Job seekers beware! You might be applying to a "ghost job"

Job seekers beware! You might be applying to a "ghost job"

You probably know it well: The exhausting, soul-crushing, crazy-making pursuit known as the modern day job search.?

Gen Z has been particularly vocal on social media about putting in hundreds of applications with no success, and it’s not uncommon anymore for recruiters or hiring managers to simply never respond to a prospective candidate.?

But the job search landscape is even more harrowing for a more nefarious reason, according to a new study. Around 81% of recruiters admit to posting “ghost jobs”—positions that are either already filled, or completely fabricated.??

“We often hear job-seekers saying, ‘I'm tired, I'm depressed, I'm desperate,’ using these very harsh words when it comes to the job market,” Jasmine Escalera, a career expert for MyPerfectResume which conducted the study, told my colleague Emma Burleigh . “This is one of the reasons why they are losing faith in organizations and companies.”

And the problem is widespread. Out of recruiters overall, a whopping 17% say that around 75% of their job postings are fake, and 21.5% say that’s true for half of their postings. That takes up a lot of real estate on job boards, with job seekers putting in resume after resume in good faith to companies that have no plans to take their application seriously.?

So why do it??

There are a few different reasons, including building a talent pool and getting a temperature check on the current job market. But keeping up appearances is a major motivator.

“Companies are trying to project ‘We're okay, we're still maintaining hiring, that we're still moving in a growth-oriented trend. In this market, our organization is doing well,’” says Escalera.?

So job seekers beware! The system is stacked against you, though that’s cold comfort during months or even years-long search. And as for recruiters: Think twice before posting a ghost job—and try to be part of the solution.?

You can read the full story here .?

Leadership Tip of the Week ??

The soul of a company is a fragile thing, and REI is learning that the hard way, writes my colleague Phil Wahba . It’s been hemorrhaging money for two years, but employees are afraid its famous backpacker-friendly culture will suffer as leaders focus on boosting profits.

Leadership Next


If you shop on the internet, you’ve probably seen?Klarna—and its buy-now, pay-later installment offers—when shopping at major retailers like?Bloomingdale's,?Foot Locker,?or Sephora. The company’s plans allow shoppers to?break up purchases into four equal payments,?with no interest.

Klarna CEO Sebastian Siemiatkowski says installment plans fill a gap in the market, allowing customers some payment flexibility without the interest and fees found with typical credit cards.

But Klarna does much more than just installments. On this week’s episode of Leadership Next, Michal and Diane Brady talk to Siemiatkowski about Klarna’s early adoption of AI, why the company also offers credit cards, and its growth plans.

Listen to the episode and subscribe to Leadership Next wherever you listen to podcasts, or read the full transcript here.

Those are our biggest leadership stories of the week.

Thanks for reading and make sure to subscribe to Fortune's Next To Lead newsletter to learn everything you need to know to make it to the corner office.

-Azure Gilman , Fortune’s Deputy Leadership Editor

Amy Forsythe

Author | Journalist | Keynote Speaker | Podcast Host | Non-Profit & Community Connector | USMC Veteran | U.S. Navy Reserve Public Affairs Officer

2 个月

“Ghost jobs” are real but what brands don’t realize is that potential employees are often customers, too. If your applicants feel they are being ghosted, they’ll most likely sour on your product or service and tell their friends that your company’s hiring practices are shady, leave a bad reviews and dissuade others from doing business with you.

Laura S.

Leadership | International Development | Policy | Management | Advocacy

2 个月

I’m hearing this from multiple sources, and seeing many companies who-despite hundreds of applicants-repost the same job dozens of times and never seem to hire for it. Apparently they do it to look good to investors and/or to motivate current employees.

回复
Samuel Bodak

Sustainable Management Strategist

2 个月

Useful tips, I even either got replies, and wonder why is that...even calling the provided phone number

回复
Jason Braun M.Ed., MA, CSM

Instructional Designer l Coach | Author of Designing Context-Rich Learning by Extending Reality | Featured in The Chronicle of Higher Education, The Riverfront Times, ESPN.com, and more | Thriving with ADHD and Dyslexia

3 个月

Someone needs to do something about this. By someone I mean me. And by something, I mean a plan so extreme and so absurd that they’ll never see it coming. Or like notice after it does.

回复
JANET W.

Clinical Pharmacy Technician @ Tri-City Community Health | PTCB Certified Pharmacy Technician

3 个月

Several of my own co-workers & friends have recently brought this practice to my attention and I find it to be detestable. The people who choose to create these "ghost" jobs have obviously never considered how damaging it could be to the psyche of the job seeker who is putting in a serious effort to look for work, yet cannot seem to find anything. As a manager, I have often heard other managers complain that no one wants to work anymore or that they cannot find qualified candidates for open positions. It would be interesting to know the percentage of impact that "ghosting" job postings has had on the ability to find said candidates.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Fortune的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了