How we think about Work

How we think about Work

Do we really think about work, other than trying to get someone else to do it for us?

Shigeo Shingo and Taiichi Ohno both had exposure to ideas that changed how they thought about work. Just out of school, Shingo was exposed to Taylor's Scientific Management and a few years later attended a training program where he learned Gilbreth's Work Study methods. Ohno's early exposure was to Flander's organizing for flow, then began to study Ford, Taylor, Gilbreth, and others.

Think Differently

Frederick Taylor and Frank Gilbreth both studied the work processes in detail. (Below is a simplified version of what they studied.)

No alt text provided for this image

Taylor's focus was on accurately defining the time it should take to complete an activity. His time study methods became a standard measure for setting productivity expectations. Taylor's focus was on the work capacity a human was capable of.

No alt text provided for this image

Gilbreth's work was in defining all the motions in completing an activity. He removed unnecessary activity (waste) and focused on making the work easier. He developed a "One Best Way"... the beginning of standard work.

No alt text provided for this image

Walter Flander's looked at work from a different perspective, at a system level first, then the details.

No alt text provided for this image

Rather than having process villages and large batch operations, he mapped the flow sequence and reorganized the layout of the machines in the sequence of operations.

No alt text provided for this image

With the machines in sequence, he addressed the issue of synchronizing the operations. How do you manage the different cycle times or capacity issues?

No alt text provided for this image

He also had to manage the problems that quality and equipment had on his synchronization efforts.

No alt text provided for this image

Ohno began experimentation on layouts that led to multiple machines being run by a single operator. This required training operators to run different types of machines.

No alt text provided for this image

Shingo added the training for time studies and Gilbreth's Work Study ideas that led to people identifying unnecessary activity, improving layouts, and defining cycle times.

No alt text provided for this image

Shingo's further study of work details was to improve the viability of running small lots by reducing the changeover time required.

No alt text provided for this image

Shingo's rethinking of changeover details led to labeling each detail as either inside or outside. The inside details required the equipment to be stopped, so you wanted as few of these as possible. The outside details could be done while the equipment was running (before or after the changeover). Following Gilbreth's "One Best Way", as much was standardized as possible to eliminate the need for adjustments, tools, etc.

To reduce the changeover time even further, he made the distinction between setting and adjusting. Where any changeover required adjusting (run one, check, adjust, run more, check... until it was good enough), the goal was to eliminate the adjustment or have a defined setting that would not require test pieces to confirm.

Ohno added the TWI skills to build the foundations for the Toyota Production System. Clearly defining the standard, solving problems, improving the standards, and respecting people. Job Instruction reinforces looking closely at each step to define the key points, and what must happen to get the desired outcomes. This can become an effective learning to see exercise in thinking about work to be done. The Job Methods skill has you challenge each detail to remove unnecessary activity (waste) and develop more effective ways of accomplishing your work.

No alt text provided for this image

To reduce disruptions caused by defects and the necessity to babysit machines, autonomation became a part of how they thought about the work done by machines.

No alt text provided for this image


Can you Think Differently about work?


If you look, what will you find?

Pick the most popular product or service you deliver. Walk the production sequence.

No alt text provided for this image

How close is each activity? Count the steps needed between each activity. Can you put some activities closer together? Would it be easy to put any two of the activities closer together? Can you have any activities handed off to the next one rather than completing a batch before moving them to the next activity?

No alt text provided for this image

What problems do you encounter with each activity? Do you have safety issues? Do you have quality and rework issues? Do you have any machine problems? Which ones can be fixed today? Which ones can you contain to reduce the issue? Do you need more facts to understand the problem? Do you know why the problem happens?

No alt text provided for this image

Which activities are difficult or take longer to complete? Can you make them easier? Can the operations be simplified? Are all details of the activity necessary?

No alt text provided for this image

Do you use the basic skills to define the standard, problem-solve and improve the standards?

No alt text provided for this image

Do you think about how to simplify changeovers so they are not a factor in scheduling production?

What are you going to do today? What will you do tomorrow?

Have any questions?
[email protected]


Share this article and challenge your peers to think differently.

Rick Black

Product Leader | ERP | B2B eCommerce | SaaS | Distribution | PIM | Lean | HVAC

3 年

There is more to looking at a process than I ever imagined. Thank you.

Narayana Rao KVSS

Professor (Retired), NITIE - Now IIM Mumbai - Offering FREE IE ONLINE Course Notes

3 年

Process Analysis and Operation Analysis are different. H.B. Maynard wrote a book on operation analysis. Motion study is part of operation analysis. Similarly study of machine work in each operation also has to be done. Maynard advocated operation analysis sheet preparation for operation analysis. Operation Analysis - Methods Efficiency Engineering??? https://nraoiekc.blogspot.com/2013/11/approach-to-operation-analysis-as-step.html

回复
Narayana Rao KVSS

Professor (Retired), NITIE - Now IIM Mumbai - Offering FREE IE ONLINE Course Notes

3 年

Differentiating process and operation is very important.

回复
Grant L.

Top 500 US Company Regional CI | LSS Manager | Black Belt(ASQ) | PMP

3 年

nice for summarizing the evolution.?

Nigel Thurlow

Executive Coach | Board Advisor | Interim Executive | Co-Creator of The Flow System? | Creator of Scrum The Toyota Way? | Forbes Noted Author | Who’s Who Listee | Toyota Alumni | Renowned Speaker

3 年

An excellent piece and threads of discussion which is timely as I’m writing my keynote for Katacon and some history is included. Context will be evolution of PDCA into complexity thinking. Many great names called out across the post. More like this ??

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Mark Warren的更多文章

  • The Art of "Making Things"

    The Art of "Making Things"

    How you think about work shapes your approach to improving processes. At the top level, you have Systems Thinking, also…

  • Toyota's Rapid Application of TPS

    Toyota's Rapid Application of TPS

    Early into the pandemic, Toyota's management was looking for a way they could be socially responsible and assist in the…

    13 条评论
  • Improving Your Production System

    Improving Your Production System

    Have you ever dreamed of creating a production system like Taiichi Ohno did at Toyota? It is possible, whether you are…

    22 条评论
  • Continuous Improvement and Disruptive Innovation

    Continuous Improvement and Disruptive Innovation

    Everyone in a leadership position is under pressure to perform better than last year. This has always been the case as…

    1 条评论
  • Reorganize for Flow Workbook

    Reorganize for Flow Workbook

    For people wanting to know more about reorganizing for flow, I have posted a Google Doc online that you can access…

    12 条评论
  • Reorganizing for Flow - Project 20/20

    Reorganizing for Flow - Project 20/20

    Why Reorganize for Flow? The earliest first-hand account of a factory being reorganized for Flow started in the fall of…

    12 条评论
  • Industry 4.0 and Lean

    Industry 4.0 and Lean

    Industry 4.0 is a natural extension of lean, While the term "Industry 4.

    5 条评论
  • Just imagine if Ohno visited…

    Just imagine if Ohno visited…

    This is a “what if” scenario that people occasionally ponder, thinking about all the insider information they might…

    10 条评论
  • Practical Problem Solving

    Practical Problem Solving

    Updated to reference coaching effect, quality tools, and continuing use The skill of creating and updating Job…

    14 条评论
  • Practical Job Instruction

    Practical Job Instruction

    Want to improve quality or productivity? Want to solve existing problems while you practice? Then you will need…

    5 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了