How Media Made America See Red
Yet another election where the people most surprised by the results are the ones closest to the story: the news media.
After a quick shift from reporting the results to explaining "what went wrong," my news feed, like yours, is dissecting the blame: Harris, for taking women for granted; Biden, for taking too long to exit; Democrats, for seemingly everything, including simply being Democrats; Oprah, for asking Harris what she'd do differently than Biden; Harris, for answering Oprah’s question; the price of gas, war in the Middle East, and last but certainly not least, the voters.
Yet, when I look at the?map, and what's red and blue, I see a narrative the media has ignored. Could it be that the media itself is at fault?
The 2024 election shows more than just a political shift; it reflects a profound disconnect between the media and the American public. Only 34 percent?of Americans now trust mass media to report the news fairly, with just 14 percent?of Republicans holding that view. Over 68 percent?believe news outlets lean toward one side (which is why?endorsements are out of vogue), fueling their turn to sources that reinforce personal beliefs — a phenomenon known as selective exposure. Media distrust leads them down this path.
Selective exposure has fueled this election cycle’s information bubbles as voters seek sources that align with their beliefs and share information within echo chambers where opposing views are scarce. This shift has allowed misinformation to thrive. According to Pew Research, 64 percent?of Americans believe fake news causes significant confusion. In today's media landscape,?distinguishing facts from partisan spin is difficult, and it causes people to feel?overwhelmed. Mainstream media should be the safety net that the public can turn to for truth.?Yet the truth is, no one even speaks of truth anymore, do they?
Many Americans see the media as abandoning its watchdog role for that of an “attack dog”—especially when it comes to Trump. A 2020 Gallup/Knight Foundation survey found that nearly half of Americans perceived the media as “very biased” against him. This perception reflects the hostile media effect, where people with strong beliefs perceive even balanced reporting as biased against them. For many, a vote for Trump may not have been about policy; it was a way to push back against a media establishment that feels disconnected from their values. That disconnection may have resulted in more red votes, regardless of political leanings.
Look at the 2024 results. The blue?areas are largely where the media is headquartered. This concentration creates a progressive echo chamber, often overlooking conservative perspectives and driving disillusioned voters to alternative sources — hello,?social media — where misinformation can thrive. It also fosters narratives shaped by preconceived notions: "Plan for voting to take time this year. Lines will be long." But they weren't.?"It will be a long time before we know the election results." But it wasn't.? Election coverage would drastically improve by dropping news media into middle America and letting them find their way out.?
Ironically, the media’s intense scrutiny of Trump may have fueled his support. For many, voting for Trump may not have been?about him personally, but rather was a rejection of a media system they see as elitist and biased. If the media’s goal was to keep Trump out, they miscalculated by alienating voters and failing in their jobs. It’s not the media’s role to tell people who to vote for or to decide what’s right or wrong. Give the public the facts, and let the voters decide. Media fails, then blames the voter? That’s unconscionable.
The real story, according to the?red-and-blue map, seems to be?that?it was the news media that was the definitive loser of?the election, and it can no?longer deny it is failing the public. It’s high time to correct course.?Otherwise, we may continue to see elections defined by media rejection.
- Jaci Clement CEO/Executive Director [email protected]
Nov. 21 Event:? Crisis Management Preparation for Organizations
Whether you're a business leader, nonprofit executive, or communications professional, being prepared for a PR crisis is no longer optional—it's essential. Our upcoming Crisis Management Masterclass will give you the tools to respond to any situation effectively?without losing control of the narrative. Experts will guide you through interactive, team-building exercises.? Sponsored by: St. Joseph's University, Northwell Health & Protiviti ?
Date: Nov. 21, 2024 Location: 58 South Service Road, Melville, LL Conference Center Tickets: Limited Availability.?$79 members, $99 nonmembers Find Out More & Secure Tickets
?
Reserve Now:?'AI, Algorithms, and Paywalls: Navigating the New Media Landscape for Communities and Leaders'
Join us on Thursday, Feb. 6, 2025, from 9 a.m. to noon for Fair Media Council’s next essential masterclass, "AI, Algorithms, and Paywalls: Navigating the New Media Landscape for Communities and Leaders." Explore how artificial intelligence, algorithms, and digital paywalls are reshaping communities and presenting new challenges for today’s leaders. This hands-on session is crafted for business executives, community leaders, and communication strategists?who need to understand and adapt to these powerful forces. Location details will be announced soon—don’t miss this opportunity to deepen your media savvy and enhance your digital strategy. Sponsored by: St. Joseph's University, Northwell Health & Protiviti
Date:?Thursday, Feb. 6, 2025, 9 a.m. - 12 noon Location:?TBA Tickets:?$79 members, $99 nonmembers The Latest Exclusive: Reply to this email to reserve tickets for this event, which has not yet been announced to the public
?
Breaking Big Stories and Getting to the Truth
In this FMC Fast Chat, investigative journalist Dave Levinthal from Centerclip tells what it takes to break the big stories to hold those in power accountable. He explains how to pursue truth — why reporters must refuse to take “no” for an answer, follow their instincts, and know when something just doesn’t add up. He also shares essential advice for the public: how to break free from echo chambers, identify quality news, and stop the spread of misinformation. Packed with insights on staying media-savvy, this episode sheds light on why a well-informed public is vital for democracy and how investigative journalism makes it happen. Listen to this podcast.
Outsmart Misinformation with Our New eBook To thank you for being a newsletter subscriber, we'd like to send you a complimentary copy of our new guide, "How to Outsmart Misinformation in the Age of AI and Deepfakes: 12 Easy Tips to Update Methods that No Longer Work." To receive it, email your request to [email protected] .?
Folio Awards Unveils Signature Awards with $1,000 Cash Prize? FOR BUSINESS, NONPROFITS & MEDIA: Social Impact Storytelling Award – The Fair Media Council Folio Awards highest honor in social media. This award is for a campaign that drives meaningful social change through powerful storytelling and engagement using social media. This is the only social media category that includes a cash prize of $1,000. FOR NEWS OUTLETS:?Truth & Impact Award - The Fair Media Council Truth & Impact Award recognizes journalism that not only uncovers the truth but also has a demonstrable impact on society, leading to significant, documented change or awareness. This is the only news award to include a cash prize of $1,000. Submit your entries across categories celebrating impactful storytelling, solutions journalism, and more. For more information. ?
Need Help Strengthening Your Media Relations Efforts? ?
We've rolled out?new?a la carte?services?that allow you to customize your engagement with FMC,?and you don't have to be a member to take advantage of these services. Our current menu of offerings includes:?
These services are available by appointment and may be held on-site or virtually. To see the complete a la carte services menu,?please click here.
Please note that our upgraded membership levels include some of the a la carte services. (Businesses and nonprofits are?eligible to become members and join the incredible organizations that?bring our?membership roster to 130,000.)?
Want Great Tips for Getting More Press Coverage? The Fair Media Council's Modern Media Publicity Kit is now live on our website. This comprehensive resource is designed to help you craft powerful media pitches, build strong relationships with journalists, and amplify your message across platforms. Whether you're aiming for local or national coverage, this toolkit will help you effectively manage your media relations efforts to meet the demands of today's fragmented media landscape. Visit our site to explore the guide. (And let us know if you'd like more of this type of information.) FMC Members also have access to our online Media Guide & Directory, which is designed to be used in conjunction with the Modern Media Publicity Kit.?
Want a Brand that Attracts News Coverage? ?
Our?Modern Branding Masterclass?is now available by appointment to groups for on-site or virtual presentations. A fee applies.
“This masterclass gives the perfect overview for everything you need to know if you are looking to expand your understanding of branding. With this masterclass, I was able to apply my knowledge to come up with some ideas that will improve and solidify my company's brand identify. I look forward to continuing to use what I've learned and to attending future Fair Media Council masterclasses.” -?Sarah Logan, IPRO For more information ?
Nominations Now Accepted for Folio Award Lifetime Achievement? Lifetime Achievement in News -This prestigious award celebrates a lifetime of impact, integrity, and unwavering commitment to informing the public and strengthening our democracy through quality news and access to information. Journalists and media professionals are eligible. Nominate someone who has shaped the media landscape and inspired future generations. NEW! Lifetime Achievement in Digital Media – Nominate an individual for innovation, leadership, and impact in advancing digital platforms, content, and technology that enhance public access to quality information and enrich the media landscape. This award recognizes a legacy of excellence in shaping how digital media informs, connects, and empowers communities. ? For more information. ?
Folio Awards Call for Entries is Now Open If you're reading this, you are eligible to enter the Folio Awards. We are currently accepting entries for news and social media, now through Feb. 1 (submit early for discounted entry fees).?We’re excited to announce the introduction of new Signature Awards and the opportunity for Lifetime Nominations.? Submit your entries across categories celebrating impactful storytelling, solutions journalism, and more. For more information. ?
Early Bird Tickets for the Folio Awards Are On Sale
Save the date: June 12, 2025. The Folio Awards is FMC’s signature event that gives the public a voice for what they want in news and media today. Secure your tickets early to guarantee your seat and take advantage of discounted pricing.
Get Early Bird Tickets and be part of the conversation that shapes the future of media. Note: Ticket sales final. No refunds.
Join the FMC Community
We give you the tools, knowledge, connections, and confidence to navigate the modern media landscape effectively, from news to social media, AI and emerging technologies. We attract organizations that prioritize trust, credibility and transparency as our members and supporters. Together, we build a stronger, more informed society. If your organization is not a member, please join us.?
FMC Fast Chat Podcast: Upcoming Episodes Please take a moment and subscribe to FMC Fast Chat , our award-winning podcast that ranks in the top 3 percent of podcasts globally. We have an amazing lineup of guests sharing expertise to increase your media savvy in our upcoming episodes, including:
Newly released:
Subscribe now so you don't miss a chat.
At a Glance:
ABOUT FMC The authority on the modern media landscape.? FMC advocates for quality news and works to create a media-savvy society.?FMC is a?501(c)(3) nonprofit organization headquartered on Long Island, N.Y. Email: [email protected] We look forward to seeing you at upcoming events and receiving your feedback. Reply to this newsletter with your comments. ?