The Launch of AI Agents: A Technological Leap and the Legal Challenges Ahead
Giulio Coraggio
Solving Legal Challenges of the Future | Head of Intellectual Property & Technology | Partner @ DLA Piper | IT, AI, Privacy, Cyber & Gaming Lawyer
The world of artificial intelligence is rapidly evolving, and a new milestone has been reached with the launch of advanced AI agents.
These agents are poised to transform our interaction with technology by not only responding to text commands but also performing actions on our computers as a human would: moving the cursor, typing, clicking, and reading the screen. Imagine a future where your computer doesn't just answer your queries but actively assists you by navigating windows, filling out forms, and managing your tasks. While this represents a significant advancement, it also brings forth a host of legal challenges that must be carefully addressed.
Beyond Text: What Do Advanced AI Agents Do?
Traditional AI chatbots have been confined to responding within the boundaries of text. However, the new generation of AI agents breaks free from this limitation. Developers can now program AI that interacts directly with the computer environment, automating repetitive and mundane tasks. Although these systems are still in their infancy—prone to errors and operating at slower speeds—they signal the beginning of a shift towards AI handling more complex activities autonomously.
For instance, an AI agent could gather information from your computer and complete forms without human intervention. This might seem trivial, but the implications are far-reaching. Such capabilities could revolutionize productivity by offloading routine tasks from humans to AI, allowing individuals to focus on more strategic and creative endeavors.
Several tech giants and startups are investing in similar AI agent technologies. What sets these agents apart is their ability to act beyond text, directly interfacing with computer systems to manage intricate projects with greater autonomy.
Privacy and Security Concerns of AI Agents
The advent of AI agents capable of operating our computers raises significant privacy and security issues. To function effectively, these agents require direct access to our devices, which poses risks of data breaches and unauthorized data transmission. There have been instances where companies delayed launching similar functionalities due to security concerns. Ensuring that user data is protected and used securely is paramount.
Moreover, granting such deep access to AI agents could inadvertently expose sensitive personal or corporate information. Without robust security measures, there is a heightened risk of malicious exploitation by cybercriminals who might hijack these agents for nefarious purposes.
This big moment on the future of artificial intelligence is happening a few days before the event of the European Data Protection Board dedicated to AI models. Hopefully, data protection authorities will understand that generative artificial intelligence, including AI agents, are the future of our economy, and solutions need to be found to adequately balance the protection of individuals with the exploitation of such technologies.
The liability cannot be just of provides of generative AI as the potential misuses are performed deployers which do not have a clear understanding of the limits in which such technologies shall be used.
Potential for Misuse of AI Agents
The power of AI agents also opens the door to potential misuse. Autonomous navigation capabilities could be exploited for activities like spamming, phishing, or generating large-scale AI-created content that floods digital spaces. The ease with which these agents can perform tasks might enable the rapid dissemination of misinformation or the creation of fraudulent schemes.
This scenario underscores the necessity for clear responsible management that needs to be implemented setting out an internal AI governance framework, leading to precise internal rules and technical guardrails in the AI usage. Developers and companies must implement safeguards to prevent abuse, such as strict authentication protocols, usage limits, and monitoring systems to detect and halt suspicious activities.
Legal Challenges to Address
With the emergence of such potent AI agents, companies adopting such technologies shall address several legal challenges that demand attention:
- Data Protection and Privacy: How can we ensure that AI agents do not access or transmit personal data outside the control of the company and without the relevant legal basis? Compliance with data protection laws like the GDPR becomes even more critical.
- Liability Issues: In cases where an AI agent makes an error or causes harm, determining liability becomes complex. Is it the developer, the user, or the AI itself?
- Intellectual Property Rights: AI agents that create content or gather data from various sources may infringe on intellectual property rights, leading to legal disputes.
- Regulatory Compliance: Existing laws may not adequately cover the capabilities of advanced AI agents. There's a pressing need for updated regulations that address these new technologies.
Looking Beyond the "Text Box"
The shift from text-based AI to agents that can interact with our computers is a game-changer. While current versions may be imperfect, continual improvements will enable these agents to handle increasingly complex tasks. We can foresee a future where AI agents manage appointments, fill out forms, respond to emails, and even curate personalized news briefings without any manual input.
However, embracing this future necessitates confronting the accompanying legal and ethical implications. Security, privacy, and ethical use are not just technical challenges but legal ones that require collaboration between technologists, legal experts, policymakers, and society at large.
Conclusion
The advent of advanced AI agents heralds an exciting new chapter in technology, offering unprecedented convenience and efficiency. Yet, it also brings forth significant legal challenges that cannot be overlooked. Addressing these issues is crucial to harnessing the full potential of AI agents while safeguarding users' rights and maintaining public trust.
As we stand on the cusp of this technological revolution, it is imperative to engage in open dialogue and proactive policymaking. By doing so, we can ensure that the integration of AI agents into our daily lives is both beneficial and responsible.
As mentioned above, whatever AI solution a company wants to adopt, a crucial step in the adoption relates to the creation of an AI governance framework. On the topic, you can read the article available HERE.
Below are the other articles of this week from my group at DLA Piper on the legal challenges of innovation.
Podcast
The state of the global online gambling market with Marco Trucco of Videoslots
In this episode of the “Diritto al Digitale†podcast, host Giulio Coraggio sits down with Marco Trucco, Chief Marketing Officer at Videoslots, to explore the evolving landscape of the online gambling industry. Listen here.
Artificial Intelligence
Has your organization implemented an AI governance model?
It's become increasingly clear that the intersection of AI and governance is pivotal for organizations looking to use the power of AI while mitigating associated risks. The rapid evolution of AI, coupled with stringent regulatory frameworks such as the EU AI Act, necessitates a structured and comprehensive approach to AI governance. Read more
Data Protection and Cybersecurity
AI and privacy: The DPAs' view on children and AI and trustworthy AI
From 9 to 11 October 2024, the fourth edition of the G7 Data Protection Authorities (DPA) Roundtable took place in Rome. Among the key issues discussed was AI and its impact on privacy, particularly in relation to building trustworthy AI systems and protecting children in the context of AI technologies. The Roundtable was hosted by the Italian DPA. The event brought together privacy regulators from Canada, France, Germany, Japan, the UK, the US, and representatives from the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) and the European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS). Read more
The one-stop-shop mechanism in the NIS2 Directive: Guidance for companies on identifying the main establishment
Under the NIS2 Directive, entities that fall within its scope have to register on the Italian National Cybersecurity Agency (ACN) portal. They have to provide the information specified in the Italian Legislative Decree No. 138/2024. And some digital service providers might have to indicate the so-called “main establishment.†In this article, we'll consider what a main establishment is with regard to digital service providers that also operate outside the national territory. They could be the recipients of the so-called “one-stop-shop†mechanism, aimed at streamlining applicable jurisdiction issues for companies. Read more
Intellectual Property
Opting out of training AI with copyrighted material is not unlimited
The Hamburg District Court has limited the opt-out by copyright holders to the use of content for AI training. On 27 September 2024, the District Court of Hamburg issued a significant ruling regarding copyright and the use of AI in a case involving professional photographer Robert Kneschke and the non-profit organization LAION (Large-scale Artificial Intelligence Open Network). Kneschke accused LAION of copyright infringement, asserting that the organization reproduced one of his photographs without authorization to create a dataset for training generative AI systems. Read more
New EU “Design Package†on the protection of industrial designs: Evolution and challenges for the design industry
On 10 October 2024 there was a historic moment for the European design industry. The Council of the European Union approved two key legislative acts under the framework of the “Design Package,†a reform that brings legal protection of industrial designs into new frontiers. This long-awaited regulatory evolution, proposed by the European Commission in 2022, responds to a continuously transforming sector, accelerated by emerging technologies such as AI, 3D printing, and the metaverse. The primary objective? To modernize the regulatory framework and adapt it to the challenges of the present and future. Read more
Food and Beverage
The Court of Justice of the European Union makes landmark decision on “meat soundingâ€
On 4 October 2024, the Court of Justice of the EU (the CJEU) decided case C-438/23 on “meat sounding.†The case concerned the lawfulness of using denominations usually associated with animal products (eg burger, sausage, steak) to designate, market or promote food made from plant proteins or, in any case, other than animal proteins, and the lawfulness of national regulations prohibiting the use of such denominations. Read more
This is a significant leap for AI technology! Understanding the legal landscape surrounding these advancements is essential. I’m excited to read your thoughts on the potentials and challenges!
Great insights on the potential of advanced AI agents! While their ability to transform interactions with technology is exciting, the privacy, security, and legal challenges are equally important.
The potential for AI agents to revolutionize our interactions with technology is undeniable, but as with any powerful tool, it's crucial to address the ethical and legal implications. I particularly agree with the emphasis on privacy and security. As AI agents become more sophisticated, it's imperative to establish robust frameworks to protect user data and prevent malicious use. As AI agents become increasingly autonomous, determining responsibility for their actions becomes more complex. Clear guidelines and regulations are needed to ensure accountability. I believe that international cooperation is essential to address the global challenges posed by AI. By working together, we can develop common standards and regulations that promote innovation while safeguarding human rights and societal values. Giulio Coraggio, thank you for sharing this informative and thought-provoking article.
AI agents are redefining interaction with tech—exciting potential ahead, but legal questions loom.