How Do You Choose a Video Management Software?

Introduction

Video Management Software (VMS) is supplied by all CCTV vendors as part of an embedded software on a Digital Video Recorder (DVR), the remote site interface, the software used for a Networked Video Recorder (NVR) be it embedded on a Linux platform or Personal Computer (PC) based on a Windows Server or the Mobile Application. They are all VMS options that allow you to interact with cameras and in some cases more than just cameras; access control, analytics, intrusion and point of sale.

Vision Catcher was one of the first companies to introduce VMS and DVRs into the South African market in 1998 with the use of the Novex VMS that was deployed into various verticals including Telecommunications, Petro-Chemicals, Banks, Mines, many other Corporations and Industries. The then basic VMS software proved the ability to link video capture cards in a personal computer (PC) with up to 16 cameras on a display; multiple viewing options and recorded video replay. The choice of recording and replay device was between an embedded DVR or the PC; the embedded DVR offering a VMS on an embedded Linux operating system restricting access to programmes thus theoretically reducing the risk of viruses or someone changing key settings. Today choosing the right VMS is critical for your solution to perform to the level of your expectations and is often overlooked as you purchase an embedded NVR and camera package.

Features & Advantages

The right VMS should provide you with at least the following features:
? Software options
? Cost options
? Simplicity
? Flexibility
? Integration
? Intelligence
? Scalability
? Reliability
? Upgrades

This simple list defines the advantages you might be expecting in a suitable VMS. As an example a basic embedded DVR will give you the software option for an inbuilt four, eight, sixteen or thirty two channels of video which will determine the cost option. The VMS should be relatively simple to use and flexible as the user probably only wants to review key events, is unlikely to require much integration, may not look to add to the NVR in terms of additional cameras or upgrades, but needs it to be reliable; therefore a low cost NVR with limited performance may be your choice.

Compare the comments above for the DVR and now consider a medium to enterprise VMS solution. There is often a requirement for live and remote monitoring rather than just recording and playback after an event. The solution plan will often be to add best of breed cameras from different vendors over a period of time expanding the system in small steps. The solution must therefore be scalable as new sites or cameras are added, flexible to map and interact with each camera through integration options and simple to use for any trained operator. The right VMS will provide a minimum of these features and will show clearly the advantages of choosing a bespoke VMS solution.

Vision Catcher is a distributor for Tyco Security Products, marketing and selling the exacqVision VMS; a fully scalable and cost effective solution. Exacq is unique in the current market as the only software vendor to offer embedded Linux Edge software on the camera using a SD card recording for up to 7 days. Having an operating system on the camera replaces the NVR and only needs a communication interface to link back to the control room; no additional software, DVR or NVR is required on site; thus reducing cost. There are three different software level options from START, PRO and ENTERPRISE, offering features and benefits that scale up accordingly to provide a stable and effective solution from one camera to hundreds of cameras. Every quarter a new version of software upgrade is released providing new and additional integration options.

DVR, NVR or VMS

You have the ability to decide what solution is best for your requirement. The right threat analysis questions from your security vendor should elicit the answers for your perceived risks and highlight your key points of concern, which should allow you to make the right choice.

DVR

You may have a legacy product that can still be used and upgraded over time. Some vendors will offer a DVR option using existing analogue cameras and adding HD-SDI cameras to improve resolution up to 1080p (2MP). Beware of the old cabling and deteriorating signal performance. The DVR will provide improved VMS features but also watch out for the live and recorded video quality as it is often restricted to keep costs down.

Hybrid

In between the DVR and NVR is a Hybrid that offers you the ability to continue using your existing analogue cameras together with the choice of adding a selection of IP cameras as you need. Over time you could reduce the analogue cameras and increase the number of IP cameras as you evolve and upgrade your solution. The VMS should give you the option to upgrade software and licences as required. This is often a very important consideration as we will explain later.

NVR

The NVR route normally requires you to replace all analogue cameras with IP cameras; the exception is to use an encoder as a legacy option for priority analogue cameras. The NVR may be scaled in a similar manner to the DVR offering lower costs for less cameras based upon the Mbps data throughput which determines the quality and capacity of the NVR components and hence the cost. This solution should be upgraded to keep pace with firmware and feature updates but may have hardware limitations that keep you using the existing software and cameras. Remember that newer cameras with improved features have new firmware requiring VMS software upgrades and may exclude you from adding a preferred new camera.

VMS

Vendors offering a VMS solution need to be able to provide realistic technical support. VMS software assumes that the purchaser has an understanding of both hardware and software implementation to ensure that the VMS is stable and reliable for the end user; this is why most VMS vendors insist that the installer/integrator is properly qualified to a set level to be able to sell and support the product. Be careful of the VMS vendor who is not fully certified, posing the question; how many DVR or NVR vendors are actually qualified to support their products?

Choosing the VMS solution route now allows you to design and build a bespoke Server solution having calculated the required data throughput for live viewing, recording and playback. Add to this, the knowledge that your storage will manage the required number of days recorded and give the option to bookmark and archive relevant events. The VMS interface should be simple and intuitive providing the operator with an easy to the eye set of features including intelligent options linked from event, analytics, point of sale exception, audio or other interface to bring up the view, push video or draw attention to a particular incident.

Your VMS choice should offer you the ability to purchase software at varying licencing levels or packages where you would use the software on a workstation or server designed by the supplier for the expected number of cameras, data throughput and operational requirement. ExacqVision offers you the option to purchase its software separately or in combination with its own hardware designed specifically for the data throughput requirements enabling a higher performance. With the current exchange rates it is often perceived that purchasing the software and designing your own hardware is a cheaper option. In many cases this is not true as the increased performance of the hardware supplied by the VMS provider extends licencing periods and enables superior data throughput by up to 20-30% with greater efficiency. This translates to better overall performance, more cameras, greater storage, quicker search and playback options all on the one device.

ExacqVision’s offering is fully scalable so that vendors may target home use, the corner store, the shopping mall, the corporation through to the large scale enterprise solutions with multiple dispersed sites. Exacq’s aim is to provide a well-priced product providing support for the many features commented upon above, able to work with the increasing range of cameras and their firmware, and finally to operate on Windows, Linux or MAC operating systems without conflicts. Manufacturers have agreed to various standards including ONVIF (Open Network Video Interface Forum) which determines a minimum set of features an ONVIF camera should attain. Hence many VMS products will claim multiple camera integrations using ONVIF without being able to provide Motion Detection, Audio and many other true integration features available in exacq’s VMS solution; please read the fine print.

Software Subscription Agreements

Licence upgrades are poorly explained leading to confusion and concern over hidden costs at a later date. When you purchase an embedded NVR and cameras it will have a current VMS software version. The VMS version is purchased as part of the embedded NVR and will work with its prescribed list of cameras as per its specification. Once installed and working you may decide to add new cameras; it is very important that you check the current VMS version to see if it supports the new cameras (firmware) and ensure the old VMS version is also updated along with older camera firmware. If you do not follow the software upgrade options you may not be able to add the new cameras to your system!

Every day new cameras are released with new firmware. The camera firmware is the on-camera software which allows the camera to perform its functions/features. The camera firmware is updated regularly for the older cameras but care should be taken that the firmware upgrade is compatible with the existing VMS software. This now starts a software upgrade cycle between cameras and the VMS, add a camera and it needs a certain version of VMS, change the VMS and you may need to update camera firmware. It is this interaction that requires the VMS producers to constantly review and update their software, which in turn leads to a cost requirement for the development. This cost requirement effectively becomes the Software Subscription Agreement (SSA).

Most VMS vendors should offer you a Software Subscription Agreement (SSA) option; normally this is around 5-10% of the licence cost per annum. Those VMS vendors that state they do not charge for software upgrades have often brought in SSA’s at a later stage when they change versions at a much increased premium. The big advantage of your SSA is that you are keeping current with the evolving developments of the software versions with new added features as well as the camera firmware upgrades. The new versions often provide improved performance, a VMS that evolves with you and current trends, keeps track of camera upgrades and allows you to choose best of breed products. Purchasing the SSA at the small price applicable will ensure your VMS is up to date with all the new features available.

The Future

exacqVision is well placed for the future with their Edge based solutions and continuing VMS developments adding integrated options for access control, fire and safety, analytics and intrusion; expanding enterprise features such as failover and redundancy, multi-server administration, multi-level mapping and system health management. Tyco as one of the larger Security companies worldwide owns and invests in exacqVision to provide a market leading and preferred VMS solution. As such exacq provides an effective and fully scalable range of VMS solutions including server hardware options and the Illustra camera range. With one of the largest diverse camera integrations the VMS offers you the ability to choose or have recommended the best of breed products for your solution requirements. Vision Catcher is the appointed Tyco Security Products distributor offering exacqVision VMS, Illustra cameras and Kantech access control. www.visioncatcher.co.za