How is Integrated-SIM (iSIM) different from Embedded SIM (eSIM)?
Manish Rawat
Semiconductor Analyst | AI | SOC | Semi Manufacturing Equipment | Semicon | Reviewer | Tech Influencer | Consumer Tech | EV | Insight
Embedded SIM technology is referred to by the names "integrated SIM" and "eSIM"; however, they have significantly different meanings.
The term "integrated SIM" (iSIM) refers to an embedded SIM that is built into a device's system-on-chip (SoC), making it effectively a hardware-based security module. As it is built into the device's hardware, the iSIM offers the same capabilities as a conventional SIM card or an eSIM while being even more secure. It is frequently used in IoT (Internet of Things) devices, where security is a top priority.
The eSIM, on the other hand, is a SIM card integrated right into the device's circuit board. A programmable SIM card enables you to change carriers without physically exchanging SIM cards. The carrier's ability to remotely reprogram an eSIM makes it easier for the user and more adaptable for the carrier.
The primary distinction between iSIM and eSIM is the incorporation of iSIM into the device's hardware as opposed to eSIM, which is a separate chip implanted within the device. Both provide the same functions; however, because iSIM is built into the device's hardware, it is more secure, and eSIM is more adaptable because the carrier may remotely reprogram it.
Advantages and Disadvantages of iSIM and eSIM
Advantages of Integrated SIM (iSIM):
Improved security: iSIM is more secure than an eSIM or a conventional SIM card since it is physically embedded into the device's hardware. It is far more difficult to hack or copy since the security module is hardware-based.
Reduced hardware costs: Because iSIM replaces an actual SIM card slot requirement, the device's hardware is more straightforward and less expensive.
Reduced power consumption: iSIM uses less power than a standard SIM card or an eSIM, which helps extend the device's battery life.
Disadvantages of Integrated SIM (iSIM):
Restricted flexibility: The user's ability to transfer carriers or modify their plan is limited since the iSIM cannot be readily reprogrammed or updated because it is embedded into the device's hardware.
Device compatibility: Because iSIM is a newer technology, not all devices now support it.
Advantages of eSIM:
Improved adaptability: With eSIM, consumers may change providers or plans without physically replacing their SIM cards. Those who often travel or wish to transfer providers will find it more convenient.
Smaller form factor: Because eSIM is smaller than a conventional SIM card, more room may be used in the device's design.
Remote activation and provisioning: The carrier may remotely activate and provide an eSIM, eliminating the need for physical SIM cards and improving consumer convenience.
Disadvantages of eSIM:
Restricted availability: Because eSIM is a newer technology, only some carriers or devices still support it.
Security issues: eSIM might be subject to hacking or cloning, which could jeopardize the device's security and the user's privacy.
Problems with compatibility: The usage of eSIM technology may be restricted for some consumers since some devices may need to be compatible with it.