Hydrogen v Electric Cars - Which One Will Come Out On Top?
Jay Barnard
Recruitment Consultant specializing in Hydrogen Fuel Cell and Electrolyzer Tech
Hydrogen v Electric Vehicles
Introduction
Hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe. It makes up 90% of all matter, but you won't find it on Earth because it's so light that it escaped into space as soon as our planet formed. However, hydrogen can be produced by splitting water molecules into hydrogen and oxygen using electricity or sunlight — two things that will always be available in abundance for us to harness. Better yet, its only byproduct is water vapor!
What is Hydrogen?
If you've ever heard of hydrogen, it's likely because of its role as one of the most abundant elements in the universe. Hydrogen is also flammable and explosive, making it dangerous to transport. That said, hydrogen can be used as a fuel source when compressed into liquid form at extremely high pressures and temperatures (up to 70 bar). This liquid hydrogen is a suspension of protons (positively charged particles) and electrons (negatively charged particles) with no neutral atoms present; this means that there is no mass or weight associated with liquid hydrogen—only energy!
Liquid or gaseous forms of this element have been used as rocket fuel since the 1960s when NASA developed their lunar program using these fuels for space exploration missions.
How does Hydrogen work in a vehicle fuel cell?
When you think of hydrogen, you probably don't picture it as a power source for your car. But with the help of a fuel cell, hydrogen is just that: a clean energy source that creates electricity in the same way your home uses it to run an electric kettle or power tools.
Unlike gasoline-powered engines that burn fossil fuels and produce harmful emissions (including carbon dioxide), fuel cells convert stored chemical energy into useful electricity by reacting it with oxygen from the air. This process produces only water vapor as waste product—no CO2 or other pollutants!
Fuel cells are more efficient than internal combustion engines because they can operate at higher temperatures and pressures and do not require moving parts like pistons or spark plugs; this means less friction loss during operation. Hydrogen-powered vehicles also have much greater range than battery electric vehicles (BEVs) due to their ability to carry high amounts of onboard storage capacity without adding significant weight due to heavy batteries needed by BEVs.
Hydrogen Cars vs Electric Cars
Hydrogen cars are technically more efficient than electric cars. The reason: they use hydrogen fuel cells to convert energy into electricity and power the vehicle, whereas electric vehicles use a battery that stores electricity converted from other sources (like coal or nuclear power).
For example, when you plug an electric car into a wall outlet, it takes about 30 minutes to fully charge the battery. If you're driving at highway speeds without any stops or traffic lights then your range may be limited to 150 miles before needing to recharge again--just enough time for lunch! On the other hand, if you have access to compressed gaseous hydrogen at fueling stations along your route then it takes less than five minutes of fueling time plus several hours of storage on-board until your next fill up is needed.
领英推荐
Other Hydrogen Vehicles
Fuel Cells can be used to power a range of vehicles and are more practical for haulage and transportation instead of cars and personal transport. For example:
Hydrogen flight is the next step in aviation, and it's going to be a lot different than you think.
Hydrogen is an ideal fuel for airplanes because it has a high energy density—meaning more hydrogen can be stored in a given volume than other fuels. It also produces fewer emissions per unit of energy generated than gasoline or diesel, so using hydrogen for aircraft power would help reduce air pollution.
Having a high energy density means that you can carry more energy with less weight. This makes it an attractive option for aviation and cars because both are trying to reduce the weight of their vehicles so they can go farther on less fuel.
For example, the hydrogen-powered Boeing 787 Dreamliner airplane has over three times as much range (1,350 nautical miles) as its predecessor (460-660), but only weighs about 200 pounds more. By comparison, Tesla’s Model S 100D electric car has more than three times
How much energy can it store?
Hydrogen fuel cells are capable of storing a lot more energy than batteries, but they're also much heavier and have other problems that make them impractical as an alternative to internal combustion engines. A hydrogen-powered vehicle would need to carry a lot more fuel on board, which would make it heavier and use more expensive materials in its construction. The energy density of liquid hydrogen is about three times higher than gasoline, but it's still not as high as some of the best lithium-ion batteries that can be found in electric vehicles today. The Honda Clarity Fuel Cell has a range of 300 miles per tankful - roughly double what you get from most electric cars - but then again it weighs almost two tons (1,800 kilograms) more than an average Tesla Model S P100D!
How long does it take to refuel a hydrogen car compared with electric vehicles and EVs?
Let's compare refueling time with electric vehicles and EVs. While you'll find hydrogen fueling stations in some parts of the world, they are not as common as electric charging stations. Hydrogen refueling takes less than 5 minutes while it takes 15-30 minutes to charge an EV at home.
In addition to this, there is also a misconception that hydrogen is more expensive than electricity for use in vehicles but this is not true either. In fact, hydrogen costs about $2 per kilogram at present whereas electricity costs about 10 cents per kWh or $0.10 per kWh depending on where you live (e.g., California vs Texas).
Sustainability | Business | Hydrogen
1 年Useful article Jay Barnard . Why not both? FCEVs are EVs at heart, Microcab Industries Ltd have a solution allowing E-recharge or H-refuel; best of both worlds? And you're covered while the transition progresses.
Director / Business Leader / Mentor / Strategic Advisor / Recruitment Specialist / NED / Emerging Technologies / Engineering & Technical/ Professional Services /Search & Selection /Headhunting
1 年Great article Jay Barnard ????