Indian knowledge systems
Art by Devdutt Pattanaik

Indian knowledge systems

The first list of an educational syllabus in India comes from the Chandogya Upanishad, when the Sanatakumar sages ask Narada what subjects he is proficient in. Narada gives the following list: the four Vedas, the fifth Veda (itihasa-purana), the Vedanga (phoenetics, etymology, grammar, prosody, geometry, time-keeping, ceremonies), logic, earth science (physics, chemistry, biology) knowledge of gods (deva), ancestors (pitr), serpents (sarpa), stars (jyotisha). The Sanatkumar point out that the list does not include self-awareness (brahma-vidya) and so Narada’s knowledge is superficial, like memorisation, lacking understanding, and assimilation, preventing application.

Ravana, is a case in point. Ramayana describes him a Vedic Brahmin, author of many books related to medicine and astrology and engineering. But he does not respect humans. He strives to be dominating and territorial. He drives his brother out of the house and claims his property. He demands complete loyalty and submission from his brothers. He does not respect a woman’s consent. This lack of empathy indicates knowledge without wisdom that Sanatkumars are referring to. This Brahma-vidya is the lodestone of Indian Knowledge Systems.

Chandogya Upanishad is said to be older than Buddhism, revealing ideas that are 2,700 years old. By this time, Indian Knowledge systems were organised, we can claim. The list was expanded later to include the knowledge (veda) of music (gandharva), war (dhanur), healing (ayur) and architecture (sthapatya). Another set of ideas emerged around 1,500 years ago. These were called the shastra (organised knowledge). These included knowledge of dharma (society), artha (economics), and kama (art and pleasure).

By the 10th century, there are texts on occult sciences (Tantra) and elaboration of mystical ideas (siddha-yoga). They spoke not just about body and breath, but also about connecting to, and controlling, cosmic energies and manipulating nature, space and time. Was this spirituality, sorcery or proto-science? We can always speculate as there is no proof either way.

But all these knowledge systems are highly Brahmanical, the lore of priests. This was transmitted orally in Sanskrit and later put down in writing. Much of Indian Knowledge Systems were not captured in texts and so are lost. There is little documentary trace of the various technologies (vidya) of the weaver, the potter, the metalsmith, the farmer, the herdsman, the trader, the butcher.? We can blame the caste system for it.

Caste system had a good side and a bad side when it came to knowledge systems. The good side was that knowledge was kept safe by a community of people, transmitted over generations, and improved over time. The bad side was that it was kept in isolation, inaccessible to outsiders. Modern knowledge systems are meant to be open sources, to be shared by all, except when patent laws are applied.

Today, Indian educators are being encouraged to remind children about the Indian Knowledge System, so that they do not feel all knowledge came from the West. They need to be made aware, and proud, of the contribution of their ancestors in fields such as mathematics, calculus, and science. But we should be careful not to assume all Indian knowledge came only from Brahmins. We need to acknowledge the contributions of Buddhists and Jains as well as members of other castes and communities and tribes of Bharat. Knowledge exists in all languages of India, not just Sanskrit. And in our eagerness to be nationalistic, we should not succumb to the temptation of pseudo-history and pseudo-science that will make us the laughing stock of the world.


First Published in Mid-Day on 11th Feb 2024

Bapuni Sahu

Network Administrator

10 个月

Jay shree Ram ????????

回复
Pankaj Swain

Manager QC Microbiology (Injectable facility) Sterility Assurance, QMS, Media Fill participation, Successfully faced EU-GMP, UK-MHRA & USFDA.

11 个月

Great Sir !!

回复
Mukul Gandhi

Software architect

11 个月

nice article, Devdutt Pattanaik sir

回复
Nilesh Bhawsar (He/ His/ Him)

Director Information Technology at Fiserv

11 个月

Very interesting information, it also underlines the need to bring back study of Sanskrit to our education system so as the Indian knwledge system starts to reapply and the new generation start not only appreciate it but also contribute to making India the Knowledge hub for the globe once again.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Devdutt Pattanaik的更多文章

  • The Jealousy Of Old, Rich Men

    The Jealousy Of Old, Rich Men

    Old rich men are jealous of Gen Z. They watch with horror as young people use their smartphones to chat, video call…

    21 条评论
  • Artificial Intelligent Slaves

    Artificial Intelligent Slaves

    The desire to make artificial intelligence, robots, mechanical tools and newer technology comes from the same source…

    15 条评论
  • The Reality of Impermanence

    The Reality of Impermanence

    Vast amounts of gold were found in a Vishnu temple in Kerala. Politicians say this was done as a mark of devotion to…

    10 条评论
  • No Safe Space For Gen Z

    No Safe Space For Gen Z

    As Gen Z enters the workplace, they are hearing on social media handles that Boomers (grandparents) and Gen X (parents)…

    18 条评论
  • A Starry Network of Arabian Trade

    A Starry Network of Arabian Trade

    When Adam and Eve were cast out of Eden, Eve (Hawa) fell on the western coast of Arabia, at the port of Jeddah, city of…

    9 条评论
  • The Gratitude Trick

    The Gratitude Trick

    Have you seen the rich constantly talk about gratitude on social media? Are they thanking people for making them rich?…

    35 条评论
  • The Rational Attack On Science

    The Rational Attack On Science

    We often confuse rationality with science. Science demands evidence and experimentation.

    19 条评论
  • Is Sustainability the New Immortality?

    Is Sustainability the New Immortality?

    We frequently hear the word “sustainability” in the 21st century. This word wasn’t widely used in the 20th century, a…

    23 条评论
  • Tricking Ourselves Into Immortality

    Tricking Ourselves Into Immortality

    Indradyumna was told to leave paradise because no one on earth remembered him. He could return only if he found at…

    16 条评论
  • How Debates Are Increasingly Becoming a Duel

    How Debates Are Increasingly Becoming a Duel

    Debates are increasingly becoming a duel, so much so that if you align with one idea, the opposition can argue that you…

    25 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了