How to Effectively Qualify a Job Position: A Guide for Hiring Managers

Hiring a new employee can be a daunting task, one that goes far beyond simply sifting through resumes and interviewing candidates. As a Hiring Manager, you've likely faced challenges that stem not from the candidates themselves, but from within your own organisation. Misalignment on the requirements, expectations, and goals for a position can lead to missteps that are both costly and time-consuming.

To help you navigate these complexities and ensure a smoother hiring process, I’ve compiled a comprehensive checklist. By addressing these key areas, you can align your team, clarify your needs, and ultimately find the best fit for your organisation.

1. Defining the Position

Job Title Consensus: Start by ensuring that everyone involved agrees on the title of the position. A job title might seem like a minor detail, but it sets the tone for the entire recruitment process and defines the expectations for the role.

Flexibility in Hours and Location: Consider the level of flexibility you can offer regarding work hours and location. For the right candidate, would you allow remote work, flexible hours, or working from a different office? Understanding and agreeing on these points early can broaden your candidate pool and improve job satisfaction.

Candidate Type – Contract, Permanent, or Temp-to-Perm: Determine whether you need a contract employee, a permanent hire, or a temp-to-perm solution. Each option has its pros and cons, and your decision should align with both short-term and long-term business goals.

Salary and Compensation Agreement: Ensure there’s alignment on the salary or hourly rate for the position. Confirm these figures with your finance department and senior management to avoid any surprises later. Clear communication on compensation expectations is crucial for attracting the right talent.

Start and End Dates: Establish a clear start date for the new hire. If the position is contract-based, also define the end date. Discuss any potential risks that could delay the start date, such as client project delays or funding issues. Proactively identifying these risks helps manage expectations and avoid last-minute disruptions.

2. Reviewing Internal Processes

Internal Candidate Consideration: Before looking externally, assess whether the position can be filled internally. Review past hires to determine if there’s precedent for promoting or moving internal candidates. Be aware of any internal policies or senior leadership preferences that prioritise internal hiring before considering external options.

Potential Hiring Freezes: Be mindful of any looming hiring freezes or financial restrictions that could impact your ability to bring on an external candidate. Staying informed on your company’s financial health and strategic plans will help you avoid starting a process that cannot be completed.

3. Clarifying Job Skills, Qualifications, and Desired Personality

Existence of a Job Description: A well-crafted job description is the foundation of your hiring process. If one doesn’t exist, enlist the support you need to create one. A clear and detailed job description not only attracts the right candidates but also helps streamline the selection process. I’ll explore how to write an effective job description in an upcoming article.

Prioritisation of Job Qualifications: Consult with your team to determine the most critical qualifications for the role. Often, you’ll receive an extensive list of desired skills, but only a few may be truly essential. Prioritise these requirements and distinguish between must-haves and nice-to-haves.

Understanding Team Dynamics and Personality Fit: Beyond technical qualifications, consider the personality traits that will best complement your team. Cultural fit is crucial, as mismatches in personality can lead to friction and turnover. Discuss with your team the type of personality that would thrive in your environment, whether it's someone more introverted, extroverted, detail-oriented, or big-picture focused.

Preferred Work Style: Determine whether the candidate should be a team player or an independent worker, a leader or a follower. Don’t make assumptions—ask your team directly what they value in a colleague’s work style.

Company Background Preferences: Consider whether your team prefers candidates from large corporations, startups, or other specific backgrounds. The culture and pace of a candidate’s previous workplaces can heavily influence how they perform in your organisation.

Career Goals and Ambitions: Finally, think about the long-term. What career goals should your new hire have? Aligning a candidate’s ambitions with your company’s trajectory can foster a more engaged and motivated employee.

Conclusion

Successfully qualifying a job position involves more than just defining the skills and experiences needed. It requires a deep understanding of your team’s needs, company culture, and the specific challenges and opportunities within your organisation. By addressing both the hard and soft requirements for the role, you’ll be better equipped to find a candidate who not only meets the job criteria but also fits seamlessly into your team and company culture.

Taking the time to align these elements before you begin your search can save you from the costly mistake of a bad hire and ensure a smoother, more effective hiring process.

Dedicated to Your Success,

Graham Townley

Follow us at Recruitment Evangelists for our latest industry news, jobs & Newsletter 'Revolutionising Recruitment: Navigating the Modern World of Hiring'.