The Inaccuracy of Recession Forecasts and the Ongoing Narrative Shifts

The prediction of a recession fluctuates widely depending on the source, with economists often shifting their forecasts dramatically. Recently, the prevailing narrative suggests that a recession is improbable in 2024 and beyond, a stark contrast from previous years. In January 2023, a survey of 70 economists by The Wall Street Journal indicated a 61% chance of a recession, but independent economist James F. Smith disagreed, predicting only a 1% likelihood. The current outlook is optimistic, with many experts, including Goldman Sachs' chief economist, projecting a low probability of recession in the near future. This volatility in economic predictions raises questions about the underlying factors driving such fluctuations.

Assessing the Likelihood of a Recession: The Role of a Strong Labor Market

James Smith emphasized the strength of the labor market, a point now echoed by other forecasters, noting record employment numbers and relatively confident consumer sentiment. However, while U.S. unemployment remains low and jobless claims are historically low, there is a slow but consistent rise in unemployment levels. Despite seemingly positive indicators, mass layoffs at major companies like IBM, Google, Microsoft, and Goldman Sachs in 2023, with continued layoffs in 2024, suggest a less robust labor market. Hiring rates are not keeping pace with economic growth, leading to sluggish employment mobility.

Inflation Management: Accomplishment or Fiasco?

James F. Smith highlighted another factor suggesting a low chance of a 2023 recession: the Federal Reserve's aggressive measures to combat rising inflation. These actions led to the lowest money supply levels in 70 years, eventually resulting in a decline in inflation. However, this decline took time, with inflation reaching a high of 9.1% by mid-2022, contrary to Fed Chair Jerome Powell's earlier assertions that inflation would be temporary. The Fed's misjudgment of the inflation's source, attributing it to excess demand rather than post-pandemic supply chain disruptions, raises questions about its handling of the situation. Although the inflation rate has decreased to 3.1% as of February 2024, it remains above the Fed's target of under 2%. Additionally, while some indicators suggest that people are financially stable, such as a significant portion repaying credit card debt in full, there are concerns about high debt levels and access to key purchases like real estate, leading to what some call a "trapped-in-place economy”.

Unpredicted Variables

The final factor to consider is the presence of unknown unknowns, which can unexpectedly disrupt the economy. James F. Smith notes that every recession is unique, and understanding the causes isn't always straightforward. However, the possibility of future mistakes remains. While this doesn't necessarily mean a recession is imminent, it does suggest that challenges may lie ahead. As the Wall Street Journal indicated in January, even if a recession is avoided, the economic conditions may still feel like one.

Read more here…

Stay ahead of the curve with our team's expert guidance. Contact Us Today!