How a Scrum Master Could Undermine a Team

Let’s explore a hypothetical scenario in which your company has planted you as a Scrum Master in their competitor's organization and appointed you as a Scrum Master of one of the Scrum Teams. Your job is to sabotage the Scrum Team so that the blame goes to Developers, POs, Leadership, Management, and Stakeholders.

While unethical and certainly not recommended, this scenario serves as a powerful cautionary tale. It highlights the importance of transparency, accountability, and ethical behavior in Agile environments. By understanding how these destructive behaviors manifest, teams can better safeguard against them.

Before you jump into the article, a quick reminder, we have the mega event coming up that you cannot afford to miss. Register now for the Scrum Day India 2024, sponsored by Scrum.org and organized by AgileWoW

Register now: www.scrumdayindia.org

1. Not facilitating the Scrum Events when required or requested

The purpose of Scrum events is to do regular inspection and adaptation. A Scrum Master can cancel or delay the event by citing scheduling conflicts or other priorities. Also, when these events occur, the Scrum Master can dominate the discussion and steer the team away from the agenda, ensuring that the team remains unfocused and unaligned.?

2. Not supporting the Product Owner?

One of the stakeholders for the Scrum Master is the PO. To undermine the team, the Scrum Master could subtly encourage the PO to ignore the backlog refinement, leading to chaos and confusion during the Sprint Planning.

3. Manipulating Metrics and Progress

Scrum Master might manipulate metrics and progress reports to paint a misleading picture of the team’s performance. They could selectively report the issues to make it appear that the team is either underperforming due to their own faults or facing insurmountable challenges pushed by leadership.

4. Eroding Trust

The most subtle yet destructive approach could involve eroding trust within the team. This might involve sharing misleading feedback about team members or with stakeholders, sowing seeds of doubt and mistrust. By creating an atmosphere of suspicion, the Scrum Master ensures that team members start blaming each other for failures, effectively diverting attention from their role in the team’s struggles.

5. Skewing the Daily Scrum

The Daily Scrum is intended to synchronize and create a plan for the next 24 hours. A Scrum Master might misguide this event by allowing it to devolve into problem-solving sessions or letting non-developers take over the discussion. This misuse could lead to losing focus on the sprint goal, reducing the developers’ ability to manage their day effectively, and subsequent failures attributed incorrectly to their planning or collaboration skills.

6. Ineffective Retrospectives

Retrospectives are meant to foster continuous improvement and are crucial for addressing what went well and what didn’t in a sprint. A Scrum Master could run retrospectives that are either too short to be effective, don’t involve the whole team, or fail to result in actionable insights. This could lead to repetitive mistakes and stagnation, with the blame potentially falling on the team for not "improving."?

7. Withholding Support & Services to Team

Another tactic might involve the Scrum Master withholding necessary support and resources from the team. This could be as blatant as not providing necessary tools and technologies or as subtle as failing to arrange additional training or guidance when team members struggle with new responsibilities or technologies. The Scrum Master could then blame the developers for not meeting expectations or the leadership for not providing enough resources, effectively shifting the focus away from their shortcomings.

?

I know there are so many other ways to sabotage your team but the purpose is not to list all of them here. BTW what is your way of derailing a Scrum team?

This article, while purely hypothetical, serves as an extreme example of how the role of a Scrum Master, when misused, can bring about the downfall of a Scrum team. It underscores the critical importance of ethical leadership and the need for each team member, from developers to stakeholders, to remain vigilant and committed to the principles of Agile and Scrum.

In reality, the strength of a Scrum team lies in collaboration, transparency, and mutual respect—qualities that every Scrum Master should foster and uphold. This cautionary exploration highlights the need for all team members to be proactive in maintaining open lines of communication and to regularly reflect on their team dynamics, ensuring that they remain healthy and productive.

Interested in learning more about Scrum Mastery? Join our upcoming online training workshops:

Advanced Scrum Master | 31st May - 1st Jun

Scrum Master | 7th - 8th Jun

Product Owner | 14th - 15th Jun

Agile Leadership - Evidence-Based Management | 22nd Jun

Scrum with Kanban | 28th - 29th Jun