"I would rather clean the mold around the bathtub than read."
The Literacy Architects
We break down complex literacy routines into step-by-step plans and deliver PD to support you along the way.
In?an article ?in The Middle School Journal, the authors tell the story of a young reader who, "when asked if he would rather read a book or clean his room, responded, 'I would rather clean the mold around the bathtub than read'." Unfortunately, this sentiment can be heard in classrooms across the country; I know I've met a few similarly reluctant readers as a reading specialist.
There are different theories of why some students may be reluctant to read. Some students may not feel connected to the texts they are being asked to read -- with the characters, situations, and settings feeling far removed from their lived experiences. Others may not have learned how to connect with a text for purposes other than academic, so reading for pleasure doesn't feel natural to them. Still others may have difficulty decoding fluently, which can hinder comprehension and enjoyment of reading.
Studies have found that, on average,?boys read less than girls , and this can continue into adulthood. There have been plenty of theories proposed for why boys are more often reluctant readers, and some of the more popular ones include boys preferring nonfiction texts over the fictional stories that are often read at school,?not seeing reading as a masculine activity,?being more interested in activities other than reading,?or not finding any books that interest them.
领英推荐
If you have time, it's worth checking out?this panel discussion on how to get and keep boys reading , in which several authors, including Jeff Kinney (Diary of a Wimpy Kid?series) and Jon Scieszka (The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Fairly Stupid Tales) offer some insight on the topic. Scieszka states that many fictional stories include discussion of relationships and emotions, which boys may not have as much practice thinking and talking about. There are character-driven books out there that offer action?and?emotions—it's just a matter of searching them out and looking beyond the usual titles.
To help ease reluctance in your readers, try to stock your classroom library with a diverse selection of books and offer students choice in what they read. Make sure to include a wide array of both fiction and nonfiction titles, stories with both boys and girls as protagonists, less traditional formats like graphic novels and magazines, and a mix of genres -- including humor, historical fiction, and nonfiction texts on a variety of topics. When it comes to suggesting books for students, start by asking about a student's personal interests rather than what they are learning about at school.
Do you have any tips for engaging reluctant readers? We'd love to hear your ideas!
Academic Intervention Coordinator, Literacy Coach &Teacher
2 年This article hits home not only as an educator but as a boy mom. In From K-2 my son loved reading and then the light went dim. It wasn’t until he was introduced to dystopian novels that his excitement for reading returned.
Students as Powerful Navigators of School Success
2 年Wonderful and insightful article! I will share some additional tips. 1. Get to know the interests of your students and their lived experience in relationship to reading. 2. Preview and read a few pages from popular young adult literature (3 to 5 Books a week). 3. Create a comfortable reading area. 4. Read aloud a chapter book (alternating each month, between a male protagonist and a female protagonist). 5. Invite boy-popular authors into your classroom. Your students can interview them. 6. Plan a class trip to the public library. You can collect applications in advance for parents to fill out. Note: The current New York Public Library Card has Spiderman on it. 7. Book Recommendation Wall: Students can recommend books that their friends or classmates might like to read. 8. Create book clubs with roles. Students can select amongst three books. I am aware that some of my tips cost money. Donors Choose https://www.donorschoose.org is a fantastic organization that will help fund books, furniture, resources and author visits. Please share https://jonscieszka.com/guys-read with educators, students, and families. ??
Educational Sales Associate @ Amplify | Educational Leadership, Curriculum Development
2 年This article proves the need for High Quality Instructional Materials for our middle school students. Many districts seem to focus on K-5 resources because 6-8 teachers love to teach "their favorite novels" while neglecting the interest of their students. There are 6-8 literacy programs that have been created for this very reason. Amplify ELA is a solution to this tragic problem. Literacy, or illiteracy lasts a lifetime. Let's continue to keep middle schoolers engaged in reading after we've taught them how to read.