THE INTEGRITY IMPERATIVE: NAVIGATING THE GREY AREAS OF ETHICAL LEADERSHIP

In our previous discussions about trust in utilities, we've touched on the importance of integrity. Today, let's talk about some uncomfortable truths about this crucial yet often challenging aspect of leadership.

When we talk about integrity in business, especially in essential services like utilities, we're not just ticking a box on a corporate governance checklist. We're talking about the very foundation of public trust – remember, the top currency for monopolies. But here's the rub: maintaining integrity isn't always as straightforward as it sounds.

Let's face it, ethical decisions aren't always black and white. They often come in shades of grey, leaving leaders to navigate pretty murky waters. And here's another uncomfortable truth: making the right ethical choice doesn't always win you popularity contests.

Take, for example, a water utility facing pressure to keep prices low in a drought-stricken area. The popular choice might be to maintain current prices, but the ethical choice might involve raising them to encourage conservation and fund necessary infrastructure improvements. It's a decision that could save resources in the long run but might not win any immediate fans.

Or consider a utility that discovers a potential health risk in a small portion of its water supply. The easy path might be to quietly address the issue without public disclosure, in the interest of avoiding panic. But the ethical path? Well, it definitely requires transparent communication, even if it temporarily shakes public confidence.

These scenarios highlight a key challenge of ethical leadership: sometimes, doing the right thing means making unpopular decisions. It requires leaders to prioritise long-term sustainability and public welfare over short-term gains or personal popularity.

But why is this so hard? Part of it comes down to human nature. We all like to be liked. There's a certain comfort in going with the flow, in not rocking the boat. Plus, in the age of social media and instant public feedback, the pressure to make crowd-pleasing decisions can be intense.

The thing is, ethical dilemmas often pit different values against each other. Do we prioritise short-term affordability or long-term sustainability? Immediate transparency or avoiding “unnecessary” panic? There often isn’t a clear-cut answer, and it’s this ambiguity that makes it very uncomfortable for leaders who prioritise their own ego.

The truth is, despite these challenges, acting with integrity is non-negotiable for leaders who are serious about building lasting trust. It's about consistently doing the right thing, even when – especially when – it's difficult.

I strongly encourage leaders to create an environment that not only tolerates but actively encourages ethical questioning. The unsung heroes of integrity are often those employees (at all levels) who have the courage to speak up when they spot potential ethical compromises. These are the individuals who ask the uncomfortable questions, who challenge decisions that might prioritise expediency, or a nod from the Board, over basic ethics.

A powerful example of this remains Enron. In 2001, Sherron Watkins, then vice president of corporate development at Enron, wrote a memo to CEO Kenneth Lay expressing her concerns about the company's accounting practices. She warned that Enron might "implode in a wave of accounting scandals." Initially, her concerns were largely ignored, and then she started facing retaliation for speaking up. Fortunately, her courageous actions eventually helped expose one of the largest corporate frauds in U.S. history.

The Enron case, more than two decades on, is a stark reminder of the crucial role that ethical voices play in any organisation. It underscores the potential consequences of ignoring or deliberately suppressing concerns raised by employees, and highlights why creating a culture of ethical enquiry is so vital.

It's crucial for leaders to value and protect these voices. They're not troublemakers or naysayers; think of them as the conscience of the organisation. By creating an environment where raising ethical concerns is seen as a strength rather than a nuisance, leaders can tap into a powerful resource for maintaining integrity.

This might mean implementing robust whistleblower protections, regularly acknowledging and rewarding ethical behaviour, or even creating specific roles focused on ethical oversight. The message should be clear: in this organisation, we don't just tolerate ethical questions - we welcome them as they’re essential to who we are.

Remember, it's often easier to address potential ethical issues early, when they're first raised, rather than dealing with the fallout of a full-blown ethical crisis.

Take, for instance, the case of Southwest Airlines following their operational meltdown during the 2022 holiday season. When thousands of flights were cancelled due to outdated scheduling systems, CEO Bob Jordan didn't try to deflect in any way. No, he immediately issued a public video apology, taking full responsibility for the failure and saying what the airline would do to make things right for affected customers and, importantly, prevent similar issues in the future. Without hesitation, he offered affected customers refunds, reimbursement of expenses, and additional frequent flyer points. He also committed to upgrading their systems to prevent future breakdowns.

Jordan’s approach, while initially painful, ultimately helped Southwest maintain public trust. By being transparent about the problems, showing genuine remorse, and committing to concrete improvements, Southwest demonstrated integrity in a crisis. In the months following the incident, customer sentiment towards the airline actually improved, with many praising the company's honest and proactive response.

Now, let's explore some guiding principles that can help leaders navigate these ethical minefields:

1. Prioritise transparency: If you remember nothing else, remember this - open and honest communication is the cornerstone of ethical leadership. Even when the news isn't good, honest communication builds trust in the long run. In fact, owning up to mistakes and clearly communicating how you're addressing them can actually enhance trust rather than weaken it.
2. Think long-term: Consider the long-term implications of decisions, not just immediate outcomes. And remember, the organisation will always outlast the individual.
3. Seek diverse perspectives: Ethical dilemmas are rarely solved in isolation. And ultimately, the old adage remains true: a problem shared is a problem halved. So, engage with stakeholders and make an effort to seek out differing viewpoints.
4. Establish agreed ethical guidelines: Having a strong, openly shared framework for ethical behaviour will offer clear direction in complex scenarios. This might involve creating a comprehensive ethics policy, setting up an ethics committee, or implementing regular ethics training for all employees. The key is to make these guidelines practical, accessible, and deeply ingrained in the organisation's being.
5. Lead by example: Integrity starts at the top. Full stop.

Remember, integrity isn't about perfection. It's about consistently striving to do the right thing, owning up to mistakes, and always keeping the public good at the forefront of decision-making.

In the world of utilities – and indeed, in any leadership role – integrity might not always be the easiest path. But it's undoubtedly the surest way to build lasting trust and create organisations that truly serve their communities.

As leaders, we need to embrace the discomfort that comes with ethical decision-making.

It's in navigating these grey areas, in making the tough calls, that we truly earn the trust placed in us. After all, integrity isn't just about following rules – it's about setting the standard for always-on ethical behaviour, even when no one is watching. It's about creating an environment where everyone takes responsibility for their actions and their impact.

This brings us to a powerful concept that takes integrity to the next level: Extreme Ownership. In our next chat, we'll uncover how this mindset, borrowed from two former US Navy SEALs, can transform utility leadership from the inside out. We'll explore how moving from a culture of blame to one of personal responsibility can create a ripple effect of brilliance throughout an organisation - and beyond.

?