Was I good, or just unlucky??

In the professional world, much like in various aspects of life, our perception of success and failure can significantly influence our career trajectory. Attribution theory, which focuses on how individuals explain the causes of their outcomes, provides valuable insights into how attribution styles can impact career development.

Internal vs. External Attribution

Case 1: Consider Laura, a young marketer who has worked diligently to prepare a presentation for a key client, after her hard work pays off and the client decides to sign a significant contract.

1. Internal Attribution (Wins):

Laura attributes her success to her effort, in-depth research, and creativity. This internal attribution not only gives her a sense of personal satisfaction but also boosts her motivation. She starts seeking further opportunities to improve her skills and tackle new challenges, believing that her efforts can lead to positive results.

2. External Attribution (Wins):

Laura attributes the success to external factors such as luck and the support of a colleague. As a result, Laura feels less motivated to enhance her skills, thinking her success is more a product of favorable circumstances than of her dedication. This mindset may lead to stagnation in his career, causing him to miss growth opportunities.

Case 2: Despite Laura's efforts the client decides not to sign the contract.

Internal Attribution (Loss):

Laura attributes the outcome to something within her control, such as the need for better preparation or a stronger pitch. This internal attribution can be challenging emotionally, as it requires her to confront personal areas for improvement. However, it also motivates her to identify specific skills to enhance, such as refining her presentation style or strengthening her client engagement approach. This mindset reinforces resilience, as she learns from the setback and channels her focus into personal growth and skill development for future opportunities.

External Attribution (Loss):

In this case, Laura attributes the client’s decision to external factors, like the client’s budget constraints or market conditions. While this protects her self-esteem in the short term, it may also limit her motivation to reflect on her performance and make changes. By externalizing the cause of the loss, Laura may feel less compelled to improve her presentation approach, which could slow her development over time. This perspective might cause her to miss valuable lessons, potentially hindering her ability to proactively enhance her skills and resilience in future challenges.

Let's now see the possible combinations and their impacts:

? Top Left (External Win, Internal Loss): This combination may reduce drive to improve after wins but encourages accountability after losses, leading to self-improvement in setbacks.

? Top Right (Internal Win, Internal Loss): Consistently builds confidence and skill by taking ownership of both outcomes, fostering long-term growth and resilience.

? Bottom Left (External Win, External Loss): Reduces motivation to develop skills or make changes, which can lead to stagnation and missed growth opportunities.

? Bottom Right (Internal Win, External Loss): Encourages improvement after wins but hinders growth after losses, potentially slowing development in the face of challenges.?

Implications for Career Development

? Resilience and Growth: Take the example of Giulia, an engineer who faced a project that ultimately failed. Rather than becoming disheartened, Giulia reflects on the reasons behind the failure. By attributing the setback to a lack of preparation and poor design choices, she decides to invest time in learning new techniques and enhancing her skills. This proactive approach allows her to tackle the next project with greater confidence and capability, ultimately leading to significant success.

? Self-Regulation: In a corporate context, managers can encourage employees to reflect on their attributions. For instance, a workshop led by an industry thought leader might focus on how to handle feedback. Maria, an employee feeling frustrated by her lack of promotions, attends the workshop and learns the importance of attributing her experiences to internal factors, like the quality of her work. This new perspective motivates her to seek constructive feedback and work on self-improvement, eventually leading to the long-desired promotion.

? Leadership and Corporate Culture: Consider a company that fosters a culture of accountability and growth. Leaders celebrate successes while openly discussing failures, attributing setbacks to controllable factors rather than fate. This atmosphere encourages employees to take initiatives and not fear making mistakes. For example, the product development team feels more secure proposing innovative ideas, knowing that even if one fails, it will be seen as a learning opportunity rather than a reason for punishment.

Conclusion

The correlation between internal and external attributions and professional success is quite strong. Those who recognize the value of their efforts and capabilities tend to advance more rapidly in their careers by taking accountability, getting positive reinforcements, improving self-esteem, and embracing lifelong learning as well as a growth mindset. Investing in training and a corporate culture that promotes internal attribution can create a more motivated and resilient work environment, significantly contributing to the career development of employees.

References

? Weiner, B. (1985). An Attributional Theory of Achievement Motivation and Emotion. Psychological Review.

? Dweck, C. S. (2006). Mindset: The New Psychology of Success. Random House.

? Seligman, M. E. P. (1975). Helplessness: On Depression, Development, and Death. W.H. Freeman.

Dave Ulrich Marc Effron Paolo Gallo Marta Ambroziak Sanjay Patel Matt Burns Roberto Farina Marco Paracciani Nico Sacco Elia Congiu Pierpaolo Aureli Daniela Ippedico Anna Rossetti Dario Montalcini Leigh Nicholson Vanessa Gleason Alastair Lindsay Christopher Nicholas Etienne Grisvard Yasutaka Zushi Petr Galík Rob Pretty Monika Moser Silvia Baronio Matteo de Padova Marco Izzo Angelo D'Attoma Teresa Mazur Erik Johnson Kate Gaston Zofia Zakrzewska Agnieszka Adamska Justyna Szumińska Jaroslaw Fotyga, Chartered FCIPD Carolina Jara Ronda Anna Pogonowska (Burzynska) Millie Flanagan Belén Fernández Laura Leivo Natalie Goffin Dr. Daniel Neubauer Aga Sieradzka ?? Experience Belonging Vincenzo Perrone Silvia Bagdadli Eriq Tshhims Tom Sneddon Michala Michael Ferdinando Pennarola Jennifer Ryan Thorsten Eger (PhD) Luca Solari David Green ???? André Strassinger (We/Us) Sandy Wang David McLean Christopher Rainey Cosimo Genovese Shane Kemp Ekta Vyas Ph.D Volker Jacobs Terence Mauri Chamseddine Othmane ICF-PCC Assoc.CIPD HARVARD Jean Cheng Ogrisek Jean Claude Le Grand Jean Cheng Ogrisek Rafael Altavini Kirsten Vasey Massimo Malaguti Sienna Grey Samuel Mete Sanja Centineo Rachael Woodman Christophe Touton Dr Dieter Veldsman (Phd) Mark Thomas Shahid Mahmood ┃CHRMP, Certified OD Specialist┃ Alessandro Martelli Keely (Straw) Dyson Sophia Kadar, CPTM, GMS-T Yasmina Mallem John Holme Lorenzo Giordano Lenita Torr?o Eisner Anna Stanich Antonios Ermenidis Claire Regis Matteo Ercole Giuseppe Scalia Victor Chiesa Reuter Elaine Igoe Money Chin Francesco Manghisi Dogan Basar, Ph.D. Navid Nazemian, PCC Gaetano Capozzolo Massimo Muzzì Andrea Petrone Annabelle Thebaud Matthew Eatwell Alina Fito Farida Eldeftar Claudio Bozzo Francesca Cortella Reiss Gregory Nuno Bou?a Marie-Christine Bouthor Liubov Bombin Guillermo Miranda Anabel Fall Alexander Zinser Alexander Palm Nicola Pistillo Anna Di Stefano Marica Montanaro Pedro Martin Massimo Rigodanza Maria Traficanti Neva Ferro Casagrande Roberta Protopapa Julie Henning Julia Enning Massimo Buonaiuto Malgorzata Cyz Matthias Frye Elora Wilbur Francesca Tallarida Alberto-Giovanni Busetto, PhD Felicia Brown Maya van Look Jenny Bach Chantal Catrin Palm Cristina Hurjui Alex Lawrence NAZIM üNLü Elsa Callini Dejan Atanasov Lisa Ryzhykova Michael Piker Guillermo Miranda Stephane Charbonnier Allison Pinkham Michael D'Ambrose Terrance C. Christopher Lind Beatriz Rodriguez Kumar Kymal HR Leaders atlas copilot Dimitri Jovanovic Falguni Shah Namita Pandey Terence Mauri Zora Lazarov Ghausi (Mr) ,CIPD , XLRI , IIM, ISO Shiladitya Chatterjee Sharon Akerele Susanne Marianne Bauer Jenny Bach Donika HASANAJ Yasmina Mallem Tuyana Chimitova Jenn Fenwick Bo Vialle-Derksen Merve Oklap Prabhjit Kaur Chana Sharon Akerele Jenny Bach Donika HASANAJ Claire Rutherford Weronika Jankowska-Tofani Daria Holm Cecilia Crossley Kimon Georgiou Nina (Tianhui) Grosse Mark Whittle Brent Cassell Neil C. Fabrice Spenninck Indy Lachhar,MCIPD Pinky Lakhia, ACC Rich Cober (he-him) Régis Mulot Cian O Morain Chantal Steen Kristin Barton Alex Browne Michiel van Duin Dr. Jutta H?usler Adele Swan Denise Grieffenhagen Sandra Forster-Bernacchia Anna S?vinger ?slund Jette Lydersen Anna Conneryd Lundgren Hanne Lehtovuori Carol Xu Sofia Brenas Alexandra List Felipe Hessel Bill Baker Giacomo Mazzariello Jackie Maestri Dion Love Jessie Knight Ceree Eberly