JCPenncy Digital Transformation and Leadership

?

1.?? INTRODUCTION

Digital transformation (DT) involves strategically integrating digital technologies and innovative processes throughout an organisation's operations, particularly in retail, to enhance customer engagement and value delivery across sales, marketing, customer service, and supply chain management. This adaptation addresses evolving consumer behaviours and market dynamics in today's digital era (Umar & Reinartz, 2018; Westerman et al., 2014). Leadership, meanwhile, is the capacity to inspire and guide individuals or groups towards common objectives (Northouse, 2018), playing a pivotal role in driving organisational improvement and change, especially amid uncertainty. Effective leadership encompasses inspiring individuals towards a shared vision, fostering innovation, and adapting strategies to navigate challenges and seize transformational opportunities.

To analyse the drivers and challenges of organisational change, this report utilises various frameworks and models. These include PESTLE analysis, the Business Model Canvas (BMC) framework (Osterwalder and Pigneur, 2010), SWOT analysis (Panagiotou, 2003), the digital maturity model (DMM) (Chanias & Hess, 2016; Grossman, 2018), and Porter's Generic Competitive Advantage (Porter, 1985). Additionally, the report provides leadership analysis based on various leadership styles and theories. In this regard, the change and its related challenges are expounded upon, with analysis provided under the subsections of business canvas elements that underwent the most significant alterations.

2.?? JCPENNY HISTORY

JCPenney, founded in 1902 by James Cash Penney, stands as a prominent brick-and-mortar retail entity renowned for its extensive offerings in apparel, home goods, jewellery, and beauty products within the United States (JCPenney, 2024).

As an integral aspect of analysing the implications of DT on the organisation, the BMC serves as a crucial framework (Appendices 1). Within this framework, JCPenney Corporation Inc. operates a hybrid retail model encompassing both digital and physical channels. Through a network of more than 1,000 department stores and its website, www.jcpenney.com , accessible via various applications and browsers across desktop, mobile, and tablet devices, JCPenney delivers merchandise and services to consumers (Colos, 2023).

3.?? DRIVERS OF CHANGE

According to Aguilar (1967), the PESTLE analysis identifies economic, sociological, and technological factors as pivotal drivers in JCPenney's transformation journey (Appendices1). The retail industry underwent significant shifts in consumer behaviour following the economic recession of the mid-2000s, marked by a decline in foot traffic at malls and department stores. Consumers increasingly sought engaging shopping experiences, leading to decreased total retail sales as traditional department store models struggled to adapt (Clifford and Helft, 2011; Wahba, 2016). However, it has been propelled by technological advancements during the same period. Modern retail has undergone a paradigmatic transformation, with digital retail at its core. This transformation is characterised by the integration of advanced technologies to streamline operations, enhance customer experiences, and drive efficiencies. Consumer preferences are continually shaped by technological advancements and social trends, necessitating a strategic response from retail companies. Consequently, the need for DT was not merely a choice but a strategic imperative for companies to remain competitive and relevant in the contemporary retail landscape. Amidst fierce competition, the industry's digital transformation, and a market saturated with undifferentiated products, JCPenney found itself facing challenges and realised that it required a change to adapt to the market (Ferreira et al., 2020; Proskurnina, 2021).

In 2011, JCPenney underwent a significant transformation under the leadership of Ron Johnson, the former head of Apple's retail stores, known for his innovative strategies (Mattioli, 2012; Clifford and Helft, 2011). Johnson's appointment resulted in a remarkable 17 percent increase in JCPenney's stocks (Clifford and Helft, 2011), indicating a strategic pivot for the company.??????????????

4.?? ANALYSIS OF SITUATION

JCPenney, under Johnson's leadership, aimed to modernise stores, revamp pricing strategies, and reshape the brand/vendor matrix to drive DT (JCPenney, 2016; Mohammed, 2012a; Janet, 2012). The mission to 'reinvent the department store by becoming America's favourite store' reflects a dedication to leveraging technology to enhance customer satisfaction (David, 1989). Johnson's bold vision, exemplified by statements such as “We are going to rethink every aspect of our business.” and “We will transform each and every JCPenney store over the next four years.”, underscores the company's commitment to change and long-term shareholder value. This intention to undergo DT is evident in their meticulous, shop-by-shop rollout of new merchandise initiatives aimed at revitalising the retail experience (Heller, 2012).

Johnson's initiatives embodied various facets of DT, encompassing the digitisation of in-store experiences through the deployment of digital displays, the integration of mobile technology such as upgrading their point-of-sale (MPos) devices, and the expansion of e-commerce operations. The company also aimed to deploy a comprehensive set of Oracle Retail solutions to enhance operational efficiency and elevate the customer experience across various channels as part of its retail transformation efforts (Calif, 2012). Under Johnson's tenure, JCPenney rose to prominence among the top 20 Internet Retailers while undergoing a comprehensive overhaul of its information technology platform in collaboration with Oracle Inc (Briggs, 2013). As provided in SWOT analysis (Appendices3), these endeavors exemplified the strengths of the company’s transformational journey, presenting promising avenues for bolstering competitiveness through digital innovation (Briggs, 2013).

Moreover, the transformation presented an opportunity for restructuring and enhancing operational efficiency. However, a discernible weakness in their strategy was the absence of target specificity regarding the technologies slated for implementation and the lack of a change management plan for applying the transformation.

Concurrently, Johnson introduced the "Fair and Square" pricing strategy as a pivotal aspect of his approach, replacing the previous model's reliance on what he termed 'fake prices' with a more transparent low-price strategy (Mohammed, 2012a; Mattioli 2012).

Furthermore, commendable efforts were undertaken to modernise the retail strategy. However, a weakness emerged: there was a notable absence of emphasis on a DT strategy. The lack of a cohesive DT strategy, encompassing the expansion of e-commerce capabilities, proved detrimental. Additionally, factors such as simultaneously implementing incorrect price and brand strategies, along with a misinterpretation of customer needs, and a deficiency in a proper change management strategy for customer readiness with the changes, coupled with top-down decision-making, further compounded the challenges faced by JCPenney. Below, you will find a further analysis of the changes made and their impact on the company.

Channels

In the digital age, one of the primary challenges facing brick-and-mortar stores is the ability of customers to purchase similar products at lower prices online. Johnson's objective was to distinguish JCPenney by offering customers a unique shopping experience and selling boutique merchandise with a focus on digital components within stores, something not readily available from internet retailers. The aim of this strategy was to establish a retail chain that gives customers compelling reasons to visit physical stores rather than making purchases online (Rafi, 2013).

JCPenney leveraged Oracle Retail software to elevate the customer experience across diverse channels, streamline retail operations, and empower staff with immediate, mobile-accessible insights into both customers and business operations (Calif, 2012). According to Justin Grossman's delineation of four levels of digital maturity, JCPenney's evolution aligns with the "intentional" stage (Grossman, 2018). Despite Johnson's efforts to modernise the retail experience, the absence of a comprehensive DT strategy and a failure to prioritise digital channels such as e-commerce proved to be significant missteps, hindering their advancement in digital maturity. While JCPenney demonstrated purpose and strategy in certain facets of DT endeavors, it fell short of achieving comprehensive integration across the entirety of its operations.

In an era marked by the rise of online shopping and digital innovations, JCPenney's failure to prioritise DT left it trailing behind competitors who had achieved higher levels of digital maturity. Companies like Walmart had effectively integrated digital strategies across various business domains, surpassing JCPenney in the online retail sphere. JCPenney found itself in an earlier stage of digital adoption, struggling to utilise digital tools effectively for sales, marketing, and customer engagement. Consequently, JCPenney missed opportunities to leverage the growing significance of e-commerce and adjust to the evolving retail environment (Redd & Vickerie, 2017; Chan, 2020).

Customer Relationship

Using Porter's Generic Competitive Strategies framework (Porter, 1985), businesses pursue cost leadership, differentiation, or niche market focus. In the competitive retail landscape, JC Penney succeeded by differentiating itself and catering to specific consumer segments. Before the 2006 US economic recession, JC Penney operated amidst two powerful forces: high-end, designer-boutique department stores like Macy’s, and trendy mass retailers like Target, Wal-Mart, and Kohl’s. Identifying a mid-market opportunity, JC Penney strategically focused on a pivotal demographic: married women aged 35 to 54, with children, and household incomes of $35,000 to $100,000 (Ellen, 2005).

Johnson's primary focus during the transformation was on altering the pricing strategy, which entailed discontinuing frequent sales and discounts in favour of an everyday low-price approach. Instead of employing an analytics-driven approach and conducting market tests prior to implementation, he heavily relied on his previous successful experience at Apple. To achieve this, he aimed to implement an Everyday Low Pricing (EDLP) strategy, offering consumers the lowest available price without coupon clipping or comparison shopping. This included adjusting prices to end in “0” and displaying only one price on tags, omitting the customary “previously sold at a higher price” convention (Hoch et al., 1994; Mohammed, 2012a; Mattioli 2012).

However, when JCPenney altered its pricing communication and structured pricing into three tiers of deals, it experienced a notable consequence, losing approximately 10% of its female customers, a demographic crucial to its business (Mohammed, 2012b). This shift in pricing strategy, however, was based on a misinterpretation of consumer preferences and expectations, and the lack of market test and customer readiness for the change. Johnson failed to recognise the emotional connection and brand loyalty that J.C. Penney's customers had developed over time due to the discount pricing model (Passikoff, 2013; Tuttle, 2013).

By the end of his first year at J.C. Penney, it became evident that the no-coupon, no-sales strategy had failed, resulting in the alienation of many core customers. Johnson's failure to grasp the preferences of J.C. Penney's core customers stemmed from his authoritative leadership and top-down approach to DT, bypassing the essential step of testing the market for the new strategy and without considering the company's established customer base. His strategy was not merely bold but radical and risky, indicating a lack of prudence in implementing numerous changes concurrently (O’Toole, 2013). This oversight hindered the company's ability to accurately assess the potential impact of the pricing strategy before its implementation, contributing to the challenges faced during the transition period.

Key Resources and Cost Structure

Johnson led an ambitious campaign to revamp JCPenney's image through store rebranding and layout redesigns, introducing boutique-style sections and digital enhancements like displays and modern point-of-sale devices. Collaborations with brands such as Martha Stewart and Joe Fresh were also initiated. Despite these efforts, they failed to resonate with JCPenney's core customer base, leaving them perplexed (Tuttle, 2013; Calif, 2012).

Under Johnson's leadership, JCPenney implemented significant cost-cutting measures to save USD 200 million annually. This included laying off 600 employees, constituting 10% of the headquarters staff, and appointing a new management team largely from outside the retail sector. Subsequent layoffs, especially targeting middle managers, caused uncertainty among employees about their roles and job security. The decision to reduce commissions for sales staff worsened challenges during this rapid transformation. The ethical implications of these actions on employee well-being, morale, job satisfaction, and overall welfare were significant. Johnson's approach of replacing experienced employees with new management from unrelated sectors without leveraging the expertise of existing staff could be seen as a missed opportunity. Utilising the expertise of managers and employees who understand the company's culture and customer preferences could have led to a more successful change strategy, enhancing both employee engagement and customer satisfaction (Edwards & Minato, 2013; Wahba, 2016; Guinto, 2013).

?Revenue Streams

The consequences of alienating its customer base proved costly for JCPenney, leading to a significant decline in financial performance. Net sales dropped by over 24%, falling from $17 billion in 2011 to $12 billion in 2012, with the company reporting a substantial revenue loss of USD 985 million (JCPenney, 2013). This decline affected both in-store and online sales, with reductions of 28% to 32%, accompanied by a nearly 50% decrease in stock prices (Tichy, 2014; Clifford, 2013; Eames, 2021). In-store sales saw a sharp decline from $154 per square foot to $116 per square foot, further worsening the financial situation. Additionally, fourth-quarter losses totaled USD 427 million (Edwards & Minato, 2013; Clifford, 2013; Tobak, 2014). By 2013, JCPenney was burdened with $5 billion in long-term debt and had an EBITDA of negative $600 million (Wahba, 2016).

?

5.?? CONCLUSION

Considering the mission and defined strategies in JCPenney's intended DT, the company faced significant challenges, including underestimating the digital era and failing to align pricing and store layout changes with customer preferences. Despite their intentions, JCPenney implemented numerous concurrent digital and non-digital strategies, lacked a change management plan for the transformation, and set ambiguous targets, ultimately resulting in the alienation of its core customer base and loss of market share.

Johnson's leadership journey encompasses both transformational leadership successes and managerial challenges (Schedlitzki & Edwards, 2014; Lewin et al., 1939). While his successful previous endeavors at Apple and Target exemplify his transformational leadership capabilities, he encountered difficulties at JCPenney due to a disconnect between his visionary mission aimed at reinventing the department store and aligning with transformational leadership principles, as highlighted by Hater & Bass (1988). The autocratic and visionary management style he employed hindered customer buy-in and underscored the importance of aligning leadership actions with Kotter's change management model (2012) (Appendices 4). This highlights the need for a more inclusive and collaborative approach to change management, focusing on communicating a clear vision throughout the organization.

6. RECOMMENDATIONS

Despite the encountered challenges, the journey towards organisational transformation presents valuable lessons for JCPenney's future endeavours. It is important to recognise the pivotal role of DT and the significance of e-commerce in today's retail landscape. Therefore, it can be recommended that JCPenney could develop a comprehensive strategy for DT, focusing on integrating digital technologies across all aspects of their operations, including sales, marketing, customer service, and supply chain management. This strategy should be aligned with the evolving needs and preferences of digitally literate consumers and should encompass initiatives aimed at enhancing the online shopping experience, leveraging data analytics for personalised marketing, and embracing emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence and augmented reality to drive innovation. By prioritising DT and embracing e-commerce, JCPenney could position itself for sustained growth and competitiveness in the digital retail landscape.

To further augment the efficacy of its strategic initiatives, adopting an incremental approach to transformation, and having a clear change management plan for implementation of the change rather than implementing abrupt changes could be suggested. This approach could help mitigate resistance from both employees and customers and facilitate smoother adaptation to new strategies. In this regard, establishing transparent communication channels between leadership and employees to foster a culture of collaboration and inclusion is imperative. Such measures can mitigate the perception of top-down decision-making and promote employee buy-in for organisational changes. Furthermore, emphasising the importance of maintaining a customer-centric approach in all business decisions is essential. Encouraging the organisation to prioritise customer needs and preferences ensures alignment with market expectations and enhances long-term competitiveness.

?

?

References

Aguilar, F. J. (1967). Scanning the Business Environment. Harvard Business School Press

Briggs, B., (2013), JCPenney rings up 25% of store sales via mobile devices’, [Online] [Accessed on 25th? March 2024] https://www.digitalcommerce360.com/2013/03/07/jc-penney-rings-25-store-sales-mobile-devices/

Calif, R.Sh . (2012) ‘JCPenney to implement complete suite of Oracle Retail applications’, [Online] [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://chainstoreage.com/news/jcpenney-implement-complete-suite-oracle-retail-applications

Chan, J.O.P., (2020) ‘DT in the era of big data and cloud computing’, International Journal of Intelligent Information Systems,?9(3), p.16. [Online] [Accessed on 25th? March 2024] https://doi.org/10.11648/j.ijiis.20200903.11

Chanias, S., Hess, T. (2016) ‘How digital are we? maturity models for the assessment of a company’s status in the digital transformation’, PP. 1–14 [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:53616590

Clifford S. & M. Helft (2011) ‘Apple Stores Chief to Take Helm at JCPenney’, New York Times, [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/15/business/economy/15shop.html

Clifford S. (2013) ‘Chief Talks of Big Mistakes and Big Loss at Penney’, New York Times, [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/28/business/jc-penneys-chief-says-his-mistakes-led-to-big-loss.html

Colos, L. (2023) ‘J. C. Penney: Business Model, SWOT Analysis, and Competitors 2023’, [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://pitchgrade.com/companies/j-c-penney

David, F.R. (1989) ‘How companies define their mission’, Long Range Planning, 22 (1), PP. 90–97, [Accessed on 25th March 2024]? https://doi.org/10.1016/0024-6301(89)90055-1

Ellen B. (2005) ‘New Penny: Chain goes for “Missing Middle”’, Wall Street Journal. New York, N.Y.: Feb 14, 2005. p. B.1

Edwards, J., Minato, C. (2013) ‘How Ex-CEO Ron Johnson made JC Penney even worse’, Business Insider. [Online] [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://www.businessinsider.com/ron-johnson-disaster-timeline-apple-guru-failed-at-jcpenney-2013-4

Ferreira, M.J., Moreira, F., Pereira, C.S. and Dur?o, N., (2020). ‘The digital transformation at organizations–the case of retail sector’, Trends and Innovations in Information Systems and Technologies, Springer International Publishing, 1(8)?pp. 560-567 [Accessed on 25th March 2024]? ?https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-45688-7_56

Grossman , J., (2018) ‘The Four Stages Of Digital Maturity: How Does Your Organization Rank?’, Forbes, [Online] [Accessed on 25th? March 2024] https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesagencycouncil/2018/11/02/the-four-stages-of-digital-maturity-how-does-your-organization-rank/

Hater, J. J., & Bass, B. M. (1988). ‘Superiors’ evaluations and subordinates’ perceptions of transformational and transactional leadership’. Journal of Applied Psychology, 73, PP. 695-702, [Online] [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.73.4.695

Heller, L. (2012). ‘Why JCPenney Will Be the most interesting retailer of 2012’, forbes, [Online] [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://www.forbes.com/sites/lauraheller/2012/01/26/why-jcpenney-will-be-the-most-interesting-retailer-of-2012/

Hersey, P. and Blanchard, K. H. (1982). ‘Management of Organizational Behavior: Utilizing Human Resources’. Prentice Hall.

Hoch, S.J., Dreze, X. and Purk, M.E., (1994) ‘EDLP, Hi-Lo, and margin arithmetic’, Journal of marketing, 58(4), pp.16-27, [Online] [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://www.jstor.org/stable/1251913

Janet H. Cho, (2012) ‘JCPenney aims to draw shoppers with everyday low prices and new brands’, [Online] [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://www.cleveland.com/business/2012/01/jcpenney_aims_to_draw_shoppers_with_everyday_low_prices_and_new_brands.html

JCPenney Company Inc. (2024), [Online] [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://corporate.jcpenney.com/about/corporate-information/

JCPenney Company Inc. (2016). ‘Form 10-K’, Annual Report, [Online] [Accessed on 25th? March 2024] https://www.annualreports.com/HostedData/AnnualReportArchive/j/NYSE_JCP_2016.pdf

JCPenney Inc. (2013) J.C. Penney, Inc. (2013) ‘Form 10-K’, Annual Report, [Online] [Accessed on 25th? March 2024]? https://www.annualreports.com/HostedData/AnnualReportArchive/j/NYSE_JCP_2013.pdf

Kotter, J. P., & Cohen, D. S. (2012). The heart of change. Harvard Business Review Press.

Kruse, K. (2014) ‘How successful people cure their blind spot’, Forbes, [Online] [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://www.forbes.com/sites/kevinkruse/2014/04/10/how-successful-people-cure-their-blindspots/#12e776f77542

Lewin, K., Lippitt, R., & White, R. K. (1939). ‘Patterns of Aggressive Behavior in Experimentally Created 'Social Climates'’. The Journal of Social Psychology, 10(2), PP. 271-299, [Online] [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://doi.org/10.1080/00224545.1939.9713366

Mattioli D. (2012) ‘Penney Ousts President’, The Wall Street Journal, [Online] [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702303836404577474931017078226 ???????

Mayer, R. C., Davis, J. H., & Schoorman, F. D. (1995). ‘An Integrative Model of Organizational Trust’. Academy of Management Review, 20(3), PP. 709-734.

Mohammed R. (2012a) ‘Understanding JCPenney’s Risky New Pricing Strategy’, Harvard Business Review, [Online] [Accessed on 25th? March 2024] https://hbr.org/2012/01/understanding-jc-penneys-risky

Mohammed R. (2012b) ‘J.C. Penney: Ditch the Risky Pricing Strategy’, Harvard Business Review, [Online] [Accessed on 25th? March 2024] https://hbr.org/2012/01/understanding-jc-penneys-risky

?

Northouse, P. G. (2018). ‘Leadership: Theory and Practice’. SAGE Publications, 8th edn.

Passikoff, R. (2013) ‘Ron Johnson ousted as J. C. Penney CEO’, Forbes, [Online] [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://www.forbes.com/sites/marketshare/2013/04/09/ron-johnson-ousted-as-jcpenney-ceo/#2c0b08ea60b6

Porter, Michael E. (1985) ‘Competitive Advantage, New York:’ The Free Press, pp. 11-15

Proskurnina, N.V., Shtal, T.V., Slavuta, O.I., Serogina, D.O. and Bohuslavskyi, V.V. (2021) ‘Omnichannel Strategy of digital transformation of retail trade enterprise: From concept to implementation’.?Studies of Applied Economics,?39(6)

Rafi, M., (2013) ‘With Ron Johnson Out, What Should JCPenney Do Now?’? Harvard Business Review [Online] [Accessed on 25th? March 2024] https://hbr.org/2013/04/now-what-should-jc-penney-do

Redd, Nikaela Jacko and Vickerie, Lutisha S. (2017) ‘The Rise and Fall of Brick and Mortar Retail: The Impact of Emerging Technologies and Executive Choices on Business Failure’, Journal of International Business and Law, 17(1) , PP. 127-171 [Online] [Accessed on 25th? March 2024] https://scholarlycommons.law.hofstra.edu/jibl/vol17/iss1/7

Schedlitzki, Doris and Gareth Edwards, (2014) ‘Studying Leadership: Traditional and Critical Approaches’, Sage Publications Ltd, 1st edn.

Panagiotou, G. (2003) ‘Bringing SWOT into focus’, Business Strategy Review, 14(2), PP. 8-10, [Online] [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://www.academia.edu/10056857/Business_Strategy_Review_Bringing_SWOT_into_focus ??????????????

Tanwar, R. (2013) ‘Porter’s generic competitive strategies’. Journal of business and management, 15(1), PP.11-17

Tichy, N. (2014) ‘J. C. Penney and the terrible costs of hiring an outsider CEO’. Fortune, [Online] [Accessed on 25th? March 2024] https://fortune.com/2014/11/13/jc-penney-ron-johnson-ceo-succession/

Eames, Jr., R. W., (2021). ‘Ron Johnson’s debacle at J. C. Penney: A management case’. In Sage Business Cases. SAGE Publications, Ltd., [Accessed on 25th March2024] https://doi.org/10.4135/9781529741971

Thaler, R. H., & Sunstein, C. R. (2008). Nudge: Improving decisions about health, wealth, and happiness. Yale University Press.

Tuttle, B. (2013). ‘The 5 big mistakes that led to Ron Johnson’s ouster at JC Penney’, TIME, [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://business.time.com/2013/04/09/the-5-big-mistakes-that-led-to-ron-johnsons-ouster-at-jc-penney/

Wahba P. (2016) ‘The CEO Who’s Reinventing J.C. Penney’, fortune, [Accessed on 25th March 2024] https://fortune.com/longform/j-c-penney-reinvention/

Westerman, G., Bonnet, D., & McAfee, A. (2014) ‘Leading Digital: Turning Technology into Business Transformation’, Harvard Business Press.

?

?

?

?

?

?

?

?

?

?

?

?

?

?

?

?

?

Appendices

Appendix 1: PESTLE analysis is a framework used to understand the macro-environmental factors affecting an organisation or a business.

?Appendix 2: The Business Model Canvas framework illustrates how an organization creates, captures, and delivers value through its products or services (Toro-Jarrín et al., 2016)

?

Appendix 3: SWOT analysis is concerned with the analysis of an organisation’s internal and external environment with the aim of identifying internal strengths in order to take advantage of its external opportunities and avoid external (and possible internal) threats, while addressing its weaknesses.

?Appendix 4: Kotter's Eight-Step Change Model is a framework to guide organisations through the process of successful change management.

Appendix 5: A digital maturity model (DMM) serves as a structured framework for assessing an organization's current level of digitalization and offering direction for prospective investments (Chanias & Hess, 2016).? Justin Grossman (2018) outlines four distinct levels of digital maturity, as depicted in the accompanying illustration.

Appendix 5 The Four Stages of Digital Maturity, (Source: https://www.pipartners.com/digital-maturity/ Online)

Appendix 6: Porter’s competitive advantage framework consists of three general types of strategies that are commonly used by businesses to achieve and maintain competitive advantage (Tanwar, 2013). Porter called the generic strategies "Cost Leadership" (no frills), "Differentiation" (creating uniquely desirable products and services) and "Focus" (offering a specialized service in a niche market) (Porter, Michael E., 1985).

?

?

?

?