Impact of CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING ON FOUNDER-EMPLOYEE EQUITY (pt. 2)

Corporate changes, such as mergers, acquisitions, or restructurings, can have significant implications for equity distribution, stock options, and vesting schedules.

Today’s article offers an in-depth examination of how companies and stakeholders can effectively navigate these challenges, protect their interests, and ensure equitable outcomes during corporate transformations.

Understanding the Corporate Change Landscape: Mergers, Acquisitions, and Restructurings

Types of Corporate Changes and its effects on Equity

• Mergers: When two companies combine to form a new entity or one company absorbs another, creating operational, structural, and ownership changes.
• Acquisitions: One company acquires another, resulting in shifts in control, potentially leading to equity redistribution and adjustments to stock option plans.
• Corporate Restructuring: This could involve changing the company’s structure, operations, or financial arrangements, including debt restructuring, spin-offs, or even recapitalization.

Equity Dilution and Redistribution

Corporate changes often lead to equity dilution or redistribution. During mergers or acquisitions, the acquiring entity may issue new shares to existing stakeholders or merge equity pools, altering ownership percentages. This is particularly significant for shareholders, founders, and employees holding large equity stakes.

• Equity Dilution: Issuing new shares can dilute the ownership stakes of existing shareholders. Companies need to be transparent about the percentage of dilution and how the new share structure will be divided.
• Fair Valuation: When equity is redistributed, a fair valuation of the acquired or merged entity is essential. Independent valuations ensure that stakeholders receive a fair share of the company’s worth in the form of new equity.

In some cases, stakeholders (particularly investors) may have anti-dilution provisions in their contracts. These provisions protect shareholders from excessive dilution by adjusting the conversion price of preferred shares to the lowest price at which new shares are issued or providing additional shares.

During a corporate change, equity held in one company may need to be converted into equity in another. The mechanics of this conversion depend on the terms of the deal, including any liquidation preferences and conversion ratios.

In many cases, corporate changes involving equity redistribution require approval from a majority of shareholders. Companies must communicate the implications of the change and allow shareholders to vote on the terms.

Stock Options and Corporate Restructuring

Key Considerations for Stock Option Holders

Corporate changes can be disruptive for stock option holders, who may face uncertainty about the value of their options and whether they will retain them post-transaction. Several critical issues need to be addressed:

• Acceleration of Vesting: One of the most common provisions in stock option agreements is accelerated vesting in the event of a merger or acquisition. This allows employees to vest all or part of their unvested options ahead of schedule.
• Option Cash-Out: In some transactions - especially where the company operates a restrictive stock options program that prevents holders from selling their shares to third-party investors until the company is sold, IPOs, restructured, or approved of the sale - stock option holders may be offered a cash-out for their options.
• Replacement Options: Alternatively, stock option holders may be issued new options in the acquiring company. These replacement options may have new terms, including adjusted strike prices and vesting schedules, often reflecting the acquiring company’s stock price and future performance.

Vesting Schedules and Corporate Change

Impact of Mergers and Acquisitions on Vesting Schedules

Vesting schedules, which determine when employees gain ownership of their stock options or equity, are often disrupted by corporate changes. The key concerns for vesting during such events include:

• Vesting Acceleration: As noted earlier, acceleration clauses may trigger the immediate vesting of some or all unvested options.
• Deferred Vesting: In some deals, unvested options may continue to vest according to their original schedule, but under the terms of the new corporate structure. This allows companies to maintain long-term incentives for employees post-merger or acquisition.

Employee Retention Post-Corporate Change

One of the most significant challenges during corporate restructuring or acquisitions is retaining key talent. If employees are concerned about losing equity or options, they may leave, damaging the company’s continuity and operational performance.

During restructuring or acquisition, companies may offer retention bonuses or new equity grants to key employees —cash or equity grants that vest after a certain period—to incentivize employees to stay post-transaction.

In some other cases, unvested stock options in the pre-acquisition company may be rolled over into stock options in the acquiring company, subject to new terms and conditions or stock option refreshers will be issued after a corporate change to replace outdated options or offer additional compensation for employees staying with the company. These options are typically subject to new vesting schedules.

Legal and Tax Considerations in Equity and Stock Options During Corporate Change

Tax Implications of Stock Option Changes

Corporate restructuring can trigger significant tax consequences for stock option holders, depending on how options are treated during the transaction.

• Incentive Stock Options (ISOs) vs. Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs): The tax treatment of ISOs and NSOs differs, and corporate changes may affect the tax obligations of employees exercising these options. For example, if ISOs are converted into NSOs during an acquisition, employees may lose favorable tax treatment.
• Capital Gains: The sale or conversion of stock options during corporate restructuring can trigger capital gains taxes. Companies should provide employees with clear guidance on the tax implications of their options and any potential opportunities to minimize tax liabilities.

Legal Provisions for Equity Protection

• Change of Control Provisions: Change of control provisions in equity agreements define what happens to equity or stock options in the event of a corporate transaction. These provisions are critical for ensuring that stakeholders are treated fairly.
• Legal Review of Agreements: Companies undergoing restructuring should conduct a thorough legal review of all equity agreements, stock option plans, and shareholder agreements to ensure compliance with applicable laws and the protection of stakeholder rights.

Communication Strategies: Ensuring Transparency During Corporate Change

Employee Communication and Engagement

During corporate changes, maintaining open and transparent communication with employees is essential to ensure engagement and retention.

Companies should provide clear, detailed explanations of how equity and stock options will be affected by the corporate change. Employees need to understand how their incentives are protected and what steps they should take. Hosting open forums, such as town hall meetings or Q&A sessions, allows employees to raise concerns and receive direct answers from leadership. This can help alleviate uncertainty and reinforce trust in the company’s leadership.

Shareholder Communication and Voting

For shareholders, transparency is critical when corporate changes involve equity redistribution or restructuring. Companies must provide detailed transaction documents about the terms of the deal, including equity conversion ratios, valuation adjustments, and voting rights, and engage in shareholder approval for equity-related changes. Companies must facilitate shareholder votes and ensure that all parties have the information needed to make informed decisions.

Additional Considerations: Future-Proofing Equity Plans

1. Provisions for Future Equity Adjustments

• Right of First Refusal (ROFR): Many startups include a Right of First Refusal in their shareholder agreements, which allows the company or existing shareholders to buy back shares before they are sold to an outside party.
• Buyback Clauses: Founders and employees leaving the company before vesting completion may be subject to buyback clauses, where the company has the right to repurchase vested shares, often at the lower of fair market value or cost price.

2. Long-Term Incentive Plans (LTIPs)

• Alternative to Stock Options: Companies may introduce Long-Term Incentive Plans (LTIPs) as alternatives or complements to traditional stock options. LTIPs are often performance-based and can include various forms of compensation such as restricted stock units (RSUs), phantom stock, or cash bonuses tied to company performance.

3. Equity Management Software

• Cap Table Management: With equity becoming a critical component of compensation and retention, startups often use specialized equity management software (e.g., Carta, Pulley, Capdesk) to manage their cap tables, employee stock options, and vesting schedules. This ensures accuracy, compliance, and ease of communication with stakeholders.

Conclusion

Corporate changes such as mergers, acquisitions, or restructuring can be complex, especially when it comes to equity distribution, stock options, and vesting schedules. Companies must be proactive in developing strategies that protect stakeholders’ interests, maintain employee incentives, and ensure a smooth transition. By understanding the potential impacts, legal considerations, and best practices for managing equity during these events, businesses can navigate corporate changes effectively and ensure long-term success.

About Legal Bytes

We are Adune Legal’s weekly Newsletter, which simplifies the Law for Busy Executives, Entrepreneurs, and Tech Enthusiasts interested in the legal aspects of Business, Technology, and Intellectual Property.

Subscribed

We love emails from our readers— reply to this email and let us know your thoughts and suggestions.

WAIT!!!

We're excited to announce that paid subscribers can access

• Q&A sessions with Nneoma Grace via chats on Substack.
• Detailed Legal Templates and examples to save you time and legal fees
• Expert Interviews and Case Studies

Don't miss out on these perks - subscribe today and start enjoying it!

Thanks for reading Legal Bytes

Adune Legal’s Team

P.S. Like Legal Bytes? Please forward us to a friend.

P.P.S. Was this publication forwarded to you? Sign up here & see previous publications.