How Your Next Big Idea Might Damage Your Reputation as a Leader
Patrick Leddin, PhD
Practice Leader | Professional Disruptive Speaker | Led the Vanderbilt Disruption Project | WSJ Bestselling Author | Podcast Host
Despite your best efforts, things don’t always go as planned.
The company may decide to penetrate a new market, but the economy elects not to cooperate. No matter what you and your people do, the numbers aren’t met. The efforts were gallant; unfortunately, the economy conspired against you. The initiative is dead.
Maybe you began a large project at the direction of your boss. Things are progressing well until leadership above you changes and so do the priorities. Suddenly the ‘big project’ is no longer important and is stopped in its tracks. You and your team did nothing wrong; things just changed. The project is dead.
These things happen; they are real; BUT they are not what I’m talking about.
What I’m referring to our initiatives that you start but lack the resources, focus, or energy to see to fruition. They are the ones that seemed like a good idea in the moment, but they never should have started in the first place. They are the ones where not only is the initiative dead, but your reputation as a leader is harmed along the way.
There are plenty of these types of initiatives. I offer three commons ones to get you thinking about these type of initiatives and the problems that ensue when they unravel.
1. Award or Recognition Programs
Organizations are riddled with dead or dying award or recognition programs. Go into a restaurant and look around to see if they have an employee of the month plaque on the wall. All too often these programs are inconstantly maintained over time and the plaque on the wall saying Employee of the Month is a glaring reminder of this – you will may have gone a few months with a recipient listed, then a blank month or two, and finally the rest of the year filled in with awardee names.
What does this communicate to the restaurant’s employees and customers?
You got it. It says, “this was a good idea when we started it, but it really doesn’t matter that much!” Award and recognition programs can be good ideas, but they require time and attention. Don’t start them unless you are willing to care and feed them.
2. Accountability Mechanisms
I’ve seen many leaders frustrated with a situation and implement an accountability mechanism to resolve the issue. In turn, they create reports and meetings that no one truly owns and are eventually abandoned.
If you are frustrated, think twice before you say, “we are going to report on this every week in our meeting” or “I want a report on this first thing each morning.” It might feel good to put your foot down in the moment, but you might end up stepping in it.
3. Technology Solutions
Technology can be amazing. I’ve seen someone present a solution to a group of leaders and everyone falls over themselves with excitement. It literally looks like one technology driven solution can answer to all of their problems.
It seems like candy – and who doesn’t like candy?
The problem is when you go to the store and buy candy, you typically don’t think of the energy required to grow and harvest sugar cane, mix all of the ingredients, produce the product, etc. It is a difficult and costly endeavor. The same can be true for technology solutions. Don’t start them if you don’t plan to see them through – half of a computer program is of little value.
-----------
I wish you all the best as you work to implement programs that matter and invest the resources to stick with them.
Best- Patrick
-----------
Join the 96,000+ who follow Patrick on LinkedIn. His goal is to help you to be a better leader and to build winning teams.
Supervisor at US Border Patrol
5 年Sometimes that fear of failure is our biggest obstacle to achieving something great.....I love the article. Thought provoking and encourages some personal reflection, and also some re-focusing on the true purpose that usually drives those “big ideas”...I’ve heard somewhere that “Reputation is what others think of you. Character is who you are.” Let your ideas reveal your character, and your reputation will be fine.
Chief Operating Officer at Segal McCambridge Singer & Mahoney
5 年Unfortunately if we enjoy trying new things there are going to be times when something doesn't make it to the finish line or isn't followed up consistently enough to be maintained.? I can think of a couple of mine; (1) the monthly internal newsletter that was going to be a great way to connect people in the firm but only lasted a couple of months, and (2) the personal anniversary notes?to thank employees for their efforts and contributions, this initiative did not make it through a full year.? There are also successes that are created and maintained.? Need to learn from those that were not sustained and consider those that did succeed and determine what the best route is for the success of new initiatives.? Time, commitment and a consistent approach are usually a good start.