How to Know When to End a Vendor Relationship

Are you stuck between staying with a vendor or leaving the relationship? Ending a vendor relationship can be complicated. How will you replace its product or service? Do you need to get your data back? Is this the right time to leave?

To help you make the big decision, we have a guide to considerations and strategies for a safe and sound exit.

Considerations for Ending a Vendor Relationship

When deciding whether you should end the vendor relationship, use a data-driven approach. This evaluates if it’s time to move on or stay.

Here’s four signs it may be time to end the vendor relationship:

1. Poor performance – If the vendor is regularly underperforming, it may be time to move on. Review the vendor’s performance metrics and SLAs to see if those metrics are consistently late or missed. While you may want to work with the vendor to resolve issues first, a history of poor performance can be a sign to exit the relationship.
2. Lack of communication – In effective vendor partnerships, reciprocation is important. Poor communication may indicate the vendor isn’t invested in the relationship and can’t provide the product or service you need.
3. High residual risk – Residual risk is your vendor’s remaining risk to your organization after all mitigating risk controls are applied. The higher a vendor’s residual risk, the more severe consequences your organization could face. If the vendor doesn’t have the right controls in place to mitigate risks, it may be too risky to stay in the relationship.
4. Consistent noncompliance – Repeated noncompliance with contractual obligations or regulatory requirements is a sign it’s time to leave. Contractual noncompliance leads to poor performance and increased risks. Regulatory noncompliance can lead to costly fines, penalties, and lawsuits – even when the vendor is at fault, your organization can be held responsible.

Evaluating the Cost of Ending a Vendor Relationship

Before you make the final decision, evaluate the risks and costs of ending a vendor relationship. Conduct a risk assessment to identify and assess potential risks with both continuing and ending the relationship. Consider the vendor’s role in your operations, the criticality of the product or service, contractual obligations, and regulatory implications.

Conduct a cost-benefit analysis. Weigh the financial and operational costs of switching vendors against the benefits of a new vendor’s improved compliance and performance and decreased risks. Include immediate costs, like termination fees, and long-term benefits like reduced risk.

Be sure to gather feedback from stakeholders, like vendor owners that interact regularly with the vendor. This provides insights into the vendor’s performance and overall willingness to improve. Consider all perspectives for a well-rounded final decision.

By taking this balanced approach, you can ensure the decision to terminate the vendor relationship is financially sound and advantageous to your organization.

Steps to End a Vendor Relationship

Breaking up is hard to do. Following a structured process helps your organization safely and soundly exit the vendor relationship.

Here are five steps to end the vendor relationship:

1. Review contractual obligations – Before formally ending the vendor relationship, review termination provisions in the vendor contract. This may include roles and responsibilities for offboarding, the return or destruction of data and equipment, early termination fees, revoking vendor access, and the communication plan. Seek legal counsel if needed to navigate contractual obligations.
2. Execute the exit plan – The exit strategy, typically formalized in the vendor contract, is decided during vendor onboarding. It provides a roadmap for offboarding the vendor. The exit plan may specify service requirements during the transition. This includes the vendor’s obligation to continue providing specific levels of performance during transition.
3. Notify the vendor verbally and in writing – First discuss the termination with your vendor verbally and then provide written notification. This may be the most difficult step. Maintaining communication with the vendor helps smooth the process.
4. Complete final administration tasks – Complete any final activities, like reviewing and paying final invoices, updating the vendor’s status in all systems, and updating vendor inventories.
5. Review lessons learned – Reflect on the vendor relationship and offboarding process. Identify opportunities for improvement. Could your organization have done anything differently? What red flags popped up during the process? Were instructions and requirements clear enough? Document findings and share with your team.

Sometimes vendor relationships must come to an end. Evaluating the risks and costs and following the steps to offboard the vendor ensures you can exit safely.

Establish your vendor offboarding process with this comprehensive toolkit. Download now.