Shadow Innovators: Celebrating the Hidden Mavericks of the Innovation World

Several years ago I had the opportunity to speak with Dr. Alvin Roth, an amazing human who has saved countless lives around the world. Most people have never heard of Dr. Roth, however in the Economics department of every major university, his name is synonymous with revolutionary advancements in market design that have fundamentally transformed how we approach complex economic systems.

Awarded the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences in 2012, Dr. Roth's groundbreaking contributions, particularly in the development of kidney transplant exchanges, have had a profound impact on an ever growing number of people. However, were it not for the efforts of a relatively unknown ‘insider’, named Dr. Michael Rees who was enlightened enough to see the life-saving genius of Dr. Roth’s vision, his journey to Nobel recognition may have never occurred.?

What is a kidney exchange and why is it important

A kidney exchange is a program where patients who need a kidney but have an incompatible donor (often their family member) can swap donors with other families in the same situation. This allows each patient to receive a compatible kidney, even if their original donor isn’t a match for them. It’s important because it increases the number of successful transplants, reduces waiting times, and helps save lives by making more kidneys available. Here's Dr. Roth explanation in his own words...

Before Dr. Roth's ground breaking work to reimagine the kidney exchange process, patients in need of a kidney transplant had two options: they could either receive a kidney from a living donor who was a direct match or wait for a compatible kidney from a deceased donor. If their willing donor wasn’t a match, the patient would remain on a waiting list, often for years, while relying on dialysis to survive. The system was fundamentally limited by the availability of suitable organs and lengthy wait times, leading to fewer successful transplants. This was a significant market failure so in 2004, Dr. Roth published a seminal paper that suggested a new approach which held the potential to save more lives, but its success hinged upon finding support from respected allies in the medical field.

Dr. Roth’s Journey to the Nobel Prize

In the early stages of his groundbreaking journey, Dr. Roth encountered a significant hurdle that is often a rite of passage for pioneering ideas: skepticism from experts in the field as well as adjacent areas. As he ventured through various academic and medical conferences, Roth passionately presented his innovative concept of creating a more equitable system for kidney transplants, a concept that melded economic theory with practical healthcare needs.

Despite the transformative potential of his ideas, Roth faced a wall of skepticism and dismissal from many medical professionals he engaged with. These experts, entrenched in the traditional methodologies of their field, viewed Roth's approach – a seeming 'outsider's perspective' – with a mix of apprehension and indifference.

This initial resistance highlighted a common yet relatively undiscussed challenge in the world of innovation: the critical role of enlightened insiders in bridging the gap between theoretical brilliance and practical acceptance.

The Crucial Role of Enlightened Insiders

Enlightened insiders are the connectors between the abstract world of innovative ideas and the tangible, often messy, reality of implementation. In the realm of kidney exchanges, for example, these champions were both real-world practitioners and early-adopters – doctors, nurses, and hospital administrators – who understood both the intricacies of the medical world and the potential of innovative ideas to save lives.

A point that Dr. Roth reiterated several times during our conversation:?

“Being able to collaborate with an insider virtually always helps in understanding the strategies available to participants, and the incentives involved.? Understanding how insiders think and the incentive systems they operate under, allows us to figure out (and implement) ways to get around counter-productive incentives to deliver better outcomes.”

Dr. Roth’s work in kidney exchanges demonstrates this perfectly. The theoretical model of a kidney exchange is elegant – it allows patients with willing but incompatible donors to swap donors with another person in a similar predicament. However, the real-world application of this theory required champions within the medical community who could see the potential of this idea and were willing to advocate for it, navigate the ethical complexities, and work through the logistical challenges.

Bridging Gaps and Building Trust

The effectiveness of enlightened insiders lies in their ability to bridge gaps – not only in understanding but in trust. In sensitive areas like organ donation or refugee resettlement, trust is paramount. A point that was reinforced by Dr. Roth as he recounted his first interactions with Dr. Michael Rees:

“Mike remembers our first meeting quite vividly. He tells a story about our first conversation at a conference and he didn't fully appreciate what I was proposing. He thought that I was just interested in maximising the number of transplants, which concerned him [for quality reasons] so he ignored me. However at some point, he says he realised that wasn't the message at all so he came back then we started to talk. Since then, we've been great collaborators.”

Enlightened insiders, by virtue of being part of the system, inherently understand the nuances and concerns of the stakeholders involved. They can communicate the benefits of a new innovation in a way that is both empathetic and convincing, addressing fears and building trust.

In kidney exchanges, enlightened insiders were key in convincing both the medical community and patients about the benefits and ethical soundness of the system. Their advocacy and efforts to maintain transparency and trust were crucial in the program’s growth and success.

Which brings us back to Dr. Michael Rees. As a leading surgeon deeply immersed in the challenges of organ transplantation, Dr. Rees recognized the transformative potential of Roth's economic theories for the field of kidney donations. He acted as a vital conduit between the world of economic theory and medical practice. Dr. Rees not only grasped the intricacies of Roth's models but also understood the practical realities of implementing such a system in the kidney transplantation community. His efforts were pivotal in establishing the first successful kidney exchange program. He worked tirelessly to navigate the complex ethical, logistical, and medical hurdles that such a program entailed, advocating for its adoption within the medical community, liaising with hospitals, and educating other healthcare professionals about the benefits of this innovative approach. Dr. Rees' commitment and expertise were crucial in turning Roth's theoretical solution into a life-saving reality for patients in need of kidney transplants, ultimately contributing to the recognition of Roth’s work with the Nobel Prize.

Looking Ahead: The Future of Enlightened Insiders

As transformative technologies such as robotics, generative AI and brain computer interfaces emerge, the role of enlightened insiders will become even more significant. These technologies, while making our lives easier and our work more efficient, also raise new legal and ethical considerations. Enlightened insiders will be instrumental in navigating these new landscapes, ensuring that the implementation of these technologies is done in a way that is beneficial and just.

These individuals face a daunting uphill battle, balancing a tightrope between groundbreaking ideas and entrenched systems resistant to change. They operate in environments where skepticism is rife, acceptance slow and mockery is rapid. Their journey is marked by constant negotiation, as they must persuade, educate, and sometimes confront established norms and bureaucracies. These insiders are tasked with not only understanding and advocating for novel ideas but also with translating them into actionable plans that fit within existing structures. It requires a unique blend of vision, tenacity, and diplomatic skill, as they work tirelessly behind the scenes, often without significant recognition.

Commenting on the importance of insiders and the need to encourage more of them Dr. Roth observed:

“Market design is a very outward facing part of economics…but what we mostly do is we write papers and writing papers doesn't by itself change the world. Without enlightened insiders, without people who can convince their colleagues that something is good to do, it's very hard to go from the conceptual stage to adoption and implementation. I think all of my successful designs have involved inside champions of some sort. But you don't need just one inside champion. You need inside champions at lots of places, lots of hospitals, lots of countries.”

These individuals are more than just intermediaries; they are innovators, collaborators, and trust-builders who turn theoretical models into life-changing realities. Their perseverance is a testament to their dedication, often driven by a deep belief in the potential of these innovations to effect meaningful change.

As we continue to tackle complex problems in our society, the importance of recognizing and supporting these champions cannot be overstated. They are, in many ways, the unsung heroes of innovation, driving change from within and shaping a better future for us all.

Ways your organization can support inside innovators:

1. Empower with Cross-Organizational Influence: Give insiders a formal role that spans across departments, enabling them to influence and collaborate beyond their immediate team. This creates pathways for them to foster buy-in across the organization and gain allies who can help implement their ideas.
2. Institutionalize Champions Programs: Develop programs that identify and cultivate “innovation champions” with mentoring, cross-functional assignments, and leadership roles in pilot projects. These programs help insiders build credibility and gain institutional support.
3. Integrate Flexible Budgeting for Experimental Projects: Establish a discretionary budget specifically for pilot initiatives led by insiders. This fund should have flexible criteria, allowing champions to pursue high-risk, high-reward ideas without needing extensive approval processes.
4. Sponsor Rotations with External Innovators: Facilitate rotations with startups, research labs, or academic institutions. These experiences broaden the perspectives of insiders, give them exposure to emerging trends, and equip them to bring fresh insights back to the organization.
5. Create “Safe Space” Forums for Strategic Experimentation: Regularly host low-stakes “innovation summits” or ideation sessions where insiders can test and refine ideas with senior leadership, obtaining feedback without pressure. Safe spaces signal openness to experimentation and build trust for transformative initiatives.

[Proudly conceived and researched by a human]