Millennials Are Not Job-Hopping (And That's A Bad Thing)
If you do an Internet search, you might think that job hopping is on the rise, particularly among self-obsessed, entitled millennials who spend more time taking selfies at bars with their friends than figuring out what they want to do with their lives.
Yet, when you look at the cold, hard facts, the exact opposite is true. In fact, millennials – and workers across the board – are more loyal than they have been in some time.
And that’s not necessarily a good thing, at least for workers.
Don’t believe me? Look at this chart published in The Washington Post, which shows that millennials have stayed at their jobs longer than any time since 1983:
Still don’t believe me? Here’s another chart from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, which shows that in the past decade, workers are staying at their jobs longer, not shorter:
What this chart says is that the typical worker in 2004 spent four years at their company. In 2014, that number jumped to 4.6 years, a 15 percent increase in loyalty.
Why Is Job Hopping Declining?
So what really causes job hopping? What causes people to go from one job to another?
There’s always going to be a part of it that stems from people changing their minds about their careers. But if history has taught us anything, it’s that human nature has stayed relatively stable over the past 10,000 years or so, so the percentage of chronic job hoppers in the world probably is the same as it always was.
No, what really causes “job hopping” is amount of job opportunity out there. After all, if there are a lot of new jobs being created with higher salaries and better chances for advancement, logic suggests more people will take those jobs, leaving their old ones behind.
So what is causing the decline in job hopping? As the old presidential slogan goes, “it’s the economy, stupid.”
Why This Is Bad
It’s a simple formula, really: the better the economy, the more opportunity, the more people changing out their old jobs for better ones. The worse the economy, the less opportunity out there, and so people stay at their jobs longer.
So, really, job hopping is an indicator of a good economy. And it also forces up wages, because there is more competition for labor.
The numbers back that up, too: the ratio between wages and corporate profits has never been higher, largely because job hopping is down. Companies are not paying their workers more because they have little fear of them leaving.
Here’s a not-so-bold prediction though: that will start changing this year. The economy, albeit slowly, is starting to improve, which should cause job hopping to increase. In turn, that will force companies to start paying workers more.
Conclusion
First off, this idea that millennials today are somehow less decisive or more prone to leave than previous generations is, as the numbers show, fundamentally untrue. In reality, a bad economy has caused a decrease in job hopping, as opportunity has dropped.
But here’s another point: job hopping will probably creep up again, soon, as the economy slowly improves. Companies who want to keep their talent would be smart by figuring out how to retain their employees in a more competitive environment, today; instead of sitting around and watching their best people leave.
About VoiceGlance
VoiceGlance is the world’s smartest hiring tool. Learn more here.
Former Senior Executive, now retired. Writing, fishing, Tying flies and generally living my best life.
9 年I think the situation has been brought on by continued focus on short-term profit and cost containment vs. longer term vision and strategy. The market is driving this and I think in some respects, driving even specialized skills to a commodity status. The globalization of the labor force and continued outsourcing also are fostering a much more short-term view among the workforce and making it difficult to foster company loyalty among younger workers who often feel that they are either cogs or are being played.
Enterprise Solution Architect
10 年You said loyalty has increased 15% but automatically assign that to a lack of better paying jobs rather than anything companies have done to retain their 'best people'. You have equated loyalty to money, nothing else, but do not make a case for that argument. Nor have you made an argument that shows employees are getting underpaid for the work they are currently performing. Nor have you made an argument that many employees really want to move but they can't due to a bad economy. Sorry, but your argument is based on supposition and can be interpreted a number of different ways.
Resource Advisor / USAF
10 年So, the increase in company loyalty is a result of the lack of better paying jobs from the employee's perspective. Ok, I believe that; however, to Julia's point, are people moving to better paying jobs within a compan? I believe that would be an example of loyalty from the company's perspective. This might be an issue for another discussion.
Manager of Process and Systems
10 年This study seems to show years at a company, not years in one position within a company, right? Wouldn't the most relevant data be how millennials are growing their careers, within one company versus switching companies?