Kenya vs Avic International
The Full Summary is published The Academy of Tax Law :
Case Information:
Judgment Summary
The Tax Appeals Tribunal in Kenya ruled on the case involving AVIC International Beijing (EA) Limited (Appellant) and the Commissioner of Domestic Taxes (Respondent) concerning disputed tax assessments covering Corporation Tax, PAYE, and Withholding Tax (WHT) for the years 2016 to 2023. The Respondent issued an audit notice on 30 July 2021 and finalized its assessments on 29 June 2023, leading to additional tax liabilities of Kshs. 530,528,802, later reduced to Kshs. 514,154,336 after objections.
Key disputes included the appropriateness of the Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM) as the most appropriate method (MAM) for transfer pricing adjustments, the accuracy of income assessments based on VAT discrepancies, and the double taxation claims related to PAYE and WHT on expatriates and seconded personnel. AVIC argued that the Resale Price Method (RPM) was more suitable given the nature of its transactions and that TNMM overcomplicated the analysis. Further, the Appellant contended that certain assessments extended beyond the statutory five-year limit.
The Tribunal upheld the use of TNMM as the most reliable method under the OECD Guidelines, noting deficiencies in AVIC’s benchmarking and FAR analysis. However, it recognized procedural errors in assessing income discrepancies and PAYE liabilities. The Tribunal dismissed claims of double taxation and ruled on the validity of deemed dividend taxes based on adjustments.
The judgment highlighted the importance of comprehensive compliance with transfer pricing documentation and functional analysis to mitigate disputes, emphasizing adherence to procedural guidelines.
READ THE REST OF THE SUMMARY HERE (INCLUDING ALL THE POINTS BELOW):
Key Points of the Judgment
1. Background
2. Core Dispute
3. Court Findings
4. Outcome
Transfer Pricing Method Used
领英推荐
Major Issues or Areas of Contention
Was This Decision Expected or Controversial?
Significance for Multinationals
Significance for Revenue Services
Similar Cases for Review
This is a reminder that applications for our Postgraduate Programmes are now open for the March 2025 intake.
Postgraduate Programmes in Transfer Pricing:
APPLICATIONS NOW BEING ACCEPTED (Closes End of March 2025)
Postgraduate Programmes in International Taxation:
APPLICATIONS NOW BEING ACCEPTED (Closes End of March 2025)
Postgraduate Programmes in South African Tax Law:
APPLICATIONS NOW BEING ACCEPTED (Closes End of March 2025)
Have some questions about the programmes?
Please don't hesitate to contact our Education Consultant, Ben Ellis, at [email protected] or call us at +44(0)2080522710.