Imitation is the Sincerest Form of Fraud: Law Firm Website Cloning and Ethical Responses

A growing online scam involves cloning a law firm's website to perpetrate fraud. Victim-firms face serious legal, ethical, and reputational risks. Law firms must take swift action to protect their clients, staff, and the public from harm. A step-by-step approach, tethered to the Rules of Professional Conduct, should be planned out before disaster strikes.

1. Immediate Steps:

a. Report the Fraud: The first step is to report the cloned website to the relevant authorities, including:

• Retain Counsel: Ethics counsel should be engaged at the outset, or better yet - retained before the fraud even occurs.
• Law enforcement: File a report with local police and/or the FBI, particularly the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3).
• Domain host: Contact the web hosting service of the fraudulent site to request a takedown.
• Search engines: Notify search engines like Google about the fraudulent site to reduce its visibility in search results.
• ICANN: File a complaint with ICANN for unauthorized use of a domain name that closely mimics the law firm’s website.

b. Notify Clients and the Public: The firm should immediately notify its clients, vendors, and partners of the scam to prevent them from falling victim. Use all available communication channels, including a prominent notice on the legitimate website. This is particularly important if the legitimate website allows for payment or the transmission of documents.

c. Internal Investigation and Mitigation:

• Evaluate Security Measures: Assess whether the firm’s own security has been compromised (e.g., data breaches) that could have facilitated the cloning or scam.
• Improve Website Security: Take steps to enhance the security of the firm’s website, including using SSL certificates, strong password protocols, and multi-factor authentication for site administrators.

2. Ethical Considerations:

The ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct place several ethical duties on attorneys, which are applicable in the event of a scam involving a cloned law firm website.

a. Confidentiality (Rule 1.6): Lawyers must make reasonable efforts to prevent the unauthorized disclosure or access to client information. If a cloned website is attempting to deceive clients into providing sensitive information, the firm must act immediately to safeguard client data. This could include informing clients of the breach and offering them assistance in protecting their own information.

b. Competence (Rule 1.1): A lawyer must provide competent representation, which includes safeguarding against reasonably foreseeable cyber threats. A law firm should have cybersecurity policies and procedures in place to mitigate the risks of website cloning and related fraud schemes.

c. Communications (Rule 1.4): The firm must keep clients reasonably informed about material developments related to the representation. If the cloned website could affect clients directly, the firm has a duty to communicate this issue and the steps it is taking to address it.

d. Supervision (Rules 5.1 and 5.3): Partners and other supervisory lawyers must ensure that the firm’s employees and tech vendors are compliant with cybersecurity protocols. Inadequate supervision could potentially lead to ethical violations if the cloned site results from lax security.

3. Insurance Considerations:

a. Cyber Liability Insurance: Regardless of size or practice area, law firms should maintain cyber liability insurance, which typically covers the costs associated with cyberattacks, including data breaches and fraud. Firms should immediately notify their insurance carrier about the cloned website incident to assess whether their policy provides coverage for:

• Response costs (e.g., hiring experts to take down the fraudulent site)
• Legal costs related to the incident
• Client notification expenses
• Potential claims of harm caused to clients

b. Professional Liability Insurance: If a scam using the cloned website results in client harm (if clients send funds or confidential information to the fraudster), the firm’s malpractice insurance may provide coverage. This could be particularly important if a client sues the firm for failing to protect their interests.

4. Legal Action Against the Scammers:

While often challenging, depending on the jurisdiction and available evidence, the firm may also have civil legal remedies against the scammers. This could include:

• Filing for an injunction to stop the operation of the cloned website.
• Pursuing civil claims for trademark infringement, unfair competition, or other legal violations if the scammers are within the jurisdiction.

However, this approach may be difficult as scammers are usually anonymous or located overseas.

5. Long-Term Preventative Measures:

a. Monitor Online Presence: Law firms should regularly monitor the internet for any unauthorized use of their branding or website. There are services available that can help detect duplicate websites and other online impersonations early.

b. Client Education: Firms should educate their clients on how to identify scams and fraud, especially concerning the firm’s communications. Clients should be advised to verify any unusual requests for payment or sensitive information, and to contact the firm directly if they suspect fraud.

c. Domain Name Protection: To prevent similar incidents, law firms should consider purchasing domain names similar to their primary domain to reduce the chance of scammers purchasing a similar domain to clone the website.

d. Intellectual Property Protection: Law firms should protect their brand through IP protection. Register the firm’s name, logo, and other key identifiers as trademarks and secure copyrights for their original website content and marketing materials, to help safeguard the firm's digital presence. Monitoring for potential infringements and enforcing their IP rights through cease-and-desist letters or legal action can further defend the firm's brand from misuse or dilution.

When a law firm's website is cloned for fraud, it must act quickly to protect clients, maintain its ethical obligations, and mitigate damage.

The firm should also review its insurance policies to ensure that adequate coverage exists for cybersecurity and professional liability. Preventative measures such as enhanced security protocols, domain monitoring, and client education can reduce the risk of future incidents. By following the guidance of the ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct and adhering to best practices, law firms can minimize the potential harm to clients and their reputation.

Let's chat about better practice, less stress.