How to Win the Customer Renewal Game: Stalking, Stats, and a Pinch of Intuition

Disclaimer: This is a Long Read. Grab Coffee, or Tea—We Don’t Judge.

Let’s face it - customer renewals aren’t just a checkbox at the end of the year. It’s a full-blown relationship saga that demands attention to detail, strategy, and, let’s be real - borderline obsession. If you think sending a reminder email two weeks before their contract ends will do the trick, well, good luck with that! Spoiler alert: it won’t. Trust me, yours truly has been there before.

But hey, we’re not here to shame; we’re here to solve. So, let’s dive into a more aggressive renewal strategy that’s sure to make your customers feel like you’ve been stalking them (in a good way, of course) and ensure they can’t imagine life without you. And just to keep things spicy, we’ll segment them based on specific parameters because - who does not love a well-organized approach to borderline stalking?

Oh, and for you number nerds, we’re throwing in some math too. For the not-so-math-savvy folks out there, don’t worry! While the math might seem like distractions, the key takeaways are about understanding your customer’s needs, knowing when to engage, and using a bit of intuition and experience to guide your renewal strategy. Whether you’re crunching numbers or just reading the room, this article has insights for everyone.

“I’m not superstitious, but I am a little stitious.” – The Office

Disclaimer: These formulas are brought to you courtesy of the internet, ChatGPT and my MBA books. While they’re excellent tools, nothing beats the CSM’s personal intuition—knowing the pulse of the customer is a superpower that only comes with experience. These indicators and numbers are just that: indicators. Real success comes from good old-fashioned KYC intimacy (Know Your Customer, not the bureaucratic stuff). Also, life at a product company comes full circle when these numbers and insights inform not just the CSMs, but the product, sales, marketing, and support teams as well. So, everyone’s got skin in this game.

1. Segment by CLV – Aka, Know Who Your "Gold Customers" Are

Not all customers are created equal. Shocking, I know. Some pay the big bucks, while others, well... let’s just say we keep them around because every penny counts. Here's how we play this game, with a little bit of number crunching.

CLV Formula:

CLV = Average?Purchase?Value × Purchase?Frequency × Customer?Lifespan

Using CLV, you can easily calculate how much each customer is actually worth. And no, this isn’t just some vague sentiment—it’s cold, hard cash.

Example:

• Customer A: $10,000/year for 3 years = $30,000 CLV
• Customer B: $3,000/year for 4 years = $12,000 CLV

High CLV Customers (a.k.a. Your Golden Geese): Treat them like royalty. For a $30,000 CLV customer, even a 1% improvement in retention means $300 more. Scale that across a portfolio, and the numbers start looking very tasty.

Low CLV Customers (The Penny Pinchers): They’re still worth something! If Customer B's retention improves by 5%, you’re squeezing another $600 out of the relationship - without much effort.

Now that we know who the big shots are, let’s see how they’re using your product.

2. Usage Patterns – Are They Even Using Your Stuff?

This is where the Customer Health Score can come in. This simple statistical approach helps you quantify how engaged or disengaged your customer is. It combines multiple metrics like logins, support tickets, and feature usage into one beautiful number, on a scale of 1-100.

Customer Health Score Formula:

Customer?Health = (Engagement?Metrics + Satisfaction?Metrics + Adoption?Metrics)/n×100

Example:

If Customer A is consistently using 4/5 features, submits support tickets promptly, and scores high on satisfaction surveys, they might get a health score of 90. They’re basically married to your product. Customer B? Maybe they’re using just 2/5 features and rarely log in, giving them a score of 50. Time for some intense care.

High Usage Customers (They Can’t Get Enough): If their health score is above 80, you can focus on upsell opportunities. Show them more ways they can integrate your product into their daily life, just like a new Netflix series. Maybe throw in a stat like: “You’re using 80% of our features; let’s get you to 100%!”

Low Usage Customers (The Forgetful Ones): For those in the 50-60 range, they’re just a step away from ghosting. The CSM should jump in, using the health score to show what they’re missing. “Did you know customers who use our X feature have a 30% higher renewal rate?”

3. Renewal Timeline – The Clock Is Ticking

Timing is everything, and you can use Predictive Analytics to figure out when a customer is at risk of churning. By analyzing past renewal data, you can calculate the probability of renewal for different customers. It’s a bit like weather forecasting but for customer behavior.

Churn Probability Formula (Logistic Regression):

Okay, that looks intimidating, but here’s what it means: You can plug in variables like time since last log-in, feature adoption, and NPS score to get a predicted likelihood of renewal. If a customer’s churn probability is high, you’d better act fast.

Example:

• Customer A: 20% probability of churn (they’re staying)
• Customer B: 70% probability of churn (Panic Mode)

With these predictions in hand, you know exactly where to focus your time.

4. Industry Segmentation – Because Not Everyone Speaks the Same Language

Customers from different industries are like different species - each with their own quirks. So, adapt. Here’s where we can introduce Cluster Analysis to segment customers by behavior and industry characteristics.

Cluster Analysis:

Group your customers based on their usage patterns, renewal rates, and industry-specific needs. Use k-means clustering to identify patterns in how customers from different industries use your product.

Example:

• Cluster 1: Tech companies using 80% of features and renewing early.
• Cluster 2: Retail companies using 50% of features, needing more hand-holding.

Based on which cluster your customer falls into, you can tailor your renewal approach. Maybe Tech companies love cutting-edge features, while Retail customers want stability and reliable support.

5. Customer Satisfaction – The Good, the Meh, and the Furious

Let’s not forget the magic of Net Promoter Score (NPS). You can statistically tie NPS scores to renewal probabilities. Use NPS data to trigger specific actions based on their score.

NPS Formula:

NPS = %Promoters ? %Detractors

Example:

• Promoters (Score 9-10): 80% chance of renewal
• Passives (Score 7-8): 50% chance of renewal
• Detractors (Score 0-6): 20% chance of renewal

With NPS in hand, you can statistically determine the likelihood of renewal based on how happy or grumpy your customers are. If they’re a Detractor, CSMs should be running a full recovery mission ASAP.

Now, Let’s Get Fancy – Layering Parameters Like a Pro

You’re not just going to use one parameter to segment your customers (which is so yesterday), right? This is where things get exciting: combine parameters to build your ultimate renewal machine. Here’s how:

• High CLV + Low Usage + Low NPS = Red Alert! This customer is slipping. Statistically, they’re not just at risk of churning—they’re practically standing at the door with one foot out. CSMs need to swoop in with usage revitalization plans and relationship repair. This is your high-touch segment.
• Mid CLV + High Satisfaction + Low Churn Probability = Fast-Track Renewal Statistically, this customer is happy and healthy, with a strong chance of renewal. Push them into early renewal mode by throwing in a little incentive, maybe a small discount or a bonus feature.
• Low CLV + High Usage + High Churn Probability = Let’s Get Tactical These customers are using your product but may still be eyeing the competition. Keep your engagement lean but effective - automated touchpoints, and an occasional CSM intervention to keep them interested.

By layering these parameters - CLV, Customer Health Score, Churn Probability, and NPS - you’ll have a mathematically-backed strategy that helps you focus where it matters most. Let's face it.

"If you can't measure it, you can't improve it." - Peter Drucker

Closing Thoughts – Because You Read All the Way Here

If you’re still with me, congrats. You’re either really committed to this renewal strategy or you’re just killing time between meetings (no judgment). The point is, an aggressive, segmented approach is how you move from “fingers crossed” to “done deal.” Whether it’s tailored touchpoints, deep data insights, or sheer relentless charm, you can ensure that your customers don’t just renew - they want to renew.

Now, while SaaS tools like Gainsight, ChurnZero, and HubSpot are some of the best in the market for tracking customer health, churn risk, and engagement metrics, remember the golden rule of customer success: “Entertainment, entertainment, entertainment!” (Okay, not quite - let’s go with “The devil is in the detail.”) Even with all these apps doing the heavy lifting, a CSM must remain vigilant. Data can paint a pretty picture, but it can also miss the subtle cues and nuances only a human touch can catch. So, don’t let these apps lull you into complacency. Stay sharp, stay proactive, and keep your finger firmly on the pulse - because the best metrics can still miss a heartbeat if you’re not paying attention.

So go ahead - stalk those usage metrics, plug in those NPS scores, and layer those customer insights like a pro. And remember, it’s not just about the math - it’s about knowing the customer’s pulse, intuitively guiding them, and letting them know you’re their best option at every stage of the relationship. So CSMs, here's a little verse for all of us:

“Let the wise listen and add to their learning, and let the discerning get guidance.” – Proverbs 1:5

#CustomerSuccess #CSM #DataDriven #CSMLife #CustomerRetention #Renewals #DataDriven #CustomerExperience #PredictiveAnalytics #ChurnPrevention #ProductManagement #SalesAndMarketing #CustomerHealth #CXMatters #SaaS #KYC #BusinessGrowth #B2B #TechLife #CustomerLoyalty #Leadership