An Independent CFPB
Baron de Montesquieu, a proponent of the tripartite system of government

An Independent CFPB

The United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, sitting en banc, upheld the constitutionality of the structure of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau in PHH Corporation v. CFPB, No. 15-1177 (Jan. 31, 2018). There has been a lot reporting around this lengthy decision (there are 7 opinions, totaling 250 pages). And certainly, its fate in the Supreme Court is still up for grabs. Personally, I found the following passage from the majority opinion interesting:

There is nothing constitutionally suspect about the CFPB’s leadership structure. … there is no reason to assume an agency headed by an individual will be less responsive to presidential supervision than one headed by a group. It is surely more difficult to fire and replace several people than one. And, if anything, the Bureau’s consolidation of regulatory authority that had been shared among many separate independent agencies allows the President more efficiently to oversee the faithful execution of consumer protection laws. Decisional responsibility is clear now that there is one, publicly identifiable face of the CFPB who stands to account—to the President, the Congress, and the people— for all its consumer protection actions. The fact that the Director stands alone atop the agency means he cannot avoid scrutiny through finger-pointing, buck-passing, or sheer anonymity. What is more, in choosing a replacement, the President is unhampered by partisan balance or ex-officio requirements; the successor replaces the agency’s leadership wholesale. Nothing about the CFPB stands out to give us pause that it—distinct from other financial regulators or independent agencies more generally—is constitutionally defective. (35)

While this is of great consequence for the CFPB and its role in the regulation of the financial sector, it also has great consequence as a matter of separation of powers doctrine. The DC Circuit is giving Congress a lot of discretion in organizing the modern Administrative State. It is up to Congress to exercise that discretion responsibly.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

David Reiss的更多文章

  • Housing Finance Reform Endgame?

    Housing Finance Reform Endgame?

    The Hill published my column, There is Hope of Housing Finance Reform That Works for Americans. It opens, The Trump…

  • Does Historic Preservation Limit Affordable Housing?

    Does Historic Preservation Limit Affordable Housing?

    I answer that it can in CQ Researcher’s Historic Preservation: Can The Past Escape The Wrecking Ball? Many people fail…

  • In Spite of It All

    In Spite of It All

    Realtor.com quoted me in 3 Most Mind-Boggling Housing Turf Wars Ever—and What They Can Teach Us All.

    1 条评论
  • Unfair, Unlawful and Abusive

    Unfair, Unlawful and Abusive

    I signed on to a Memorandum in Support of a bill to amend New York's consumer protection law to make it consistent with…

  • Financing The American Dream

    Financing The American Dream

    I published Financing The American Dream in the May/June 2019 issue of the ABA’s Probate & Property magazine. it opens,…

  • Skyscraper’s Future up in The Air

    Skyscraper’s Future up in The Air

    The New York Law Journal quoted me in Upper West Side Skyscraper’s Future Uncertain After NY State Court Ruling. The…

  • Luxury Rental Turned Into College Dorm

    Luxury Rental Turned Into College Dorm

    Realtor.com quoted me in ‘Help! My Luxury Rental Was Turned Into a College Dorm’.

    1 条评论
  • Housing Policy, Going Forward

    Housing Policy, Going Forward

    The Hill published a column of mine, The Next Two Years of Federal Housing Policy Could Be Positive under Mark…

  • Protecting Small Businesses

    Protecting Small Businesses

    Students in my Community Development Clinic and I have a column in the New York Law Journal, Small Business Jobs…

  • Cutting Back on Community Reinvestment

    Cutting Back on Community Reinvestment

    Bloomberg Law quoted me in Banks Look to Narrow Exams Under Community Reinvestment Act. It opens, Banks see an opening…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了