IKEA - A Case Study

Background of IKEA

Established as a small Swedish furniture store in 1943 by Ingvar Kamprad, IKEA has grown into a global retail powerhouse with a profound vision to improve the lives of its diverse stakeholders. The name "IKEA" is an acronym derived from Kamprad's initials and the first letters of the farm and village of his upbringing: Elmtaryd and Agunnaryd, respectively. Emphasizing consumer welfare, the company is dedicated to offering high-quality products at affordable prices without compromising the interests of other stakeholders, including employees and vendors. As of 2015, the company was the world’s largest furniture retailer, with a net profit of 3.5 billion Euros from total sales of 31.9 billion Euros. Today, IKEA remains a venerated global retailer, with a presence in 47 countries encompassing over 365 stores. This enduring success can be attributed to IKEA's masterful utilization of market segmentation strategies, which has earned it acclaim for its well-designed furniture, exuding the distinctive allure of Scandinavian aesthetics at budget-friendly rates.

Problem Statement

The home furnishing industry confronts a multitude of cost-related hurdles, including customer price sensitivity, the necessity for premium retail locations, and logistics and supply chain expenses. Evolving consumer behaviors, such as a growing emphasis on sustainability and a preference for digital solutions, further intensify these challenges. In this context, IKEA, as a prominent player in the retail furnishing domain, distinguishes itself through a price leadership strategy, necessitating efficient operations without compromising quality. To achieve this, the company has implemented strategic actions and initiatives, such as optimizing store locations, one-way store layouts, reliance on written product information, and the use of lightweight and durable transport solutions. In this case study, we explore the cost-related challenges faced by IKEA while adapting to evolving consumer demands. Specifically, our investigation centers on the role of sustainable supply chain practices, organizational culture, and innovation in overcoming these challenges. By delving into these dimensions, this paper aims to offer valuable insights and recommendations to help IKEA navigate the intricacies of cost management within a dynamic business environment.

Minimizing Costs and Adapting to Changing Consumer Behavior: A Supply Chain and Innovation Perspective for IKEA

Challenges

From a supply chain perspective, IKEA faces the challenge of minimizing costs while maintaining product quality. Relying solely on low-cost manufacturing hubs like China and India proves challenging due to significant transportation costs to European markets and disparities in design expertise (Baraldi, 2003). Thus, IKEA must strike a balance between low-cost manufacturing and competent vendors. Moreover, the rising consumer preference for sustainability necessitates cost-effective integration of sustainability across the supply chain, from sourcing to the product life cycle. Modular design approaches and repair, reuse, and recycle programs emerge as potential solutions.

Regarding innovation, IKEA's strategic store locations strike a balance between customer access and proximity to distribution centers. However, with changing consumer behavior and the increasing reliance on technologies such as VR and AR, IKEA must evaluate the effectiveness of its current store designs against competitors employing cost-effective AR and VR solutions to enhance the customer experience. Today, almost half of the customers who visit furniture stores use their smartphones to gather information before their visit (Rangaswamy, Nawaz & Changzhuang, 2022). This suggests that customers tend to switch between different sources of information. A proactive approach of redesigning warehouses, stores, and experience centers to cater to evolving customer needs becomes imperative.

Expanding into new markets presents challenges for large organizations like IKEA, as differences in language, culture, and legal requirements can hinder seamless operations (Etukudoh & Joe, 2019). Despite its culture of openness and effective communication, IKEA's organizational culture remains deeply influenced by its Swedish roots, potentially limiting its ability to cater to diverse cultural preferences of global consumers.

Potential Solutions

???????????In the following proposed solutions, seemingly disparate ideas are intentionally interconnected, highlighting their alignment with a strategic theme. It is crucial to recognize that strategic theme being explored here is, cost-efficiency through innovation.

1.????Organizational Culture

???????????The cultural roots of IKEA, deeply influenced by its Swedish origins and the region of Sm?land in southern Sweden, imbue the company with values of strong work ethic, community support, and a close connection with nature (Ericsson, 2018). This organizational culture, characterized by enthusiasm, unity, and a determined spirit, serves as a catalyst for efficiency and employee satisfaction. However, to further empower IKEA towards innovative and cost-effective solutions, fostering an inclusive culture becomes imperative.

An inclusive culture leverages emotional maturity and personal growth to enhance organizational capabilities and gain a competitive edge (Oshiotse & O'Leary, 2007). Chaudhry, Paquibut, and Tunio (2021) assert that actively recruiting employees with diverse inherent traits (such as ethnicity, gender, language, religion, and abilities) and acquired traits (such as educational background, marital background, and work experiences) enables companies to outperform and out-innovate their counterparts. Given the strategic direction of cost-efficiency through innovation, IKEA must incorporate inclusivity metrics into every facet of its organization.

This entails hiring individuals based on behavioral competencies in addition to technical competencies and fostering a culture that promotes and encourages inclusivity throughout the organization. By embracing inclusivity and diversity, IKEA can unlock a wealth of innovative solutions to address its multifaceted challenges, including those related to costs. The subsequent section explores a modular design approach for IKEA, exemplifying the interconnectedness of the proposed solutions. This approach enables IKEA to design furniture that caters to multiple cultural contexts by leveraging modular components and minimizing the number of new parts per design.

2.????Sustainable Supply Chain (Circular Business Model)

Circular business models are gaining traction, necessitating a shift in mindset and the adoption of strategies that promote product longevity and circulation. The aftermarket plays a pivotal role in a circular economy, enabling companies to create value through additional services and spare parts. Design strategies focused on extended use and multiple use-cycles facilitate the transition to a circular business model (Malmgren & Larsson, 2020).

A modular design approach offers benefits in terms of reduced part variety and improved logistics planning. By creating standardized design elements, IKEA can effectively manage demand across their reuse, repair, and refurbishment departments, while minimizing costs associated with the use of modular parts. Engaging manufacturers in low-cost hubs like China for producing modular design elements further enhances cost-effectiveness.

To overcome potential limitations of modular design, a blockchain-enabled solution can be introduced, allowing designers worldwide to contribute to IKEA's product portfolio using the modular parts. This approach reduces costs and fosters innovation by tapping into global talent. The implementation of an inclusive culture facilitates cross-cultural communication, innovation, and resource optimization. A strong quality control program is necessary to ensure designs align with IKEA's quality standards and turn the program into a prestigious brand partnership opportunity.

Integrating IKEA's supply chain with blockchain technology strengthens sustainability efforts by effectively incorporating the IKEA supplier Code of Conduct (IWAY) (Laurin & Fantazy, 2017). Blockchain enables cost-effective marketing of IKEA's sustainability initiatives, empowering customers to track the authenticity of sustainable products they purchase.

Considering a subscription model can help IKEA address evolving consumer needs and predict return logistics demand. By leveraging Artificial Intelligence (AI) in the supply chain, IKEA can enhance demand predictability in both forward and reverse logistics. Predictive market intelligence becomes instrumental in cost optimization, particularly for organizations like IKEA, where the supply chain is a core competency (Anaplan, n.d.).

3.????AR/VR Solutions

As a global leader in the home furnishing industry, IKEA continues to seek diversification in emerging economies like India and China, capitalizing on economies of scale to reinforce its cost leadership strategy. To achieve cost-effective expansion, IKEA can leverage advanced technologies such as Augmented Reality (AR), Virtual Reality (VR), and Artificial Intelligence (AI).

VR presents an opportunity to revolutionize furniture retailing by allowing consumers to virtually inspect and experience products, eliminating the need for physical contact (Oh, Yoon & Shyu, 2008). By developing an Internet-based Virtual Reality Integrated Solution (VRIS) system that is cited in the study by Oh, Yoon & Shyu, IKEA can enable customers to visualize furniture coordination and create immersive product experiences, positively influencing their decision-making. VR-integrated websites can serve as virtual entry points to IKEA's physical stores, establishing a click-and-brick strategy that adapts to fast-paced and unpredictable markets. IKEA can offer the VRIS solution as a licensed product for interior designers to design home interiors using IKEA products, effectively transforming these designers into virtual IKEA stores.

Alternatively, IKEA can directly provide the VRIS solution to consumers, augmenting it with AI capabilities for personalized interior design experiences. Users can scan their rooms, input preferences for themes or utilities, and leverage the AI engine to provide tailored design recommendations. By selecting themes like outdoor or utilities like gym, users can access design solutions aligned with their preferences. The solution can also suggest enhancements for partially furnished spaces or provide recommendations for fully furnished areas. This approach enables IKEA to adapt to evolving consumer journeys while facilitating cost-effective virtual expansion into tier 2 and tier 3 cities in emerging markets. Integrating the VRIS solution with IKEA's supply chain further enhances operational efficiency.

Pointers for Implementation

To effectively implement the proposed recommendations, strategic alignment is crucial, beginning with the identification of key performance indicators (KPIs). The sustainability balanced scorecard (SBSC) can serve as a valuable tool to ensure alignment with strategic goals. Once strategic alignment and KPIs are established, individual projects such as supply chain integration with blockchain, VR design solution, and modular design philosophy can be identified. Employing project management tools like Six Sigma is essential to monitor project progress, achieve goals, and address any deviations from milestones.

However, several challenges are associated with the implementation of these solutions. Firstly, given IKEA's deeply rooted Swedish culture, attempting to change organizational culture may face resistance from senior management. Carefully thought-out change management strategies must be employed to navigate this challenge effectively. Secondly, the modular design approach requires an iterative approach to gradually reduce the number of new parts per design. As suggested earlier, the modular design approach could limit the design outcomes if not implemented thoughtfully and strategically. Additionally, implementing AR/VR solutions through design vendors may require a shift from a business-to-consumer (B2C) approach to a business-to-business (B2B) approach, necessitating adjustments in the company's operational approach.

Lastly, successful implementation requires comprehensive change management efforts, potentially involving restructuring initiatives. For instance, the AR/VR solution and modular design approach may require effective vendor management to accommodate the involvement of new external stakeholders. Managing these challenges will be instrumental in driving successful implementation and realizing the potential benefits of the proposed solutions.

Implementation Plan

1.????Ensure strategic alignment of the proposed solutions using tools such as the sustainability balanced scorecard (SBSC).

2.????Identify Key Projects and related KPIs.

3.????Change Management - Communicate and ensure buy-in from senior management and the employees.

4.????Project execution - Measure, Adapt, and Reevaluate

Order of Implementation

1.??Implement an inclusive organizational culture.

2.??Launch a re-skilling and up-skilling program for employees.

3.??Integrate Supply Chain with AI/ML predictive capabilities.

4.??Launch the Furniture Subscription Model.

5.??AR/VR solution.

6.??Modular Design Approach.

7.??Integrate Supply Chain and AI capabilities with the AR/VR solution.

8.??Integrate the modular design approach with blockchain and smart contract.

?

The first step in the implementation plan involves fostering an inclusive organizational culture, as research demonstrates that such cultures enhance employee innovation and organizational agility (Chaudhry, Paquibut & Tunio, 2021).

To preserve the organizational culture and bolster employee morale, a re-skilling and up-skilling program should be incorporated. This program aligns the existing workforce with the evolving skill demands, reducing the need for extensive layoffs and costly hiring processes. Layoffs can create a negative perception and attitude towards the proposed solutions. Additionally, the process of layoffs and subsequent hiring can be time-consuming and costly. By investing in employee development, IKEA can ensure a smooth transition and maintain employee engagement throughout the implementation process.

To manage resources effectively, capital-intensive projects should be implemented in a phased manner. Adopting agile project management methodologies allows for iterative development, incorporating consumer feedback and enabling adjustments based on market dynamics. This approach ensures flexibility and responsiveness during implementation.

By proactively addressing these challenges and implementing the proposed solutions in a phased and agile manner, IKEA can navigate the implementation process effectively and maximize the benefits of the strategic initiatives.

Conclusion

The role of organizational culture is crucial in understanding an organization's performance as it adapts to changing circumstances within the framework of its established cultural norms (Colyer, 2000). For IKEA, whose culture is deeply influenced by national norms, expanding its global reach necessitates the adoption of inclusivity and diversity. By fostering an inclusive environment, IKEA can ensure that all employees feel valued and contribute effectively to organizational growth.

Traditionally, supply chain management (SCM) practices overlooked the strategic significance of suppliers and other actors in the supply chain. However, recent shifts in perspective highlight the vital role of SCM in global economies, emphasizing the interdependence among stakeholders. To achieve a competitive advantage through sustainable supply chains, organizations should prioritize collaboration and integration among key stakeholders, restructure procurement, operations, and distribution activities, and effectively incorporate sustainability initiatives across the entire supply chain.

In conclusion, IKEA can overcome cost-related challenges, promote growth, and maintain its competitive advantage in the home furnishing industry by embracing innovation, sustainability, organizational culture, and strategic initiatives. By implementing the proposed solutions, IKEA can establish itself as a leader in cost-effective operations, customer satisfaction, and sustainability, effectively meeting the evolving demands of the industry and consumer preferences. This case study underscores the importance of strategically aligned solutions that cut across various business disciplines to sustain a competitive edge in the global market.

?

References

Anaplan. (n.d.). What is Supply Chain Management? (Your guide to SCM). Anaplan.com. https://www.anaplan.com/blog/what-is-supply-chain-management/#:~:text=Supply%20management%20is%20made%20up,created%20from%20the%20demand%20plan

Baraldi, E. (2003, September). The places of IKEA: using space as a strategic weapon in handling resource networks. In Conference on Clusters, industrial Districts and Firms: The Challenge of Globalization, Modena, Italy. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Enrico-Baraldi/publication/228363998_The_Places_of_IKEA_Using_Space_as_a_Strategic_Weapon_in_Handling_Resource_Networks/links/00b7d526676486c20b000000/The-Places-of-IKEA-Using-Space-as-a-Strategic-Weapon-in-Handling-Resource-Networks.pdf

Chaudhry, I. S., Paquibut, R. Y., & Tunio, M. N. (2021). Do workforce diversity, inclusion practices, & organizational characteristics contribute to organizational innovation? Evidence from the UAE. Cogent Business & Management, 8(1), 1947549. https://doi.org/10.1080/23311975.2021.1947549

Colyer, S. (2000). Organizational Culture in Selected Western Australian Sport Organizations. Journal of Sport Management, 14(4), 321–341. https://doi.org/10.1123/jsm.14.4.321

Ericsson, A. (2018). Organizational Culture and Employee Loyalty: The Case of IKEA. https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:1192802/FULLTEXT02

Etukudoh, B., & Joe, E. J. D. (2019). IKEA's challenges and opportunities in Asia. Authorea Preprints. https://doi.org/10.22541/au.155595497.79027133

Laurin, F., & Fantazy, K. (2017). Sustainable supply chain management: a case study at IKEA. Transnational Corporations Review, 9(4), 309–318. https://doi.org/10.1080/19186444.2017.1401208

Malmgren, K., & Larsson, M. K. (2020). Reverse Logistics in the Transition towards Circular Economy-A Case Study of Customer Returns at IKEA. https://odr.chalmers.se/server/api/core/bitstreams/8b2b1667-c4e8-4b1f-9c99-c35a5af00e0f/content

Oh, H., Yoon, S. Y., & Shyu, C. R. (2008). How can virtual reality reshape furniture retailing?. Clothing and Textiles Research Journal, 26(2), 143-163. https://doi.org/10.1177/0887302X08314789

Oshiotse, A., & O’Leary, R. (2007). Corning creates an inclusive culture to drive technology innovation and performance. Global Business and Organizational Excellence, 26(3), 7–21. https://doi.org/10.1002/joe.20140

Rangaswamy, E., Nawaz, N., & Changzhuang, Z. (2022). The impact of digital technology on changing consumer behaviours with special reference to the home furnishing sector in Singapore. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 9(1), 1-10. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-022-01102-x