How do you turn more interviews into job offers?

Welcome to Career Well-being. Each week Ana Goehner empowers professionals to prioritize well-being with practical work-life strategies: workplace boundaries, flexibility at work, targeted job search, and career advice.

? Click subscribe to be notified of future editions

Landing an interview is a huge step forward in your job search, but how do you convert that interview into a job offer?

If you've been interviewing without getting the results you want, you're not alone. Many professionals find themselves in the same boat—qualified for the role but unable to seal the deal.

So, what sets the top candidates apart?

The Key to Success: Specificity

In my HR years of interviewing and preparing candidates for job interviews as a coach, I've noticed one thing that consistently sets the top 1% of candidates apart from the rest—specificity.

Candidates who offer clear, detailed answers based on their research and experience always leave a lasting impression. It’s not just about giving the right answers—it’s about showing that you understand the company’s needs and have the experience to back them up.

Why Generic Answers Won’t Cut It

Most candidates give generic answers. These often sound like:

• "I think I would be a great fit."
• "Your company is doing amazing things, and I want to be part of it."
• "I’m passionate about the work you’re doing."

While these statements may sound positive, they don’t tell the interviewer much about why you’re the right fit. There’s no substance behind them, and they lack the specificity needed to stand out.

What Specific Answers Look Like

To make a lasting impression, you need to be specific. This means doing your homework—researching the company, its challenges, goals, and current initiatives. You need to show that you’ve thought about how your skills and experience align with the role and how you can help the company achieve its objectives.

Here's an example.

Interview Question: Why Do You Want to Work for Our Company?

Generic Answer:

"I think your company is great, and I believe I would be a great fit."

This answer doesn’t provide any real information. It could be used for any company, and it doesn’t explain why you want to work there or what value you bring.

Specific Answer:

"I’ve been following your company’s growth, particularly your recent expansion into sustainable fashion. Your commitment to reducing waste through eco-friendly fabrics and manufacturing processes really stands out. At my previous company, I led an initiative to source sustainable materials, which reduced our production costs by 15% and earned us industry recognition for ethical practices. I’m excited to bring my knowledge of sustainable fashion to your team and help further your mission to create environmentally responsible products."        

This answer is tailored to the company. It shows that you’ve done your research and can clearly articulate how your past experience will benefit the company.

How to Prepare for Your Next Job Interview

To stand out and turn more interviews into job offers, follow this simple three-step process:

1. Research Thoroughly

Dive deep into the company’s background, values, recent projects, and challenges. Understand their mission, goals, and the industry trends that affect them. Check out their website, social media, news articles, and even LinkedIn profiles of the hiring team.

The more you know, the better equipped you’ll be to tailor your answers.

2. Craft Specific Answers

Once you’ve done your research, use it to craft specific answers that tie your experience to the company’s needs. Prepare a few examples from your past roles where you solved a problem or achieved a result that aligns with what the company is looking for.

Ask yourself:

• What challenges are they facing that I’ve already solved in my career?
• How can I use my skills to help them achieve their goals?

3. Test Your Answers

For each answer, ask yourself: "Would this make sense if I were interviewing at another company?"

If your answer could be applied to any company, it’s too generic. Your goal is to make your responses so tailored that they only make sense for the company you’re interviewing with. You’re on the right track to standing out if you achieve that.

Turning a Job Interview into a Job Offer: Example Scenarios

Let’s look at how you can apply this approach in different interview scenarios.

Scenario 1: Career Growth in the Same Industry

If you want to advance within the same industry, you can use your past accomplishments to demonstrate your value to the new company.

Question: "Tell me about a time you led a project."

• Generic Answer: "I’ve led several projects in my last role, and I’m confident I can do the same here."

Specific Answer: "At my previous company, I led a cross-functional team to streamline our supply chain process. By implementing new inventory management software, we cut delivery times by 20%, improved customer satisfaction, and saved the company $200,000 annually. I noticed your team is focusing on improving operational efficiency, and I’d love to bring my experience in optimizing processes to this role."        

Scenario 2: Changing Industries

If you’re transitioning into a new industry, your answers should show how your transferable skills can benefit the company.

Question: "Why are you interested in switching to [Industry Name]?"

• Generic Answer: "I think [Industry Name] is exciting, and I’m ready for a new challenge."

Specific Answer: "In my current role as a marketing manager, I’ve developed strong skills in data analysis and customer segmentation. I noticed your company is looking to expand its digital marketing efforts, and I believe my ability to analyze consumer data and create targeted campaigns would help drive growth in your e-commerce sales."        

Scenario 3: After Receiving a Job Offer

Once you’ve aced the interview, how do you handle receiving a job offer? This is your moment to ensure you’re getting the best possible deal.

What to Do After a Job Offer:

• Review the Offer Carefully: Take your time to review the compensation package, benefits, and work-life balance.
• Negotiate: Don't hesitate to negotiate if the offer doesn’t meet your expectations. Know your worth and have data to support your request for a higher salary or better benefits.
• Clarify Any Doubts: Before accepting, ask any lingering questions about the role, team, or company culture.

Final Thoughts on How to Turn Your Job Interview Experience into a Job Offer

Securing a job offer after an interview comes down to one essential element—specificity. When you take the time to research the company, craft tailored answers, and demonstrate how your experience aligns with the role, you stand out from the crowd.

Remember, interviewers can spot generic answers from a mile away.

To turn your next job interview into an offer, focus on being specific, showing your value, and demonstrating how you can contribute to the company’s success.

The job offer you’ve been waiting for might be just one specific answer away.

??P.S. If you want more content like this, become a Career Well-being Thriver ! Get my exclusive Thursday newsletter directly to your inbox + a gift! ??