How to prevent accidents by getting your accident/incident management system right
Andrew McNeil
Managing Director @ CorpAcuity Ltd | CMIOSH, MCIEH, Fractional Health and Safety Director, Risk Management Consultant
These are some of the ultimate goals you likely have for your accident and incident management system. My mission is to equip directors responsible for health and safety with the kind of quality of information that directors of sales and marketing or finance have at their fingertips. To help you achieve these goals, think about 5 questions.
1. What are my company’s reporting process goals?
Think about what you would like to achieve with your reporting system? It might be some or all of the following:
2. What difference will a good reporting system make?
You might be having repeated incidents simply because you don't have good information about them. A good system will help you control injury and loss. This will be good for morale.
Good reporting can increase efficiencies in operational processes. Processes that cause incidents waste time and money. Better visibility on where processes are going wrong will save you both these precious commodities.
If you are relying on paper-based systems you are creating a barrier to reporting. Organisations with paper-based systems get a fraction of incidents reported simply because of the inconvenience of finding the right form and handing it in to the right place. When it is handed in it has to be correctly routed. All of those stages in the process are points of failure.
The handling steps and lack of routing controls in a paper-based system may not be GDPR compliant.
Your digital system may not work well for or fit your flow. A generic or off the shelf digital system may give you even worse problems than a paper-based system. People may not have ready access to the system because of licencing issues and cost. This presents barriers to entry of data. Also, the system may not be tailored to your organisation and therefore may not provide you with appropriate levels of access for different levels of management.
You want senior management focusing on outputs, not data manipulation. If senior management are absorbed with Excel spreadsheets and spending time hunting data for putting into PowerPoint presentations for board reports, this is grossly inefficient. Some medium sized organisations have one or more persons simply managing the incident management data collection and presentation process, all of which can be automated.
A good reporting system will red alert incidents that management need to know about before the reporters or police arrive to ambush them.
3. What is hindering you now?
Is your current system working well? If not, what could be the barriers to change?
There can be some degree of corporate complacency or paralysis, perhaps because no disaster like a prosecution has occurred to bring the reporting system under sharp focus. Also, the organisational maturity might not have developed so that directors prefer not to be faced with bad news and would rather not know about incidents.
There might be cultural issues such as accidents often being reported after an employee returns to work, not at the time of the accident. This creates the risk of RIDDOR notifiable accidents being missed simply because they don’t get reported in time and hours data not being visible to the management team.
Is there a heavy reliance on manual exchange of information for accident reporting? Long delays on receiving and processing information and lack of transparency of information due to the process being paper and email based leading to huge inefficiency and frustration.
领英推荐
Is the data gathered and displayed in such a way that it can be learned from, e.g., to spot the trends in root causes of accidents/incidents?
4. What does your current reporting system cost you?
As a director for health and safety poor data is weakening your argument for budget and change and your status in the company.
A poor incident management system definitely costs an organisation a lot, but those costs may be hidden.
Myth – “Well, our system it is paper based, so it doesn’t cost anything”. What is the impact on your employees’ well-being and health as well as lost productivity?
Ongoing administration costs arise from data entry. If your current process involves manual data transference from emails and paper forms as the basis of creating endless spreadsheets and documents, how much time is spent on this?
Your current system may not safeguard against spurious accident claims. If contemporaneous photographs or other metadata is not part of the process, this can allow for abuse of the system.
With a poor system you are missing a wealth of learning opportunities from near-miss observations. There are possible higher insurance costs because you are not reducing accidents and there is a risk of prosecution from late RIDDOR notifications.
5. How will a digital system fit and integrate?
An off-the-shelf system that just fits right doesn’t exist. The right system for each company requires tailoring.??
Generic systems inevitably give generic outputs. Indiscriminate data will not give you the insights you need to reduce incidents.
Our systems are designed to fit and integrate with your needs. We start with your KPIs and known risks. Base your system around that. A good digital system will also integrate outputs from audits, checklists, and inspections to enable you to achieve your goals.
How to get the right accident and incident management system for you?
With decades of experience of corporate incident management system design, I deeply understand the issues you face and what you need proportionate to the size and risk level of your organisation.
I will be very interested to talk to you about your needs and wishes. I am happy to look at your current reports and help you think about what kind of reporting will be ideal. We can examine the flow of data within your organisation based upon its local and regional divisions and the flow of management responsibility. Let’s look at the tools your operatives currently have available and the way they interact with them.
McNeil Collective will assemble a configuration of our system for you, cost effectively using pre-coded parts and tools and also seamlessly coding specific aspects of the solution.
Do not hesitate to call or text me, Andrew McNeil on 07545 642 236 right now to begin getting your accident/incident management system right.
Managing Director @ CorpAcuity Ltd | CMIOSH, MCIEH, Fractional Health and Safety Director, Risk Management Consultant
2 年Please share your thoughts Kirsty Strannigan, Adam Gomes CFIOSH FIWFM and Martin Cahalan if you would be so kind.
Managing Director @ CorpAcuity Ltd | CMIOSH, MCIEH, Fractional Health and Safety Director, Risk Management Consultant
2 年Please share your thoughts and experiences on this area of expertise Michael Justice, Dave Garioch, Liz Cole, Andrew Griffiths, Adam Gomes CFIOSH FIWFM, Isthar Pearce CMIOSH, Kirsty Strannigan, Roger Smith CMIOSH FRSPH MIFSM MIIRSM, Ian Viveash CMIOSH, Lisa McCaulder, Elizabeth Hancock, Tim Birkin, Tim Beach, Mark Hardy BEng GradIOSH, Martin Cahalan, Claire Hornby CMIOSH AIEMA
Managing Director @ CorpAcuity Ltd | CMIOSH, MCIEH, Fractional Health and Safety Director, Risk Management Consultant
2 年I would love to hear what you say about this Elizabeth Dunphy LLM, PG Dip. OSH, B. Bus., CMIOSH MCIEH, Mark McDixon CMIOSH, FCMI, Chris Trodd, Julie Medina, Richard Henderson, Zara Laing, Stuart Hughes, Carl Shaw, Kieran Williams CMIOSH, Rob Clark, Paul Humphreys, Rachel Danby, Richard Hemingway, Victoria Aruldoss-Hines, Ricky O'Sullivan CMIOSH MCMI, Ruth Wilkinson, Natasha Brayne, Gary Bennett BSc CMIOSH FISQEM, Ryan Hodson, Nick Painter GradIOSH MIIRSM TIFSM, Ian Peri CMIOSH MBA MSc Dip2.OSH, Sue Emery, Tom Stephenson, Casey Fleming, Helen Tucker MSc Bsc (Hons) CMIOSH DipNEBOSH, Derek Millard-Healy (TechIOSH), Kelly Nicoll, Anna M Hickman, Tristan Charles, Brian Bowes
RoSPA "Influencer of the Year 2023", Author of "The Safety Salesman", Head of Health, Safety and Environment, IOSH/IIRSM Mentor, Retired Police Officer
2 年Thanks for the mention Andrew. I come at this from the criminal investigator mindset given my own background, so anything that would support the "golden hour" principles and help people conduct a decent investigation is a good thing. ??
Managing Director @ CorpAcuity Ltd | CMIOSH, MCIEH, Fractional Health and Safety Director, Risk Management Consultant
2 年It would be great to get your insights on this please SCOTT BOSWELL, Nichola Harrison, Christian Reeve (MBA,CMIOSH,PIEMA), Fran Foy, Terry Marriott, Lawrence Jones (GradIOSH), Vanessa Brandham, Mark Littlejohns, Ateeka A., Ian Stacey CMIOSH MIIRSM, Sharon Banner, Dr Susan Tannahill CMIOSH, Janis Murphy, John Pritchard, Paul Norman-Brown, Anna Curtis, Tuesday H., Terry Short, CMIOSH, Rebecca Betteridge, Warren Lowe