HOW INSIGHTFUL #49 - The Consistency Trap: Are Your Voting Habits Blinding You in the Next Canadian Election?

As the next Canadian federal election approaches, many voters may already have a preferred party or leader in mind. This week, HOW INSIGHTFUL looks at our voting habits and makes some recommendations for the upcoming campaign. While having established political beliefs is a normal part of a functioning democracy, it is crucial to consider whether these preferences are based on a thorough evaluation of current platforms and candidates or simply a continuation of past voting habits. The human tendency towards consistency bias, a well-documented psychological phenomenon, can significantly influence electoral choices, sometimes leading individuals to vote for the same party election after election, regardless of evolving issues or the emergence of potentially better alternatives. Understanding this bias and actively working to mitigate its effects can empower voters to make more informed decisions that truly reflect their current values and priorities.

The inclination to maintain consistency stems from a fundamental aspect of human psychology. Consistency bias, at its core, describes the psychological drive to align our actions with our previous behaviors, beliefs, or statements 1. This principle helps us avoid cognitive dissonance, the uncomfortable feeling that arises when we hold conflicting ideas or act in ways that contradict our self-perception 2. By behaving consistently, we reinforce a positive self-image, viewing ourselves as rational and dependable individuals 3. This bias can even manifest in subtle ways, such as the "foot-in-the-door" technique, where agreeing to a small initial request makes us more likely to comply with a larger one later . In the realm of social interaction, consistency is generally viewed as a positive trait, associated with strength and honesty, while inconsistency can be perceived negatively, leading to a societal reinforcement of consistent behavior . Furthermore, our brains often rely on consistency as a shortcut, allowing us to make decisions without having to re-evaluate every situation from scratch .

This powerful psychological tendency has significant implications for voting behavior. Voters may find themselves consistently supporting a particular party, even if the party's current platform no longer fully aligns with their evolving values . The desire to remain consistent with past voting choices can create a resistance to new information that might suggest a different political alignment . For instance, someone who has always voted for a certain party might be less likely to consider the merits of another party's platform, even if that platform now better addresses their key concerns.

In the Canadian political landscape, the influence of consistency bias can be observed in several ways. Partisan loyalty, where individuals strongly identify with a particular political party, plays a significant role in voting decisions . Research suggests that party identification can sometimes outweigh specific policy preferences, with a large majority of party identifiers consistently voting for their party's candidates . This ingrained habit and emotional connection to a party can make it challenging for voters to consider alternative options, even when issues change. Regional loyalty also contributes to consistent voting patterns 4. Voters in certain provinces or regions may have a long history of supporting a particular party due to shared historical experiences, regional interests, or cultural alignment. This can lead to a consistent pattern of voting for that party, regardless of shifts in the national political landscape. Similarly, social and cultural factors, such as religious affiliations, have historically influenced voting behavior in Canada, sometimes leading to long-term patterns of party support 4. Even negative voting, where individuals are primarily motivated to vote against a particular party, can become a consistent behavior, with voters repeatedly supporting whichever alternative appears most likely to defeat their target of opposition .

Consider a voter who initially supported a party due to its focus on fiscal responsibility. Over time, the party's platform may evolve to emphasize social conservatism, a stance with which the voter does not fully agree. However, due to the established habit of voting for that party and a desire for consistency, the voter might still cast their ballot in the same way . Similarly, a voter who once supported a party with strong environmental policies might continue to do so even if the party's commitment to environmental issues weakens due to economic considerations 6. These examples illustrate how consistency bias can lead to voting decisions that are not entirely based on a current and comprehensive evaluation of all available options.

While consistency bias can be a powerful influence, research indicates that Canadian voters are not entirely immune to change. Recent polling data surrounding hypothetical leadership changes suggests a degree of fluidity in voter allegiances . For example, the emergence of a new leader for one of the major parties has been shown to attract voters from other parties, including those who previously supported rivals . In one poll, a significant portion of voters who supported the NDP in the previous election indicated an intention to vote for the Liberals under new leadership . This suggests that while many voters exhibit consistent patterns, factors such as leadership and significant political events can prompt reconsideration .

The probability of a Canadian voter repeating their vote from one federal election to the next varies depending on several factors . Polls have shown different rates of voter retention for various parties. For instance, after a hypothetical leadership change, the intention of past Liberal voters to vote Liberal again increased significantly . In contrast, other polls have indicated higher initial retention rates among Conservative voters . These figures suggest that the likelihood of repeat voting is influenced by the strength of a voter's initial party identification, their satisfaction with the current leadership, and the prevailing political climate . It is important to note that overall voter turnout in Canadian federal elections has seen a general decline in recent decades . The 2021 election, for example, had a turnout of 62.6% . This trend indicates that a substantial portion of the electorate may not be deeply engaged in the political process, potentially making them more reliant on habitual voting or less likely to seek out comprehensive information before casting their ballot .

To break free from the potential limitations of consistency bias and make more balanced decisions in the upcoming Canadian federal election, voters can adopt a proactive approach. Here is a three-step plan:

1. Self-Reflection and Acknowledgment: Before the election campaign fully takes shape, take some time to think about your past voting history and the reasons behind your choices. Recognize that the tendency towards consistency might be influencing your current preferences . Asking yourself why you have consistently supported a particular party can reveal whether those reasons are still valid in the current political context.
2. Diverse Information Consumption: Actively seek out information from a wide range of news sources and perspectives, including those that might challenge your existing political views 7. Explore the official platforms of all the major political parties, going beyond headlines and social media summaries . Reading in-depth analyses from various media outlets and considering different viewpoints can help you gain a more comprehensive understanding of the issues at stake .
3. Issue-Based Evaluation: Instead of primarily focusing on party affiliation, identify the key issues that are most important to you in this election. These could include healthcare, the economy, climate change, or social justice. Once you have identified your priorities, compare the specific policies and proposals of different parties on these issues 8. This approach encourages a more rational and less emotionally driven evaluation of the available choices .

For all Canadian voters, here are three key things you can do during this campaign to educate yourself and see if you are still aligned on the prospective parties' platforms:

1. Check Elections Canada and Party Websites: Visit the official Elections Canada website (elections.ca) to find information about the election process, the candidates running in your electoral district, and links to all registered political parties . Explore the official websites of the major Canadian political parties (Liberal Party of Canada, Conservative Party of Canada, New Democratic Party, Green Party of Canada, Bloc Québécois, People's Party of Canada) to read their detailed platforms and understand their proposed policies on various issues .
2. Utilize CBC Vote Compass and Other Online Tools: Use interactive tools like the CBC Vote Compass (votecompass.cbc.ca) to see how your own views align with the positions of different political parties 10. Many reputable news organizations offer online resources that provide summaries and comparisons of party platforms on key issues . These tools can offer valuable insights into which party's platform best reflects your own priorities.
3. Attend Local Candidate Events and Debates: Keep an eye out for announcements of local candidate meetings, town halls, and debates happening in your community. Information about these events can often be found in local news outlets and community bulletin boards. Attending these events provides an opportunity to hear directly from the candidates running in your riding, learn more about their platforms, and ask them questions about the issues that matter most to you 11.

In conclusion, while the psychological pull of consistency can influence our voting habits, it is essential for every Canadian voter to actively engage with the upcoming federal election by seeking out diverse information, evaluating party platforms based on the issues that matter most to them, and considering all candidates fairly. By taking these steps, voters can make informed decisions that truly reflect their current values and contribute to a more representative and responsive democracy. Ultimately, the strength of our democratic process relies on the active participation of well-informed citizens who are willing to look beyond ingrained habits and vote in a way that best serves the future of Canada.

I do hope you find this edition of HOW INSIGHTFUL both thought-provoking and worthwhile. Feel free to share your thoughts on consistency in Canadian voters, I’d love to hear from you! Subscribe for more Insights.

Stay tuned for our upcoming PODCAST where we delve into the reach of AI; THE EFFECT OF AI ON >>>EVERYTHING