How to Navigate a Turbulent World with Customer Profitability Management: A Case Study

Imagine you are the leader of a company that operates in a world where nothing is certain, everything is changing, and nothing makes sense.

• How do you measure your success?
• How do you make decisions?
• How do you keep your customers happy?

Zenith Industries (fictional name), a leading manufacturer of precision instruments, faced a daunting challenge over the past few years. The company operated in an uncertain world where nothing was stable or predictable.?

They had to cope with volatility, meaning rapid and unexpected changes in the market and customer demand. They had to deal with uncertainty, suggesting a need for more clarity and confidence about the future. They had to navigate complexity, meaning many interconnected and interdependent factors influencing their business. And they had to manage ambiguity, indicating a need for more consensus and understanding about the meaning and implications of events. These four elements, known as VUCA, describe the challenges and risks many businesses face today as they are constantly exposed to disruption, innovation, and competition.?

But Zenith also had to contend with another set of elements that added to the difficulty and stress of their situation. They had to overcome brittleness, the fragility and vulnerability of their systems and structures, which could break or collapse under pressure. They had to reduce anxiety, meaning the emotional and psychological distress that uncertainty and unpredictability caused to their employees and customers. They had to adapt to nonlinearity, meaning the disproportionate and unforeseen effects that small changes could have on their outcomes and performance. They had to learn from incomprehensibility, implying the impossibility of fully understanding or explaining some of the changes and phenomena in their environment. These four elements, known as BANI, describe the drivers and consequences of change many businesses face today, as they are constantly challenged to innovate, collaborate, and transform.

Zenith realised that traditional metrics, such as volume and market share, were insufficient to guide their strategy and operations. They needed a new compass: customer profitability management (CPM). CPM is a strategy that aims to identify and optimise the profitability of different customers or customer segments by measuring, monitoring, and improving the value they create and the costs they incur. CPM can help businesses achieve sustainable growth and profitability by focusing on the most valuable customers, improving the customer experience, and aligning the organisation's resources and processes with customer needs.

In this article, we will explore how Zenith implemented CPM, using advanced management accounting tools and analytics, and how they overcame the challenges and opportunities in their journey. We will also share some lessons and best practices to help you apply CPM in your business.

Breaking Down the Data Silos

Zenith's first step was to integrate their data. The company had a lot of information about its customers, but it was scattered across different systems and departments, such as sales, marketing, finance, and operations. This made it difficult to get a holistic view of customer interactions and understand customer profitability drivers and factors.

The Head of Customer Insights, a visionary leader, embarked on a data integration odyssey. He broke down the walls and built a unified data lake, a centralised repository that stores and organises data from various sources. He also implemented data quality and governance processes to ensure the data was accurate, consistent, and secure.

This newfound transparency revealed a hidden world: a small segment of loyal customers, dubbed "Zenith Aces", generated a disproportionate share of profits, while others, called "Value Vampires", consumed resources with limited returns. Zenith used customer segmentation, a technique that groups customers based on their profitability, behaviour, and value potential, to identify and classify these segments. Customer segmentation enabled Zenith to design and implement targeted marketing and resource allocation strategies and to identify and address churn risk.

Telling Stories with Data

More than data alone was needed. Zenith needed to communicate their insights and persuade stakeholders to act on them. The Head of Customer Insights, a master storyteller, translated data into compelling narratives. He used data-driven storytelling, a technique that uses data to build stories that resonate with the audience, drive cultural change, and support data-driven initiatives.

The Zenith Aces became cherished allies, deserving premium service and targeted upselling. The Value Vampires, although valued, couldn't be the sole focus. Alternative service models and transparent pricing structures created mutually beneficial partnerships. Zenith also identified and nurtured other segments, such as "Rising Stars" and "Sleeping Giants", with high potential and strategic value.

Building Loyalty Beyond Transactions

Zenith understood that loyalty was not built on transactions alone. They sought to create emotional connections with their customers by delivering value and personalisation. They used social media analytics to analyse customer preferences and pain points from online platforms to guide targeted content and engagement. They also designed loyalty programs based on behaviour insights that rewarded repeat business and fostered a community spirit.

Zenith used customer relationship management (CRM) software, a tool that stores and manages customer interactions and preferences, as the central nervous system of their CPM strategy. CRM helped Zenith track and optimise the customer journey, the entire customer experience from awareness to advocacy. Zenith also used sentiment analysis tools to monitor and evaluate customer emotions and opinions from online conversations to identify potential issues and opportunities for proactive intervention.

Embracing Sophisticated Tools

As Zenith's journey progressed, they embraced more sophisticated tools and techniques to enhance their CPM strategy. They used customer lifetime value (CLV) modelling, a method that predicts a customer's or segment's future profitability, to guide resource allocation and investment decisions. They also used customer journey mapping, a technique that visualises the customer journey, to reveal friction points and opportunities for improvement.

Zenith went beyond traditional cost accounting and used tools like profitability analysis and customer profitability dashboards to reveal the actual margin generated by each segment. Profitability analysis is a technique that calculates the difference between the revenues and costs of a customer or segment. In contrast, customer profitability dashboards are tools that display and compare the profitability of different segments. These tools helped Zenith optimise their pricing, promotions, and service offerings based on data-driven insights.

Reaping the Rewards

Zenith's journey was not without its challenges. They faced cultural resistance from traditionalists who clung to old metrics and methods. They also had to invest and train their staff in data analytics skills and tools. Yet, the rewards were undeniable. Zenith saw their customer churn plummet, replaced by loyalty and advocacy. Their customer satisfaction and retention rates soared, as did their profitability and market share. Zenith became a beacon of enduring partnerships in a world of volatility, uncertainty, complexity, ambiguity, brittleness, anxiety, nonlinearity, and incomprehensibility.

Zenith's story shows how customer profitability management (CPM) can help businesses navigate a turbulent and uncertain world by focusing on the most valuable customers, improving the customer experience, and aligning the organisation's resources and processes with customer needs. Zenith used advanced management accounting tools and analytics to measure, monitor, and improve the profitability of different customer segments and generate and communicate insights and recommendations. Zenith also overcame the challenges and leveraged the opportunities in their journey by fostering a customer-centric culture, embracing innovation, and collaborating across functions.

#CustomerProfitability #CPM #CustomerLoyalty #DataDriven #DataIntegration #CustomerExperience #DataVisualization #ProfitabilityAnalysis #CustomerJourney #CRM #SentimentAnalysis #CPMStrategy #DataQuality #CustomerRetention #CustomerAdvocacy #DataStorytelling #CustomerSegmentation #LoyaltyPrograms #SocialMediaAnalytics #CustomerLifetimeValue #CustomerJourneyMapping #DataAnalytics #CustomerCentricity