How using AI to produce your LinkedIn comments can damage your reputation

In the age of artificial intelligence (AI), many professionals are exploring how AI tools can streamline their workflow and optimize productivity. AI offers capabilities to automate tasks, generate content, and even assist with communication. However, while these tools can be incredibly valuable in many contexts, there’s a hidden risk in using AI to generate something as personal and high-stakes as LinkedIn comments.

In this article, I will explain why relying on AI to produce your LinkedIn comments can damage your personal and professional reputation. I’ll cover the importance of authenticity, provide examples of how AI-generated comments can backfire, and offer advice on how to approach LinkedIn engagement more thoughtfully.

The Importance of Authenticity in LinkedIn Engagement

LinkedIn is not just another social media platform. It is a professional networking hub where your online presence directly reflects your brand, values, and expertise. Authenticity is critical in building trust and credibility on this platform, and your comments are an extension of that. When you engage with others on LinkedIn, you are contributing to discussions that can enhance your reputation, signal your thought leadership, and open doors to new opportunities.

When AI is used to generate these interactions, it often produces comments that are generic, impersonal, or worse, irrelevant. LinkedIn audiences are savvy, and they can easily spot when a comment lacks genuine thought or effort. Over time, such AI-generated interactions can erode trust, signaling to your network that you aren’t truly engaged or interested in meaningful dialogue.

The Problem with Generic AI Comments

Let’s look at a common scenario: You’re scrolling through LinkedIn and come across a post by a connection who shares a thoughtful article on leadership. You think, "I should engage with this post to stay on their radar," but you're short on time. So, you use an AI tool to quickly generate a comment. The AI produces something like, “Great article! Leadership is so important in today’s world.”

While this comment isn’t overtly negative, it’s also not impactful. It adds no value to the conversation and could be seen as an empty platitude. Imagine if multiple people left similarly vague comments—your contribution would blend in, and your connection might begin to see you as someone who skims content rather than offering meaningful input.

Compare that to a manually crafted comment: “I really appreciate your take on leadership, especially the emphasis on empathy. I’ve found that leading with emotional intelligence can transform team dynamics. What strategies have you used to encourage open communication in your team?”

This second comment is specific, thoughtful, and invites further conversation. It signals that you’ve read the content, reflected on it, and are interested in engaging with the author. Over time, consistently providing this level of engagement will establish you as a thoughtful, insightful professional.

Irrelevant Responses Damage Your Credibility

AI can also go wrong in more dramatic ways. Consider this scenario: Your colleague shares a post about their recent promotion, expressing excitement about a new role in data analytics. You use AI to craft a comment, and the tool produces something like, “Congratulations! I love how you’re making an impact in digital marketing.”

Not only is this comment irrelevant to the topic of data analytics, but it also shows a lack of attention to detail. Your colleague might feel as though you didn’t care enough to read their post before commenting. This type of error can damage your reputation by making it seem like you’re more interested in “checking the box” on engagement rather than meaningfully contributing to the conversation.

Such mistakes are more common with AI than you might think. AI tools, though advanced, can still misinterpret the context of a post, especially when language is nuanced or when a post touches on multiple subjects. When your comments appear tone-deaf or unrelated, it’s a direct hit to your credibility.

The Risk of Over-Automation

Another potential pitfall of using AI on LinkedIn is the temptation to over-automate. If you’re using AI tools to comment on multiple posts at scale, your interactions may become overly formulaic. Your network could notice patterns, like repeating phrases or a lack of depth across your comments, leading them to assume that you’re using a tool to automate your responses.

One real-world example involved a marketing executive who used an AI tool to comment on dozens of posts daily. Over time, their network noticed a pattern: the comments were all similarly vague, such as, “Great insights!” or “Interesting perspective!” These comments were never specific to the content and often didn’t align with the topic at hand. Eventually, people began to point out the lack of genuine engagement, and the executive’s reputation suffered as a result.

This example illustrates a broader point: LinkedIn is a professional platform, and if people suspect that you’re relying on automation to engage with them, they may begin to question your commitment to authentic networking. Your personal brand might come across as mechanical or detached, which can hurt relationships that are built on trust and genuine interest.

AI’s Limits in Understanding Tone and Nuance

LinkedIn is a platform where tone and nuance matter. You might be commenting on a post that shares exciting news, sensitive information, or even a controversial opinion. AI tools can struggle to understand these subtleties. A comment that might seem neutral or supportive in a different context can come across as inappropriate if the tone is misjudged.

For example, imagine a post where a colleague discusses the challenges of being laid off and searching for a new job. If an AI tool generates a comment like, “Great post, thanks for sharing!” it would come across as callous and unsympathetic. In this case, a human response would be necessary to acknowledge the emotional weight of the post and offer meaningful support.

In a world where empathy is increasingly seen as a critical leadership skill, using AI to respond to such posts could create the perception that you lack emotional intelligence. This perception can have lasting consequences for your professional reputation, especially in industries that value soft skills and relationship-building.

How to Avoid the AI Pitfall

To avoid the negative consequences of AI-generated comments, here are a few practical tips for maintaining authenticity in your LinkedIn engagement:

1. Limit the use of AI: While AI can help generate ideas or draft longer content like articles, avoid using it to produce comments or personal messages. Keep those interactions human and personal.

2. Be selective with your engagement: It’s better to leave fewer, high-quality comments than to flood your network with generic responses. Focus on the posts where you have something meaningful to contribute.

3. Add value to the conversation: Whenever you comment, aim to provide insights, ask questions, or offer a new perspective. Thoughtful comments are more likely to be remembered and appreciated.

4. Personalize your responses: Reference specific points from the post you’re commenting on. This shows that you’ve read and understood the content, and it makes your interaction more engaging.

5. Listen to feedback: If you notice that your network isn’t responding well to your comments, take it as a cue to adjust your approach. Focus on genuine engagement over efficiency.

Conclusion

While AI offers powerful tools to streamline many aspects of our professional lives, using it to generate LinkedIn comments can damage your reputation.

LinkedIn is a platform built on trust, authenticity, and meaningful interactions, and generic or irrelevant comments will quickly erode your credibility. Instead of relying on AI, invest time in crafting thoughtful, personalized responses that add value to your network. Your reputation—and your relationships—will be better for it.

_____________________

David Petherick is a LinkedIn Profile Doctor who since 2006 has been making his patients healthier on LinkedIn by making their presence more visible, legible and credible. If you have not already done so, subscribe to his monthly LinkedIn newsletter .

If you'd like a free ten-minute LinkedIn Profile Microsurgery, David offers this for limited hours one day a week. Book your appointment today at is-in.link/chat