Key Legal Factors for Indian Startups Expanding Overseas

Introduction

Cross-border investing has become increasingly common in recent years, with investors looking beyond their home countries for new opportunities and startups seeking capital globally. As with any complex financial transaction, cross-border investments carry legal considerations that investors and startups should understand before proceeding.

This article provides an overview of the key legal aspects of cross-border investing, with a focus on investments into Indian startups. We'll examine the relevant laws and regulations, investment structuring, due diligence, documentation, approvals, post-investment considerations, and dispute resolution. Recent developments and trends impacting cross-border investments into India will also be discussed.

The goal is to provide investors and startups with a high-level understanding of the legal framework for cross-border investments, so they can make informed decisions and avoid potential pitfalls. While not exhaustive, the information presented should help readers identify areas that require more in-depth legal analysis based on the specifics of a deal.

Key Laws and Regulations

Foreign investments into Indian startups need to comply with various laws and regulations governing cross-border transactions. Some key considerations from legal and regulatory perspective are:

i. FDI Policies

• The FDI policy issued by the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT) regulates foreign investment into different sectors. Startups can raise foreign capital under the automatic route in most sectors barring few exceptions like e-commerce, multi-brand retail etc.
• Conditions like sectoral caps, pricing guidelines etc may apply for foreign investment. The FDI policy needs to be checked to ensure compliance.

ii. Taxation Laws

• Income tax laws like withholding taxes on capital gains, interest, dividends, royalty etc. need compliance. The Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) with the source country may provide beneficial tax rates.
• Goods and Service Tax (GST) may apply on transactions between Indian startups and foreign investors. Appropriate GST registration may be required.

iii. Exchange Control Regulations

• The foreign exchange management regulations notified by the Reserve Bank of India contain various requirements relating to foreign investment like mode, instruments, reporting etc.
• Regulations pertaining to overseas listing, foreign currency expenses, and repatriation also need to be checked.
• Compliance around valuation, share issuance, and filings is important before accepting foreign investment.

Proper structuring and compliance with these laws is critical for startups while raising capital from overseas investors. Regulatory requirements may also apply post-investment.

Structuring Investments

When making cross-border investments, one of the most important considerations is how to structure the investment. The choice of investment vehicle can have significant legal, tax, and operational implications. Some key factors to consider when structuring cross-border investments include:

Types of Investment Vehicles

• Equity investment - Investing directly into the equity share capital of a company. This gives the investor ownership and control rights. Equity investments carry higher risk but allow the investor to benefit from future profits and exit via an IPO or trade sale.
• Convertible instruments - Investing via convertible debt, SAFE notes, or preferred equity that converts into common shares in the future based on certain triggers. This allows the investor to initially take lower risk while retaining the option to convert to equity later.
• Joint venture - Forming a separate legal entity jointly owned by the investor and startup. The JV can sign commercial agreements with the startup to license IP, provide services, etc.
• Limited Partnership - The investor contributes as a limited partner to a venture capital or private equity fund that then invests into startups. This allows diversification but the investor has limited control.

Implications for Foreign Investors

When structuring cross-border investments, foreign investors need to consider factors such as:

• Tax implications in the home and host countries. The choice of investment vehicle can impact tax treatment.
• Repatriation of profits, investment returns, dividends, etc. Remittance may be subject to caps or restrictions.
• Exchange rate risks if investment is made in foreign currency.
• Regulatory approvals required in host country for foreign investment under FDI rules. Investment vehicle may impact approval process.
• Rights and protections granted to foreign investors under local laws and applicable treaties.
• Eligibility for incentives or tax exemptions offered to foreign investors.
• Opinions from legal counsel in both jurisdictions to ensure compliance.

The appropriate investment vehicle depends on the specific objectives, constraints, timeline, and risk appetite of the foreign investor. Consulting experts to structure the investment optimally is highly recommended.

Due Diligence

Conducting thorough due diligence is a critical part of any cross-border investment. The key areas investors should review include:

• Financial records - Review the startup's financial statements, tax returns, outstanding debts/liabilities, sources of revenue, profitability, cash flow, and projections. Look for any red flags or inconsistencies.
• Business model - Understand the startup's business model, products/services, competitive advantages, market validation, growth potential, and risks. Assess the startup's ability to scale and expand globally.
• Management team - Evaluate the background, skills, and experience of the founders and key executives. Gauge their leadership abilities, integrity, and commitment.
• Legal compliance - Verify the startup is compliant with all relevant laws and regulations in its home country as well as in target markets. Watch for issues like data privacy, IP protection, and local employment laws.
• Technical assets - Review any patents, trademarks, proprietary technology or IP held by the startup. Ensure ownership is clearly established.
• Third party risks - Look into relationships with vendors, partners, and other third parties that may impact the investment.
• Regulatory risks - Consider legal, tax, currency exchange, and other regulatory risks associated with cross-border investments into the startup's jurisdiction.

Thorough due diligence takes time but is essential to avoid costly surprises later. It helps investors identify red flags and make an informed decision about the risks and potential of the investment. Overlooking due diligence can expose investors to major liabilities down the road.

Documentation

The key legal agreements involved in cross-border investing include the term sheet, share purchase agreement, shareholders' agreement, and subscription agreement. These agreements contain important provisions that protect the interests of both the investor and the startup.

Key Agreements

• Term Sheet: This non-binding agreement sets out the key commercial terms between the investor and startup, such as the amount to be invested, valuation, shareholding percentage, liquidation preference, special rights, etc. It forms the basis for definitive agreements.
• Share Purchase Agreement (SPA): The SPA is the main legal contract for the investment. It specifies terms like the number of shares to be purchased, the price per share, closing conditions, representations and warranties, indemnities, etc.
• Shareholders' Agreement: This agreement between startup shareholders and investors specifies the rights of investors like board seats, voting rights, ROFR, anti-dilution provisions, transfer restrictions, exit rights, etc. It governs the relationship between shareholders.
• Subscription Agreement: This agreement is signed by the investor to subscribe to the startup's shares. It includes subscriber details, subscription amount, share capital information, and representation of the investor having reviewed all relevant documents.

Representations and Warranties

The SPA contains representations and warranties from the startup founders/promoters regarding the company's legal status, financial position, assets, intellectual property, compliance with laws, litigation status, etc. This gives comfort to the investor regarding the startup's condition. If any representation is inaccurate, the investor can claim indemnification. Key representations include:

• Compliance with applicable laws
• Legal validity of shares being issued
• Accuracy of financial statements
• Ownership of assets and intellectual property
• Absence of undisclosed liabilities
• Absence of litigation
• Payment of taxes
• Corporate authority to enter into the investment

The representations form the basis for the investor's decision to invest, so the startup founders have to make them to the best of their knowledge. Their accuracy is key to avoiding disputes later.

Deal Approval

The deal approval process for cross-border investments into Indian startups involves obtaining necessary government approvals. This is an important consideration for foreign investors as it impacts deal timelines.

The key government approvals required include:

• Approval from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) under the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA) for foreign direct investment (FDI). The RBI approval is required for investment transactions that result in foreign ownership exceeding specified sectoral caps.
• Approval from the relevant administrative ministry or department. For example, for investment in sectors like telecom, insurance, banking, a no-objection certificate would be required from the respective regulator.
• Registration of the investment with the RBI within 30 days of receipt of funds. This reporting requirement applies to all FDI transactions.
• Approvals from tax authorities may be needed in case of special tax exemptions or benefits claimed by the investee company.

The time required for obtaining these approvals depends on the sector and proposed foreign ownership level. RBI approval for automatic route sectors can be obtained in 2-3 weeks. Approvals for government route sectors take longer, around 8-10 weeks. Timelines for administrative ministry approvals also vary across sectors.

Hence, investors should factor in the approval timelines while planning their investment into Indian startups. The investee companies should identify the approvals required and initiate the process well in advance. This will help avoid delays in deal closure. Proper planning and management of the approval process is key for successful cross-border investment transactions.

Post-investment Considerations

Once the investment has been made, there are a number of ongoing legal considerations for both the investor and the startup. These include:

a. Ongoing Compliance

• The investor will want to ensure the startup remains compliant with all applicable laws and regulations in the jurisdictions in which it operates. This includes things like corporate governance, accounting standards, labor laws, data protection regulations, etc. The investor may require periodic reporting from the startup to monitor compliance.
• The startup will also need to comply with any specific requirements laid out in the investment agreements, such as restrictions on taking on additional debt or issuing more shares. Failure to comply could trigger defaults under the agreements.

b. Reporting Requirements

• Most investment deals will require the startup to provide regular financial and operating reports to the investor. This keeps the investor informed on the performance and progress of the startup.
• The specific reporting requirements are usually detailed in the term sheet or investment agreement. This includes content, frequency, and delivery method for the reports.
• Accurate and timely reporting is essential to maintaining a healthy ongoing investor-startup relationship. Lack of transparency can erode trust between the parties.

c. Exit Considerations

• Investors will eventually seek to exit their investment and realize returns. The method and timeline for exit should be considered early on.
• Common exit mechanisms include IPOs, acquisitions, secondary sales, and buybacks. The applicable exit rights are typically negotiated upfront.
• Things like drag-along and tag-along rights impact the investor's ability to force a certain exit outcome. Founders will want to pay close attention to the fine print around exits.
• Tax implications also come into play upon exit, especially for cross-border investments. Navigating local tax laws across multiple jurisdictions can get complicated.
• Having clear exit strategy alignment between investors and founders from the start helps avoid problems down the road.

Dispute Resolution

When cross-border deals go awry, resolving disputes can be complex. Key considerations around dispute resolution for India-based startups making overseas investments include:

Applicable Laws

• Determining which laws apply is a first step. This depends on factors like where the investment entities are located and incorporated, which courts have jurisdiction, and the dispute resolution methods specified in investment documents.
• Indian laws vs laws of the country where the investment is made can apply. Some key Indian laws relevant to cross-border disputes include the Indian Contract Act, Arbitration and Conciliation Act, and Code of Civil Procedure.
• International laws may also apply such as the United Nations Convention on International Settlement Agreements Resulting from Mediation.

Methods of Dispute Resolution

• Litigation in national courts is one route, but can be slow and expensive across borders.
• International commercial arbitration has risen in popularity. Arbitration clauses are often included in investment documents, specifying arbitration venues, governing law, etc. This private dispute resolution method offers binding outcomes without the same procedural complexities of court litigation.
• Mediation is a third option, which aims for negotiated settlement through a neutral mediator. Cross-border mediation is still evolving in usage.
• Enforcement of foreign rulings or arbitration awards in local courts also poses challenges that need to be considered. Overall, selecting appropriate dispute resolution methods requires strategic planning during investment structuring.

Recent Developments

The landscape for cross-border investing in India has evolved rapidly in recent years due to several regulatory changes and market trends. Here are some of the key recent developments:

Regulatory Changes

• The Indian government relaxed foreign direct investment (FDI) norms across several sectors including e-commerce, single-brand retail, contract manufacturing, and coal mining. This has opened up new opportunities for foreign investors.
• The RBI increased the aggregate limit for overseas investments by Indian mutual funds from $7 billion to $15 billion. This enables greater outbound investments by Indian funds.
• SEBI simplified know-your-customer (KYC) requirements for foreign investors. PAN is now the single identifier for participating in the Indian securities market.
• Dispute resolution through international arbitration was enabled for FPI investments, boosting investor confidence.

Trends and Outlook

• India is projected to receive over $120-160 billion in inbound FDI over the next 5 years based on rising investor interest.
• Investments in technology startups and digital businesses are surging as India undergoes rapid digital transformation.
• Sectors like renewable energy, infrastructure, manufacturing, and real estate are attracting major investments under India's nation-building initiatives.
• Global liquidity, India's growth prospects, and reforms momentum make India an attractive investment destination compared to other emerging markets.
• Geopolitical shifts like US-China trade tensions are also redirecting investments into India's large consumer market.
• Initiatives like Make in India, Digital India, and Startup India continue boosting investor sentiment.

The interplay of favorable regulations and market trends points towards a promising outlook for cross-border investments into India.

Conclusion

Cross-border investing comes with complex legal considerations, but careful planning and diligence can mitigate the risks. The key takeaways are:

• Laws and regulations governing foreign investment differ across jurisdictions. Investors must research rules on ownership structures, profit repatriation, taxes, and other issues.
• Thoughtful deal structuring is important, factoring in tax implications, investor rights, and exit strategies. Using intermediaries like venture capital funds can simplify things.
• Extensive due diligence on the target company is essential before finalizing any investment. This covers areas like financials, operations, contracts, intellectual property, licenses, litigation, and regulatory compliance.
• Proper documentation must memorialize the investment terms and shareholders' rights. Shareholder and subscription agreements are crucial to align stakeholder interests.
• Robust approval processes should be followed on both investor and recipient sides before closing deals. This provides checks and balances.
• Ongoing monitoring of portfolio companies is needed to protect shareholder value. Shareholder rights must be exercised vigilantly.
• Disputes are best avoided but may still arise despite proper planning. Arbitration clauses and choice of law provisions in agreements are advisable for resolving conflicts efficiently.

Legal aspects are integral to successful cross-border investing. Conducting comprehensive due diligence and structuringwatertight legal agreements will enable investors to manage risks and make smart investment decisions.

Subscribe this newsletter and follow Legal Suvidha? and First Unicorn ?? ? to get more updates about exciting startups where you can invest and if you are a startup having a great vision/mission and solving a big problem connect with us for funding opportunities.

If you are planning to launch your Startup, read my Free e-book here: https://growsocio.com/product/e-book-launch-like-a-pro-the-mvp-method-for-startup-success/