Just Say No- When the best communications strategy is to shut up

When Prince Andrew sat down for an extended interview with the BBC’s Emily Maitlis, it was one of the “gets” of the year. Great for Maitlis and her program.  Not so great for the House of Windsor. 

Not since King Charles I rose in his own defence at his trial in 1649 has royal oratory met with such calamity.  Charles lost his crown and his head.  The Duke of York was yanked from public duties and his mother cancelled his 60th birthday party, leaving him physically intact but exposed as an insensitive toff.  

As a former reporter my default position is to advise clients to do interviews, even in times of crisis, reasoning that it is always better to tell your own story rather than have others tell it for you. 

But there are exceptions. In Andrew’s case it was a glaring, five-alarm-fire, nuclear meltdown exception.   There are times when a face to face interview is going to be a no-win scenario.  Perhaps the journalist is known to be aggressive and is likely to roast the client. Other times the story is just so negative and the answers to the likely questions so weak that it is best to decline.  So it should have been with Prince Andrew. 

In those situations, the only alternative is to put out a statement with the best available message, keep one’s royal trap shut and do not add fuel to the fire.  Other people facing such a negative story might risk being ambushed by a reporter and camera, but even the proudly bumptious British news media are unlikely to “doorstep” a royal.  

Given that his PR director resigned not long before the interview, it is reasonable to surmise that the prince was indeed advised to decline but relied on his own flawed instincts and inflated sense of brilliance to believe he could clear up everything through a chat with a formidable interrogator on national television.  His flak no doubt threw up his hands and left rather than be a party to the catastrophe to come. 

The Duke of York has a record of showing a tin ear to public perceptions and a high sense of entitlement, even for a royal.  He was dubbed “Air Miles Andy” for having helicopters carry him over the commoners stuck in traffic to convey him to nearby engagements.  Along with his friendship with the vile sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, his propensity for cozying up to autocrats and crooks had already caused The Firm much embarrassment. 

He displayed similar wisdom both in accepting the interview and in his performance. 

BBC Newsnight has a long tradition of no-holds-barred interviews, with hosts known for interrupting, badgering and at times verging on verbal torture of guests.  But Maitlis sagely chose to remain calm, polite and devastatingly focused, never more so than when Andrew said: “Do I regret the fact that he has quite obviously conducted himself in a manner unbecoming? Yes.”  At which Maitlis narrowed her eyes and pointedly responded, “Unbecoming? He’s a sex offender”.

"Yeah, I'm sorry, I'm being polite," harrumphed the hapless prince, his already damaged reputation now disappearing down the toilet.  

In times of crisis, we counsel clients to be guided by the principles of empathy, responsibility and transparency.  He failed on all three.   

No empathy for Epstein’s victims, no responsibility for his actions and no transparency in his slippery answers.  His only expressed regret was for “letting down the team”.  

But his largest mistake was in not saying no to the interview. Unlike his ancestor Charles I, he gets to keep his head, but his punishment will be to live out his remaining days with a ruined reputation.  


Kimberley A.G. Bates, BJ, APR

Communications, Public Affairs, Governance, Public Speaker

5 年

Totally with you on this one Sean. When I first shifted to the comms?biz I always advised?"never say no comment", but when one is so hapless as the Prince,?turning down the interview would have been a much better option.?Can't blame that advisor. There are better ways to communicate a response.?

回复
Tony Chapman

Conference Host, Speaker and Moderator. 3 X Hall of Fame Inductee Host of Chatter that Matters Podcast / Founding Partner Chatter AI

5 年
回复
Tony Chapman

Conference Host, Speaker and Moderator. 3 X Hall of Fame Inductee Host of Chatter that Matters Podcast / Founding Partner Chatter AI

5 年

great picture to go with a great article @Sean Mallen

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Sean Mallen的更多文章

  • The Banker Politician Must Learn the Game, and Fast

    The Banker Politician Must Learn the Game, and Fast

    Mark Carney is an impressive man with an unmatchable resume. Longtime lured by lustful Liberals seeking a saviour from…

    18 条评论
  • The Sound of Silence

    The Sound of Silence

    It was a roaring silence. 21 seconds of natural sound outside Rideau Cottage, punctuated by occasional bird song, a…

  • Sick Talk-How Untrustworthy Communications makes the Pandemic Worse

    Sick Talk-How Untrustworthy Communications makes the Pandemic Worse

    There are not many issues where an effective, believable communications strategy is a matter of life or death. COVID-19…

  • The Emperor Had No Answers

    The Emperor Had No Answers

    The post-mortems on Michael Bloomberg's epically awful debate performance naturally turned to his preparation. Did he…

  • No need to panic, but...

    No need to panic, but...

    Like many people across Ontario, my Sunday had a disquieting start. We woke up to a Province of Ontario Emergency Alert…

    6 条评论
  • Answer the Question

    Answer the Question

    “Do the right thing. It will gratify some people and astonish the rest.

  • When Key Messages Aren't Enough

    When Key Messages Aren't Enough

    Advisors to Ontario Education Minister Lisa Thompson must have thought long and hard before agreeing to book her for an…

    9 条评论
  • Falling for London in Vancouver

    Falling for London in Vancouver

    Hey Vancouver, hope to see many friends and colleagues this Tuesday evening March 19 at Book Warehouse, 4118 Main St…

  • Bringing London to Alberta

    Bringing London to Alberta

    It's been a terrific return to Alberta to talk about Falling for London. Sue Deyall and Gord Gillies were kind enough…

  • Launching Falling for London

    Launching Falling for London

    An incredible, memorable night. Thanks so much to UK High Commissioner to Canada Susan le Jeune d'Allegeershecque and…

    3 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了