lost its opportunity to dominate the tech industry, becoming a shadow of its former self.

The Leadership Lesson

The Ming Dynasty and Xerox both had the tools to innovate but chose complacency over adaptation. Leaders must recognize that past success does not guarantee future dominance. To survive, companies and empires alike must evolve with the times, embrace change, and anticipate disruption before it arrives.

Poor Leadership & Decision-Making

The Fall of Czar Nicholas II & WeWork – When Leadership Fails Under Pressure

In the early 20th century, Czar Nicholas II ruled Russia during a time of immense social and political unrest. Instead of addressing economic hardship and growing public dissatisfaction, Nicholas ignored warning signs and failed to modernize his government. His poor decisions—such as entering World War I without adequate preparation—fueled widespread discontent. In 1917, revolution erupted, toppling his empire and leading to his execution.

A century later, Adam Neumann, the charismatic but reckless CEO of WeWork, followed a similar trajectory. Neumann promised rapid expansion, industry disruption, and limitless growth, yet his leadership was marked by erratic decisions, reckless spending, and failure to implement a sustainable business model. Investors eventually lost confidence, and in 2019, WeWork’s valuation plummeted from $47 billion to near collapse. Like Nicholas II, Neumann’s poor leadership led to the downfall of what was once considered an unstoppable force.

The Leadership Lesson

Both Nicholas II and Neumann failed to listen, adapt, and make sound decisions under pressure. True leaders acknowledge reality, seek counsel, and make strategic choices that ensure long-term stability, not just short-term gain.

Overconfidence & Resistance to Change

The Fall of the Spanish Armada & General Motors – When Hubris Leads to Disaster

In 1588, King Philip II of Spain sent the Spanish Armada, one of the most powerful naval fleets ever assembled, to conquer England. Confident in Spain’s superiority, he underestimated the agility of the English navy and the power of unpredictable weather. The Armada was decimated, and Spain’s dominance in Europe began to decline.

Similarly, General Motors (GM) once ruled the American auto industry, confident that its market dominance would never be challenged. However, when Japanese automakers like Toyota and Honda introduced fuel-efficient, high-quality vehicles in the 1970s and 80s, GM ignored the shift in consumer demand. Instead of adapting, GM doubled down on inefficient gas-guzzlers. The result? By 2009, GM filed for bankruptcy, requiring a government bailout to survive.

The Leadership Lesson

Spain and GM both suffered from hubris and resistance to industry shifts. No leader or company is invincible. Success requires humility, awareness, and a willingness to pivot when necessary.

Ignoring Competition & Industry Disruptors

The Fall of the Byzantine Empire & BlackBerry – When Leaders Underestimate the Enemy

For over a thousand years, the Byzantine Empire stood as a stronghold of Eastern Europe. However, by the 15th century, the empire had shrunk dramatically, and leaders failed to recognize the growing power of the Ottoman Turks. The Byzantines believed their mighty walls and legacy would protect them—but in 1453, the Ottomans, using superior military technology like massive cannons, breached Constantinople, ending the empire.

A modern parallel exists in BlackBerry, once the king of mobile phones. In the mid-2000s, BlackBerry executives dismissed Apple’s iPhone as a mere fad, believing their physical keyboard and email security would keep them competitive. They ignored the touchscreen revolution, and as Apple and Android devices surged ahead, BlackBerry lost relevance. By the 2010s, it was all but extinct in the smartphone market.

The Leadership Lesson

The Byzantine rulers and BlackBerry executives both ignored warning signs and underestimated their competition. Leaders must constantly innovate, monitor competitors, and be willing to disrupt their own models before others do it for them.

Conclusion: Learning from the Past

The echoes of leadership failures—whether on the battlefield or in the boardroom—teach us that history repeats itself for those who fail to learn from it. From empires that resisted change to businesses that underestimated competition, the message remains the same: Adapt. Innovate. Lead with wisdom.

Success is not about avoiding failure altogether—it’s about recognizing when change is needed and acting before it’s too late. The leaders who shape the future are those who learn from both victories and defeats. The question now is: Will you be one of them?

Michael Halsey

Chief Operations Officer- FirstStepBeverage

?