INSIGHT: Are INGOs ready to let go of power?

INSIGHT: Are INGOs ready to let go of power?

'Colonialism is alive and well in international development' is one of many controversial quotes in this excellent article that tackles the power imbalance between south and north NGOs (i.e. local and international NGO) in trying to answer the question: Are INGOs ready to give up power (see link below)?

https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/transformation/are-ingos-ready-give-power/

Having worked for INGOs most of my life before founding a local NGO, I can now appreciate the frustration of local NGOs face when trying to be autonomous and/or even sustainable in a constricted funding landscape. Most of my time is spent finding money, making sure people are paid on time and delivering social impact all whilst staying on mission. It keeps me up at night. As much as I agree, in principle, with the need to shift power from north to south NGOs (which is the ethical thing to do given that the lived experiences of south voices makes them better forgers of their own future), local NGOs have not made it easy for funders and taxpayers to trust them, something I learned all too well whilst working with INGOs. Cases of fraud/fake receipts, double-dipping, founder's syndrome and ‘cosmetic charity’ are rife among local NGOs; now whether this is because of this power imbalance highlighted in this article, I don’t know. But we cannot talk about 'shifting the power' without also addressing, honestly, the problems plaguing local/south NGOs; we (local/south NGOs) must also be held accountable.

This is a conversation the development sector needs to have – this is our #metoo conversation; it’s about time we had it.

#aidtoo #shifthepower #povery #povertyreduction #development #philanthropy

Stuart Smith

Partner at Ground Water Science and Ground+Water Tanzania Ltd.

5 年

My observation in our sphere in Tanzania is that the technical capacity is available locally when encouraged. I serve a certain technical guidance role for now, but it won't be long before I am mzee-figurehead ;-) and I am happy with that. On behalf of my colleagues, I squirm when our benefactors seem to think they have to explain everything. But what will adventurous Westerners do??

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Muthi Nhlema的更多文章

  • Things I would say to my younger self...

    Things I would say to my younger self...

    We all have them! Those cringe-worthy moments from our past that make us ask, 'What in tarnations was I thinking?' - if…

    2 条评论
  • Silence of the Imperfect Dead

    Silence of the Imperfect Dead

    I have said this before, but I feel it's worth saying again. It is deeply arrogant of us, the living, to pass judgement…

  • Decolonization and The Privilege of Hindsight

    Decolonization and The Privilege of Hindsight

    History is complicated and often inconvenient. Winston Churchill's opinions on race were deeply despicable, but he saw…

    5 条评论
  • Dear Graduate (who also happens to be a genius)

    Dear Graduate (who also happens to be a genius)

    This post is dedicated to you, you first degree-holders with that enviable 'distinction' qualifier. I know you feel…

    2 条评论
  • Dear Millennial...

    Dear Millennial...

    I know you are tech savvy. I know you hold more liberal beliefs and hopes for a better and more equal world.

    6 条评论
  • Confessions of a Grant Writer

    Confessions of a Grant Writer

    Having been a grant writer (mostly by accident as is common in the development sector) for most of my post-graduate…

    14 条评论
  • Your job can be your business!

    Your job can be your business!

    One day, standing on one of the many ubiquitous queues in one of many Malawian banks that claim to put customer service…

    2 条评论
  • Karma Has No Deadline!

    Karma Has No Deadline!

    You don't have to be Hindu or Buddhist to understand how Karma can affect our professional lives. Here are two of…

    1 条评论
  • The Morality of Data Suppression

    The Morality of Data Suppression

    The importance of verifiable and reliable data cannot be overstated. Data has been at the heart of solving some of the…

  • Is The Workplace Becoming Big Brother?

    Is The Workplace Becoming Big Brother?

    A friend of mine, who coincidentally introduced me to the wonderful work of LinkedIn, refuses to have an online…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了