Just How Important is a Filter?

Just How Important is a Filter?

All too often chemicals are blamed for poor water quality when in fact the root cause is more often than not, insufficient filtration. If a domestic pool owner only runs their pool pump for a few hours a day, they are relying far too much on the disinfectant (e.g. chlorine) in the water to keep the pool safe, clean and crystal clear. Moving water is safe water! This also applies to public swimming pools. The more filtration and circulation of the water the better the quality will be and the easier it will be to maintain. It is important to ensure that the water passes through the filter media at the right speed. Too fast and any captured debris is pushed through the media and back to the pool. The slower the water passes through, the better and more efficient the media will be. In fact, if you simply half the speed at which the water passes, you will increase the filter efficiency by 4 times. Beware, if you reduce the speed of the pump, you will ultimately slow down the circulation of the water in the pool tank. This can result in dead spots with bacteria and algae taking hold. Unless a filter with a larger surface area can be installed, you may need to compromise with variable speeds to achieve a slower filtration speed for part of the day and increase the speed for the rest of the day to maintain good circulation.

What goes in, must come out. The purpose of the filter is to capture any physical debris from the water. This debris builds up over time to the extent that it will reduce the performance of the media and begin to block up. This is why the backwash process is just as important as is achieving an efficient filtration speed. What ever the media used, it’s important to get fluidisation of the media bed in order to release all the captured debris. According to German DIN standard, where sand is used as a filter media, the required speed for backwash is 60m/h (m3/m2/h). This requires a lot of water and also will not guarantee a break up of the ‘mud balling’ than occurs in sand. The result of an insufficient backwash is the reduction of filtration efficiency. Captured debris remain in the filter, harbouring bacteria and increasing the demand on the disinfectant used. It’s at this point that the water quality starts to suffer.

A more efficient backwash can be achieve at a slower backwash speed when glass media is used instead of sand. This stands to reason as glass is lighter than sand in weight so, less forces are required to achieve the same lift. We would recommend a speed of 45m/h to get the required fluidity. However, not all glass media will give the same filtration and/or backwash performance. The shape, size and colour of glass media available on the market vary considerably. Some are very round, almost sphere like. I liken this spherical media to the plastic balls you find in kids play pits. You can quite easily push your hand right through them. This demonstrates a lack of mechanical performance although I understand that it works well at very slow speeds in grey water applications. Other glass media are quite flat, a bit like piling coins on top of one another and will block up a filter very quickly resulting in the need for more frequent backwashing. Most will still be prone to ‘mud balling’ and encourage bacteria growth but, not to the same extent as sand.

AFM (Activated Filter Media) has been engineered to a specific shape and size and is available in various grades. It has been independently tested by IFTS (Institut de la Filtration et des Techniques Séparatives) out performing other medias. Because it is made from specially selected green and brown glass, the raw material already has a certain ionic charge to it. No other coloured glass carries an ionic charge at these levels. The charge is enhanced with further heat treatment and chemical processes. As a result, the surface of AFM is bio-resistant. No ‘mud balling’ can occur and bacteria cannot reach its surface. Captured debris is released very quickly during even the shortest of backwashes, resulting in huge reductions in water consumption and savings on heating for replacement backwash water. Disinfection demand is greatly reduced thus resulting in less disinfection by-products which, in turn results in a safer, more pleasant environment for bathers.

So, just like in the ’Pyramid of Pool Water Treatment’, if you get the foundation correct in the first instance with the correct dimensioning of the filter vessel, the correct flow rate, correct backwash speeds, the best filter media and you simply eliminate future water quality problems significantly.

Fabian Stark

3D depth filtration - flexible, efficient, sustainable - Let us do the clean-up! OPEX savings up to 75%!

1 年

The most important thing is always the filtration, because after all the impurities should be removed from the water. Merely disinfecting would mean that these impurities remain in the water and sediment. All heavy ordinary filter media, no matter what size, create friction inside the filter housing and with the introduction of impurities, the filter media itself becomes a problem, because it grinds flies, leaves, flowers, feathers, pollen, etc., which leads to more smaller impurities in the micrometer range. This in turn promotes biofouling and as a result clumping in the filter bed. Only a very strong backwash with additional air flushing can make a difference here, but this device has only a few, and is unnecessary. Once the filter bed is clumped, idle channels form through which the water to be filtered is led back to the pool unhindered. If, on the other hand, you use a lightweight and advanced weaving technology, you not only have a filter medium that is 100 times lighter, which makes maintenance extremely fast, but also a filter material that is 100 times more efficient than sand, i.e. the separation efficiency is up to 100 times better than sand. Savings of 50% disinfectant and 95% flocculant, and 40% energy.

Simon Spragg

Small Business Owner at Techpools

1 年

There is so much truth here. The industry knows this still persists in proclaiming "salt electrolysis" as some form of miracle non maintenance cure of all swimming pool woes. Actually electric shock of a sodium chloride to produce CL2 a dangerous gas is just a crazy way of producing liquid chlorine... It does not address the saturation index, in fact hinders it. When all the time filtration and circulation are the vital elements 24/7 - 365 days a year. Programmed considered flow rates depending on bather load, environmental conditions, heated and or covered pools. Of course chemical treatment is vital but the chemistry must be constantly circulating in order to maintain balance...

Peter Bonner

BonZiBlu StillWaterWorx - freelance Innovator, designer, problem solver,and inventor in the swimming pool market. Revising the filtration process to simplify pool maintenance; reducing chemical, power and Water wastage

1 年

Jimmy, I agree 100% with you statements on the importance of good filtration and circulation. So too, according to Mr Venturi et al, what goes in, must come out. Pressure and velocity change but VOLUME stays the same. A filter using sand, glass or cubes (I can’t speak for specifically coloured glass, as if it would make a difference) will build up “mud-balls”, irrespective of the length of time you backwash. This is not taught in Swimpool maintenance 101. These”mud-balls” create eddies inside the filter, and since water takes the path of least resistance, water flowing through on filter and Backwash modes will NEVER be done successfully unless these “mud-ball” are removed REGULARLY through a manual sand wash. Even then, some of the “mud-ball” material remains, and quickly gather together to create the same problem. These problems are usually addressed by pool owners with expensive chemicals and is very time consuming. I am sure you have heard that pool maintenance is a lot of work, a million times. The key to this is simple - if you own a BonZiBlu Filter Friend. The Filter Friend shortens the backwash process with a rinse almost just a formality. Water used - less than 50 gallons. Wonder what the IFTS will say about this.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Jimmy Lamb FISPE的更多文章

  • AFM and PWTAG Guidance

    AFM and PWTAG Guidance

    I often get asked questions by installers or end users who are considering a swap from sand to AFM, “where does AFM sit…

    3 条评论
  • Stop installing 1?” pipe! By Jimmy Lamb FISPE & John Cheek FISPE Dip MRSPH

    Stop installing 1?” pipe! By Jimmy Lamb FISPE & John Cheek FISPE Dip MRSPH

    Jimmy Lamb: Why is that time and time again, I see images on social media of pool companies installing two main drains…

    1 条评论
  • When is a 24" Filter not a 24" Filter?

    When is a 24" Filter not a 24" Filter?

    When you check the size of a filter in a suppliers catalogue, you will notice that the diameter (o/d) of the filter is…

  • A Square Peg Through a Round Hole

    A Square Peg Through a Round Hole

    When it comes to installing a domestic pool filtration system, why is it that so often I’m seeing 1 ?” (d50mm) diameter…

    3 条评论
  • John Lamb & CPC, the history as remembered by Jimmy Lamb

    John Lamb & CPC, the history as remembered by Jimmy Lamb

    Following in the footsteps of my Dad John Lamb, I entered the Pool industry in late 1999. Some might say that I was…

    6 条评论
  • Do You Need Automatic Dosing & Control Equipment?

    Do You Need Automatic Dosing & Control Equipment?

    Manual Dosing of chemicals directly into a commercial pool presents a number of risks. A commercial pool is a leisure…

  • BISHTA Press Release - Aug. 2018

    BISHTA Press Release - Aug. 2018

    Wood-fired (Scandinavian-type) hot tubs used in holiday parks (Business Settings) BISHTA issues the following advice…

    1 条评论
  • Why Such Basic Water Treatment?

    Why Such Basic Water Treatment?

    Why is it that all too often I come across pools that must have cost hundreds of thousands of pounds to build, then…

    1 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了