How Disasters Revolutionized CAT Modeling
By Kirk Gordon, Risk Control Manager and Senior Vice President
CAT modeling provides a probabilistic calculation of property loss expectancies associated with a variety of natural catastrophe perils. Insurers and lenders are keen to understand the anticipated loss expectancy associated with a portfolio’s exposure to a particular peril, e.g., windstorm, storm surge, flood, etc. Natural catastrophe insurance limits can be costly and should be accurately determined.“
Carriers and MGAs use CAT modeling to gauge the risk of an individual account, which determines their likelihood to offer coverage, the price at which they do so, and the limits they offer, as well as the amount of risk it will inject into their overall book of business,” said George Papadakis, client director at Moody’s Risk Management Services.“
Risk managers need this information as well to determine how high their purchased limits should be and how to structure their policies to make their coverage as cost effective as possible. As intermediaries, brokers need access to these tools to advise their clients and negotiate with carriers on their behalf.”
Catastrophes Spurn Evolution
Hurricane Andrew in 1992 changed the insurance industry’s perception of hurricanes and the need to better understand and calculate the catastrophic damage associated with future weather-related events. Improvements in modeling required better understanding of the science of particular perils as well as additional detail on building construction and the resilience or lack of resilience in a severe storm condition.
“Andrew led to the wholesale adoption of CAT modeling by carriers for tracking accumulations of possible losses, and not just exposures,” Papadakis said. “This happened at the carrier level and bled down into the brokerages as they needed these same tools to provide relevant advice to their clients. Model vendors also began to develop more peril models, such as for severe convective storm, winter storm, wildfire, flood, and expanded into more international territories.”
Hurricane Katrina in 2005 resulted in more losses due to secondary flooding than due to the wind-generated catastrophe. After the storm surge data was re-evaluated, many hurricane model profiles needed updating.
"Katrina also prompted the development of loss amplification, or the scaling up of economic losses, due to increased localized inflation caused by shortages of labor and materials after major events,” Papadakis said.
CAT models are continuously being evaluated and revised based on current events as well as changes in building materials, building codes, population density changes, and resulting infrastructure changes.
Exceedance Probability and Hurricanes Ian and Harvey
Exceedance Probability (EP), which plays an important role in CAT modeling, is the probability that a certain loss value will be exceeded in a predefined future time period.
For example, if you simulate 10,000 years of hurricanes, the highest loss will have a 0.01% chance of being exceeded.
The Probable Maximum Loss (PML) is the peak dollar value of the EP curve and represents the percentile of the annual loss distribution in a given time period (1/250 years, 1/500 years, etc.). The Average Annual Loss (AAL) is the average of the entire loss distribution and is represented as the area under the EP curve. The AAL is the estimated annual premium based on the particular catastrophic exposure.
Models are highly adept at measuring very large events such as Hurricane Ian in 2022. The wind event was well predicted and performed as the models expected, building structures performed as the model predicted, and the flood model predictions were accurate. This would suggest the PML exposures and the AAL premium dollars responded as the clients and insurers anticipated.
“Another example is 2017’s Hurricane Harvey,” Papadakis said. “A large, big-box retail client examined their property distribution and values and had it modeled. The high results indicated they needed higher limits for projected hurricane losses. They also had a high risk for Business Interruption (BI) due to the location of some of their distribution centers. By buying additional BI coverage and higher wind limits, they were able to recover more fully and quickly than they would have otherwise.”
Read McGriff’s It Benefits You, a monthly newsletter containing information on HR best practices, employee benefits industry trends and regulatory requirements. McGriff provides employers with tools and resources to help your company identify and manage the risks inherent with employees and the valuable benefits needed to recruit and retain people.
About McGriff - Never settle for less.
When it comes to protecting your most valuable assets, at McGriff we believe no one should settle for less than the best. We’re a get-it-done broker, rooted in relationships and driven by a passion to serve. For more than a century, we’ve relied on our experience, resources, and relationships to deliver insurance and risk management solutions focused on our clients’ priorities and what they value most.
Read our story on McGriff.com.
Business Insurance ? Risk Management ? Employee Benefits ? Personal Insurance
This article is provided for informational purposes only. McGriff is not providing legal advice and recommends you consult with your own counsel for legal guidance/opinion.?
?2024 McGriff Insurance Services, LLC. All rights reserved. McGriff Insurance Services, LLC is a subsidiary of TIH Insurance Holdings, LLC.