How to Evaluate & Retain Talent During a Merger

When a business undergoes a merger or acquisition, one of the most critical aspects for management to address is the evaluation and retention of current employees. The success of a transition often hinges on whether the right talent remains within the company. Here are key considerations for management during these pivotal times.

1. Evaluating Current Employees During a Merger or Acquisition

Something to think about… 30% of employees voluntarily leave within three years of a merger due to uncertainty or dissatisfaction with the new organizational culture.

The first step in managing an acquisition or merger is evaluating the employees of the acquired business. This evaluation should go beyond simple performance reviews. It's important to understand how each employee contributes to the company's overall culture, operations, and strategic goals. Key questions to ask include:

• How have individual employees contributed to the company’s success?
• Are their skills transferable to the new business model?
• What kind of training or support will be required to transition them effectively?

Having a structured process for employee evaluations ensures that management makes informed decisions about who should remain part of the new organization.

2. Management - Be Proactive in Identifying Key Employees

Being proactive is essential in identifying key employees early in the process. These individuals are often critical to maintaining business continuity and driving future growth. To ensure a smooth transition, management must quickly identify which employees are indispensable due to their skills, institutional knowledge, or leadership capabilities.

By proactively pinpointing these key employees, management can take steps to retain them, minimizing disruptions and fostering stability during the integration phase. The Center for American Progress reports that turnover costs can range from 16% to 213% of an employee's annual salary, depending on their role.

3. The Cost of Failing to Retain Key Employees

Failing to identify and retain critical employees can result in significant costs. Key employees often hold valuable knowledge about the company’s operations, clients, and strategies. Their departure can lead to according to HBR 50% decline in productivity as a result of:

• Leadership
• Structure
• Loss of institutional knowledge
• Decreased morale among remaining employees
• Increased recruitment and training costs to replace them
• Disruption of client relationships or delays in service delivery

All these factors contribute to a substantial loss in productivity, further jeopardizing the success of the merger or acquisition.

4. The Process of Employee Evaluation Begins

The process of evaluating current employees should start as early as possible in the transaction process. Ideally, this begins during the due diligence phase, before the deal is finalized. By evaluating employees early, management has enough time to develop retention strategies and address any concerns that may arise.

This early intervention allows for smoother transitions and enables management to communicate openly with employees about their roles in the new organization, which can reduce uncertainty and anxiety.

5. Best Practices for Retaining Key Employees

To retain key employees, management should focus on:

• Clear Communication: Employees need to understand their roles and the value they bring to the new organization. Regular communication about the merger process helps reduce anxiety.
• Incentive Programs: Offering retention bonuses or other financial incentives can encourage key employees to stay during the transition.
• Career Growth Opportunities: Provide employees with a clear vision of their career paths within the new organization. This helps them feel secure and valued.
• Cultural Integration: Cultural alignment is crucial. Ensure that the company’s culture resonates with employees to maintain engagement and prevent turnover.

As a result, according to Towers Watson, retention bonuses can lead to retention rates of 87% for key employees.

6. Tools and Tactics for Employee Evaluation and Retention

Management should use a combination of formal and informal tools to assess and retain employees:

• Employee Surveys: Gather feedback on employee morale, concerns, and expectations.
• 360-Degree Feedback: Use performance reviews from multiple sources to get a comprehensive understanding of each employee’s contributions.
• One-on-One Meetings: Engage directly with key employees to discuss their future in the company and any concerns they may have.
• Retention Bonuses: Offer financial incentives to ensure that critical employees stay through the transition.

7. The Consequences of Losing Good Employees

Losing high-performing employees during a merger or acquisition can have ripple effects throughout the organization. It may:

• Undermine team morale, leading to further resignations
• Cause operational disruptions
• Impact the company’s ability to meet business goals
• Affect customer relationships, especially if the departing employees had key client responsibilities

In essence, good employees serve as the backbone of an organization, and their loss during such a crucial time can seriously harm the business. According to Harvard Business Review, mergers that fail to integrate employees properly have a failure rate of 70-90% in achieving their intended value.

8. Employee Retention Applies to All Companies

The principles of employee retention apply to all companies, not just those going through mergers or acquisitions. Every company should continuously evaluate and engage its workforce to ensure high performance and loyalty. Regular employee assessments help identify growth opportunities and areas of concern, while retention strategies keep valuable employees on board, reducing turnover costs.

9. Best Ways to Retain Employees on a Day-to-Day Basis

For companies looking to retain employees in the long term, consider these best practices:

• Provide Competitive Compensation and Benefits: Ensure your salary and benefits packages are competitive within the industry.
• Foster a Positive Work Environment: Promote a culture of respect, collaboration, and continuous development.
• Offer Professional Development: Employees want opportunities for growth and learning. Regular training and skill-building programs are excellent incentives for retention.
• Work-Life Balance: Provide flexible work arrangements that cater to the personal needs of employees to maintain high morale and productivity.

Managing employees effectively during a merger or acquisition is vital for a successful transition. Early evaluation, proactive retention strategies, and clear communication are key to keeping valuable employees engaged and motivated, ensuring long-term success for the business.

?