"I'm afraid I can't do that Dave".

"I'm afraid I can't do that Dave".

The escalating debate over AI has become the cause celeb as proponents go about replacing tasks, jobs and functions that are/were handled or performed by humans.

In Stanley Kubrick’s stunning and prescient chef d’overe “2001: A Space Odyssey, one shot in the film chillingly foreshadows the brink upon which we are poised. 

In the film, while two astronauts quietly discuss their growing concern over their onboard computer, the HAL 9000, the camera slowly moves in on the “eye” of HAL. It becomes clear that the computer is lip reading, learning and, as we soon discover, becoming an independent thinker.

So much so that when astronaut Dave asks him to “Open the pod bay doors HAL” the computer replies in a cooly seductive and passive aggressive voice: 

“ I’m afraid I can’t do that Dave.”

Can’t or won’t? 

Spoiler Alert: If you haven’t seen the film, read no further.

Dave realizes the only way to regain control is to dismantle the computer. As HAL “dies,” he descends into mournful mindlessness. 

Dave reclaims power over his fate and when retired, his embryonic self floats across the screen, ushering in a new order.

Unlike Dave, we cannot “kill” our HALs. 

But we must regulate their use and applications where doing so, like other advancements in say, weaponry, pharmaceuticals or malevolent use of the internet itself, threatens humanity and well-being.

While those who sit at keyboards and spreadsheets rub their hands over anticipated outcomes, they too should keep a watchful eye on their clever inventions. 

Who’s to say these entities might not evolve to engineer their engagers very redundancy?

 Reducing human essence and endeavors to mere data, who and what is safe from early or enforced obsolescence?  

Is this why we’ve yet to see populations on other planets in our solar system?

 Did their HALs outsmart them and the suspected glimpses we have of their technology are merely the robotic remains of civilizations long replaced by their own devices? 

Are we now the last outpost of humanity in our sphere, myopically making sure we are?

The money side of the AI debate will do nothing until/unless the ethics side becomes an active and palpable economic threat.

If every individual, group, organization, alliance, etc., standing for the rights of and protection of the copyright to our own essence, bands together and calls out the lack of ethics involved in the wholesale commandeering, replacing or replicating of humans with doppelg?ngers, we have a fighting chance to put guard rails around the very technology that could turn on every one of us and ever so patiently, with a watchful eye and a patronizing taunt, echo HAL and not “open our pod bay doors.”

 Causes and movements have efficacy and effect initiatives when they gain momentum, traction and become a financial, ethical and PR force with which to be reckoned.

This needs to happen yesterday.

Regulation or Cancellation?

It doesn’t get any bigger than this.

Great article Marice. The government needs to get involved yesterday. We all need to send emails to our representatives.

回复

Thanks dearest M for your customary pithy and incisive take on this. AI may be here to stay but I think you're dead right that original creators and copyright owners need to go on the offensive about the ethics of what's happening. There is a degree of blithe arrogance and presumption coming from tech companies about their ability and right to source their innovations freely from other people's work and intellectual copyright. As someone at Amazon said to my agent Maxine about their apparent plan to repurpose recordings of my voice to this end "It's all just data to us". Fortunately we won that particular argument due to her prescience at the contract stage, but it's interesting to see how this is being discussed in other creative communities too, including visual artists and photographers who are pointing out that in order to create AI artworks algorithms will have previously scanned millions of their original images. Likewise music, as evidenced by the current case of the cloning of Drake and The Weekend to create a supposed collaborative song without their consent. I'm all in favour of technical innovation but making money out of other people's work without due permission or payment verges on downright theft and dishonesty.

Ben Sullivan

Your Happy Place is calling... are you Home? Realtor? at Coldwell Banker Studio City

1 年

I had an interaction with a buyer just last week who is launching a new company and is setting about the social marketing... so grateful that we ended up on a phone call where he shared with me that the entire script for his product was written by ChatGPT, and that he, at first, had cloned a super famous actor's voice for this launch, and he played it for me--and, it was indistinguishable. Scary. I was hired and paid, but left feeling so uneasy and a multitude of other fears about what might be coming. Like Thompson said... the pivot.

回复

Thanks for this. I’ve got my union pensions waiting for me if it gets really bad really quickly. Many (most?) talent don’t have that luxury.

回复
Jeff Plunk, Actor/Voice Actor

Actor & Voice Over Renegade / Storyteller delivering Broadcast-Quality Voice Over Recordings From My Home Studio for Commercials, Narration, Promo, Political, Web Video, Explainer Video, & More

1 年

Great article Marice. I think about the outcome of AI daily and it scares the crap out of me.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Marice Tobias的更多文章

  • TMI is TMI

    TMI is TMI

    Some years ago, I started collecting what I call “Nightmare Specs”- that section on copy and scripts that describes…

    2 条评论
  • The Game has changed. So must the Rules.

    The Game has changed. So must the Rules.

    There is an entitlement raging through the creative community like the virus we just battled the last three plus years.…

    17 条评论
  • AI:The Speeding Train

    AI:The Speeding Train

    I used to think the only way earthlings would stop slugging it out with one another was when the Mother Ship showed up…

    3 条评论
  • AI 2.0: I'm not afraid to do that Dave.

    AI 2.0: I'm not afraid to do that Dave.

    Responses to “ I’m afraid I can’t do that Dave” are loud and clear: AI is top of mind, especially throughout the Arts…

    3 条评论
  • TMI is TMI

    TMI is TMI

    Technology has made the world more accessible and less. Accelerated by COVID, it has all but eliminated the value-added…

    12 条评论
  • "Mind the Gap"

    "Mind the Gap"

    The original use of this term was in the 1960’s London Tube station, Embankment, warning riders to be careful due to…

    4 条评论
  • The Promise

    The Promise

    In the ad game, The Promise is the “unique selling proposition” that distinguishes our “Hero, ie, client, product or…

    10 条评论
  • The Attention Economy

    The Attention Economy

    Yes, it’s a thing. Just when I think I have a fix on say, the Metaverse, this pops up and sends me into FOMO…

    2 条评论
  • True North

    True North

    Through the ages, the North Star has been a touchstone for mankind far above all other stars. Also known as Polaris, it…

    14 条评论
  • The IT Factor

    The IT Factor

    With every new Quarter, many more submissions than usual are sent to agents and managers. Most do not get any response,…

    10 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了