?? Judge Criticizes Home Office Errors in Palestinian Refugee’s Visa Case
City of London Solicitors
Expert Legal Solutions 'Simplified' - Family and Immigration Solicitors in the heart of London
The Home Secretary extends a sincere apology to Amena El Ashkar, a Palestinian refugee, for serious errors in her student visa application. Despite receiving a full scholarship for a PhD at the London School of Economics (LSE) as a Chevening scholar, she was denied a visa by the Home Office.
?? Critical Judgment:
- The Upper Tribunal criticized the Home Office for its "shockingly poor" and "seriously flawed" handling of the visa application, citing a "litany of errors."
- The decision not to notify Ashkar of the visa refusal certification by the former Home Secretary, Suella Braverman, was deemed "deliberate" and "unlawful."
?? Legal Challenge:
- Ashkar, a stateless Palestinian raised in a refugee camp in Lebanon, faced emotional turmoil due to the visa denial.
- Despite being awarded the Chevening scholarship by the Foreign Office, the Home Office rejected her visa application, stating her presence in the UK wasn't "conducive to the public good."
?? Judicial Review:
- The failure to inform the tribunal of the certification decision led to a legal challenge brought before the wrong court.
- Despite the "grave situation" highlighted by the judge, contempt of court proceedings were not initiated.
?? Fresh Decision:
领英推荐
- Home Secretary James Cleverly expressed willingness to reconsider Ashkar's visa application in light of the errors.
?? Response from Ashkar:
- Ashkar expressed her dismay and confusion, particularly as a Palestinian refugee, questioning the reasons behind the decision.
?? Legal Representation:
- Ashkar's lawyer emphasized the contradiction between being awarded a prestigious scholarship and the visa rejection without explanation.
?? Official Statement:
- The Home Office refrained from commenting on individual cases, citing longstanding government policy.
?? Current Status:
- Ashkar, currently working as a research assistant in Qatar, remains hopeful of obtaining the visa to pursue her PhD at LSE.
Amidst challenges in immigration processes, transparency and accountability remain paramount for ensuring fair treatment of applicants.?
?