Not Invented Here Syndrome

Not Invented Here Syndrome

"Jack of all trades, master of none". We have all heard the expression a thousand times and I can't imagine it is an expression many of us have aspired to live up to. Most of will recognise the path to success as being the best we can be at a defined number of core skills.

So why do so many technology providers invest so heavily in developing sub optimal functionality where their users would be better served with best in class solutions? There are many, many examples of this, but some of my least favourites are;

  • Are VMS and ATS users best served by limited on-boarding functionality when best in class tools like Silkroad Red Carpet provide a much richer experience.
  • Does deploying any technology solution with integrations that are hand built for every implementation when richer, speedier and more robust results can be achieved with one of the excellent iPaaS solutions such as Dell Boomi, Cyclr, Mulesoft etc.
  • The many excellent Analytics solutions available will give users so much more flexibility than proprietary in application report builders.

I fully understand that much of the proprietary functionality like this pre-dates the wider availability of SaaS solutions that can deliver these enhanced capabilities. I also understand that commercial considerations are a significant factor in such development decisions.

I'm not arguing that there is no room for proprietary solutions in some of these areas, but some of the arguments I've heard for not offering integrations with third party best in class solutions seem very one dimensional. Surely the stickiness of delivering the very best solutions is the ultimate commercial justification.

Again a legacy reason for not following this path would have been the complexity of integrations and the user experience of working through multiple applications. However in this day and age I would argue that this is no longer a good reason.

I realise that not everyone will share my point of view, but I believe that providers taking an open minded approach to well thought out collaborations is a win, win, win for collaborators and clients alike.

Claire Curtis

Technical Delivery Manager

8 年

Well said Matt Jessop, there is a real danger of diluting your value proposition when adding on noncore functionality and diverting focus from the real solutions your software brings. We take a really healthy approach to partnership at Jobtrain and look for best in class partners to enhance our clients overall experience. As an example we work in partnership with Launchpad and integrate the video interviewing technology with Jobtrain’s recruitment software. Our clients really love this approach.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Matt Jessop的更多文章

  • Emotional Intelligence

    Emotional Intelligence

    Thank you (I think!!) to my friend and partner Tom Kaminsky , for nominating me to continue the #defiantoriginstory…

    21 条评论
  • Are we Finally at a Technology Tipping Point in the Contingent Workforce Industry?

    Are we Finally at a Technology Tipping Point in the Contingent Workforce Industry?

    My thoughts on the Changing VMS Landscape I’m lucky that after more than 20 years, I’d still happily talk for hours…

    2 条评论
  • Integrations; It’s Broken, Who Fixes It?

    Integrations; It’s Broken, Who Fixes It?

    So hopefully we can all agree that being able to run a talent acquisition and/or contingent workforce program with just…

    1 条评论
  • Technical Ability vs. Domain Expertise: Which is More Important for the Resourcing Function?

    Technical Ability vs. Domain Expertise: Which is More Important for the Resourcing Function?

    With the increasing use and importance of reporting and analytics as a key component of a resourcing function, how to…

  • Ways to Factor in Location when Benchmarking

    Ways to Factor in Location when Benchmarking

    One of the challenges when designing reports and benchmarks is how best to factor in location as one of the criteria…

  • Contingent Workforce & Equality

    Contingent Workforce & Equality

    I was just reading an article about the gender pay gap. Whilst I totally agree that it is a worthy topic that…

  • Hans Rosling, the ultimate storyteller

    Hans Rosling, the ultimate storyteller

    Sadly this week we said goodbye to one of the great data visionaries, Hans Rosling. Notable for a great many…

    2 条评论
  • Mental Health Carers

    Mental Health Carers

    Today is National Time to Talk day, which is a great initiative and I'm greatly encouraged by the amount of visibility…

  • The Devil is in the Detail

    The Devil is in the Detail

    It's a cliche that many of us reference and instinctively believe to be true. However I've been pondering on the…

    5 条评论
  • Law of Unintended Consequences

    Law of Unintended Consequences

    It was the Sociologist Robert K. Merton that popularised the Law of Unintended Consequences.

社区洞察