The human part of machine learning forecasts

The human part of machine learning forecasts

I've seen a few videos showing a robot making a burger (here's one of RoboBurger for example). It seems pretty impressive that a machine can create a fresh burger. However, one thing seems missing in those videos. How do the ingredients get there? That part is kind of ignored.? Of course no ingredients means no burgers. It is what happens before the robot assembles the burger which is the most important step. A farmer has spent years raising a cow. Another farmer has grown tomatos for the ketchup. Another farmer has grown wheat for the flour in the bun and so on. The "robot" bit is the culmination of a massive amount of human effort.

When it comes to financial markets, it's often what you don't see which is most important too! Machine learning is creating a buzz in many places including financial markets, in particular models like ChatGPT, which work with text. Whilst these can be incredibly useful for financial markets, ultimately, what most folks are doing in financial markets boils down to forecasting time series (is a stock going up? is inflation going down? etc.). We can still use machine learning for time series forecasting, but typically we need to use different sorts of models when we do a regression, as opposed to ChatGPT.

Turnleaf Analytics, which I cofounded with Alexander Denev is built around using machine learning to forecast economic variables. What have we learnt from this about forecasting using machine learning? Machine learning allows us to squeeze more out of complex datasets, where simpler models aren't as effective. However, in order to do the modelling effectively, requires a lot of human effort for research. It can be tempting to simply do a "horse race" of many different machine learning models and just pick the best one. In practice, you need to understand the particular forecasting problem in a lot of detail. Forecasting inflation is different to many other types of forecasting, whether it is inventory changes, market prices etc.

If you can understand the particular nuances of your particular problem it can help greatly. Feature engineering is a big part of solving the problem. In some areas, feature engineering has been automated, such as computer vision through the use of deep learning. However, in that problem there is a lot of data which can feed data hungry models like CNNs....

To read the rest of the article on the Turnleaf Analytics website, please click here!

Well said - differentiated feature engineering comes from domain knowledge. On the model horse race front - definitely should not be a brute force race - understand the different strengths and angles makes the race deliberate.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Saeed Amen的更多文章

  • Learning from running financial models live

    Learning from running financial models live

    Let's say you are the world's best burger chef (we all have ambitions, right). You'd be serving up all manner of…

    1 条评论
  • DeepSeek, objectives and constraints

    DeepSeek, objectives and constraints

    When a new burger joint opens up, there's often a buzz. Everyone (well, at least me) wants to try the new burger.

    1 条评论
  • Hundreds of quant papers from #QuantLinkADay in 2024

    Hundreds of quant papers from #QuantLinkADay in 2024

    I tweet a lot (from @saeedamenfx and at BlueSky at @saeedamenfx.bsky.

  • What we’ve learnt from reading thousands of Fed communications

    What we’ve learnt from reading thousands of Fed communications

    We recently had the last FOMC decision of 2024. Market l participants reacted to the hawkish tone including Powell’s…

    1 条评论
  • Takeaways from QuantMinds 2024 in London

    Takeaways from QuantMinds 2024 in London

    Over the past years, the quant industry has changed substantially. My first visit to Global Derivatives was just over a…

    12 条评论
  • Takeaways from Web Summit 2024

    Takeaways from Web Summit 2024

    Think of Lisbon and no doubt it’ll conjure images of explorers setting sail in centuries past across the ocean, the…

    1 条评论
  • FILS Europe 2024 Takeaways

    FILS Europe 2024 Takeaways

    Paris is home to many things, the Eiffel Tower, the Arc de Triomphe, burgers (ok, I made that one up!). In recent…

    4 条评论
  • Don't look back in hangar steak

    Don't look back in hangar steak

    I'm currently in the queue for Oasis tickets. Rather than mindlessly watching the counter of people in the queue ahead…

    5 条评论
  • The Olympic spirit for forecasting

    The Olympic spirit for forecasting

    The Olympics finally finished, and the Paralympics are about to begin. I managed to go to some of the Olympic football…

  • Eleven years of independence

    Eleven years of independence

    Regrets become ever more edged with the passing of time. Recalling a time long gone, when perhaps a decision made, was…

    5 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了