How to Lead Change When You Don't Agree With It Yourself by Kathy Dempsey, RN, MED, CSP
Tina Altman
Consultative Sales Expert- Proven Track Record, Strategic, Collaborative and Passionate Hunter, Army Mom, Leo Wife, TeamWomen Member
Here’s a typical work scenario: In a meeting, your boss announces an upcoming company-wide change. You had little warning about the change and you don’t have a lot of time to implement the change. You might have some reservations and may even be thinking, “Are you kidding me? You want me to do what?” But, no matter how you feel about it, you know you are expected to leave the meeting, announce the change to your team, rally them around the idea, and then get to work on making the change happen. Effectively dealing with change is learning how to SHED - letting go of the old and embracing the new. Everything in life is built on this one essential process. The challenge is that we’re human and we don’t always agree with the changes put in front of us. If you have ever had a personal conflict over leading change that you don’t believe in 100%, then you’ve experienced a “SHED Dilemma.” A recent survey indicates that more than 50% of people resist change for one main reason: they don’t agree with the change. So,what do you do if you face a SHED Dilemma? Ask yourself these six questions and let the answers guide your next steps.
1.Can I live with this? I live in Arizona. It gets a tad hot herein the summer. Some of my neighbors can’t live with the heat — when the temperature gets over 100 degrees, they are out of here! Others, like me, love the heat and live in a ghost town for the month of August because so many people leave to escape the heat. When it comes to change, everyone has a different tolerance levels that they must reach before they say, “I can’t live with this anymore.” Try this: visualize a “change thermometer”where 120 degrees is your boiling point. Then ask yourself these questions: “Is the proposed change something that is unethical, immoral, or against my values? Is it a big hassle? Or, is it a minor inconvenience?” Measure your responses onyour change thermometer.need to decide to SHED any negativity and move forward with implementing the change.
2.What additional information do I need?When change happens at a rapid pace, key communications are often left out. It’s critical to ask questions so you have the information you need about the change. Even if you don’t agree with the change 100%, understanding why the change has to be made will help you move forward. Being told, “Because I said so” by our parents may have worked years ago, but today’s successful organizations find this short-term strategy ineffective in the long run.
3.What losses am I experiencing with this change? Before you can effectively lead change, you first need to deal with your own personal losses regarding that change. Start by identifying what the anticipated losses are with this change. Be honest with yourself about your feelings. Below are the stages most of us go through during change. Although they appear to be sequential, you may bounce up and down through these stages many times. Recognize that your change process may look more like an abnormal EKG. That’s OK. In fact, it’s normal. The goal is to: feel, function and keep moving forward.
I. Loss II. Anger III. Discouragement IV. Acceptance V. Celebration
4. How much control do I have over the situation? The amount of control we have over a situation varies with each situation we experience. Identifying what situations you actually have control over will help you manage change and your energy most effectively. Imagine the amount of control as a continuum.
Degree of Control No Control Full Control Influence
On one end of the scale you have full control, on the other,you have no control. Somewhere in the middle you may have some influence over a situation. The goal is to clearly understand what your degree of control is in each situation and then focus your energy on those things you can either influence Are You Experiencing a SHED Dilemma?
Everyone’s reaction — their response on the “change thermometer” — is based on individual circumstances. If you are being asked to do something that’s unethical or against your values and it’s reaching your boiling point, you may have to SHED the job right away or start planning to get out. If you determine that the change is just a hassle or minor inconvenience, then you or control. Unfortunately, most people waste their energy on those things they can’t control. It’s helpful to break down the change into smaller components. Based on your role in the organization and the situation, you’ll probably evaluate the amount of control you have on these aspects differently. Let’s look at an example and see how you can evaluate your control over a change. Situation:Your organization is merging with another company. That means you’ll be managing a lot of change for yourself and your team.
5. How do I communicate the change to my team?We all SHED and respond to change in different ways. The four SHED Styles are Stabilizer, Hedger, Energizer and Driver. Each style has a correlating need regarding change. The Stabilizer needs stability, the Hedger needs order, the Energizer needs possibilities, and the Driver needs results. We all have a primary style and tend to communicate in that style. But, in doing so, we are only 25% effective because we tend to overlook the other three styles. So when you communicate change to your team, you need to ensure you address all of the SHED Styles. This will help your team members who have different SHED Styles manage the change more effectively. Before you communicate with your team about a change, use the checklist below. It will help you lead change. For the best possible outcome, make sure you employ all of these approaches.
6. How can I bring as much joy to the situation as possible? Life is full of uncertainty. Our careers and our lives are a continuous journey of peaks and valleys. It is easy to be joyful in the peaks. (Don’t we all wish we could stay there?) But the reality is that we learn most in the valleys where our strength and skills as leaders are built. If you focus your energy on bringing as much joy as possible to a challenging situation,you will reduce the sorrow of the valleys for yourself and your entire team. The goal: Happy Shedding!
Let’s go back to our SHED Dilemma scenario. Your meeting with your boss is over. You know change is imminent and that your leadership is critical. Instead of brooding or worrying, set a 30-minute meeting with yourself and go through the six “SHED Dilemma” questions. The answers will empower you to lead change in an entirely different — and successful — way.
Kathy B. Dempsey, CSP is President of Keep Shedding! Inc., a speaking, training and consulting company that ignites people with the practical skills and motivation to lead and master change. Kathy led Memorial Health Care System’s strategic organizational development efforts to become one of the Top 100 Hospitals in America. Her most popular book, Shed or You’re Dead?: 31 Unconventional Strategies for Growth and Change, is the recipient of a Writer’s Digest International Book Award. Get proven strategies to SHED for Success?at www.KeepShedding.com
Marketing Consultant: PPC/SEO/SEM, Search Marketing, Web Optimization Marketing Manager, & Google Analytics Consultant
4 年A key point to recognize -?Everyone’s reaction — their response on the “change thermometer” — is based on individual circumstances. Great article, Tina Altman! Embrace other's perspective.
Freelance Writer for Coaches / Consultants
5 年Great article, Tina! Our brains are wired to avoid pain. While implementing change might bring about success and good feelings later - in the short-term it is almost always challenging and a person's brain in the beginning a lot of times continues to tell them "It is not worth the trouble." Being prepared with the information you gave in this article can inspire a person to take action on implementing change and to implement it successfully.
Inclusion Strategist and Creator of the E.M.E.R.G.E.N.T. Inclusion System? | Author & Keynote Speaker | Culture Created from the Hearts of Individuals
5 年Tina Altman thanks for the article. To SHED or not to SHED? Love it!