How dirty is your grease?
MRG Labs grease cleanliness report, 06/13/2017

How dirty is your grease?

For many years, those in industry have understood that dirty oil is a real problem. Moisture and dirt in oil are a leading cause of wear and premature bearing failure, causing fatigue, abrasion and erosion. By addressing the cleanliness of new oils, filtering oil before putting it into the machine, and protecting the machine from further contamination has demonstrated huge savings and return on investment.

But what about grease? We place grease into the same types of machines, lubricate the same bearings with grease that we lubricate with oil, yet little thought is given to the contaminants present in the grease and what that is doing to the life of our machines. Perhaps this is due to two reasons: one, its hard to do anything about dirty grease other than throwing it away or purging it out (you can't easily filter it); and secondly, there has been no easy way to quantify the presence of contaminants in greases. That is about to change, as ASTM will be shortly publishing a revision to ASTM D7918 that will include the first Standard Method for quantifying particulate and moisture levels in greases.

In the video above, a Grease Thief Analyzer being operated in accordance with D7918 was used to evaluate five different new greases right from the packaging. And the results are stunning. Some greases were found to be nearly pristine, with little to no particulate content, while others (as you can see) are downright filthy. And there was no way to differentiate these greases by looking at them. Only the high-resolution camera in the Grease Thief Particle Counter (GT-PC) was able to make this distinction, and assign a quantitative value to the cleanliness of the grease. On the moisture side, using the Arizona Instruments VaporPro on a grease substrate prepared by ASTM D7918, these greases were found with new moisture levels ranging from just under 100 ppm to several thousand ppm. With SKF stating that damage to bearings can be significant with as little as 400 ppm moisture, without knowledge of the condition of the new grease being pumped into your machines, there is no way to know how much money you are wasting on bearing replacements.

But rather than just raise the alarm, we are going to do something about it. We are going to perform a study of new greases to characterize their cleanliness and share the results on LinkedIn. The first 30 customers that contact us will be sent a free Grease Thief Sampling Sleeve to be returned with the new grease of their choice. Pick something that is used in your most critical equipment to find out whether you are lubricating with grease, dirt, water, or all three. We will analyze your sample and share the results with you, and then show you where your grease stands when graphed against the other samples that were submitted. If you are interested, comment here and we will reach out with an InMail message with instructions to participate. And we will update the results here as well. Our goal is to change the way folks treat their grease lubricated equipment by providing the data that can lead to better maintenance decisions.

Duane Dys

Technical Sales Representative specializing in precision-driven maintenance and reliability solutions

7 年

Hi Rich, I am with One Eye Industries and we would like to commend you on this effort you are putting forth. It is about time that industry realizes that a small amount of contaminents can cause major failures in equipment. Gears, according to manufacturers specs say 4 micron. I read you are testing to 10 micron. Is there any way that your test could do 1 micron or less? Perhaps if you dilute the grease before testing? Will yor test work on oil? The reason we are asking is we provide magnetic filtration where we have proven to get to sub micron levels in oil, gear lubes, grease... We believe if you put the grease through our pre-filter you would not see any particulate in your current test kit. We would also recommend that consumers filter it prior to use The amount of particulate matter is determined in part by the process of making it additives, environment, etc. I am sure you are aware of such. We would appreciate the opportunity to discuss this with you. Once again, great work, I hope you get a positive response from the manufactures of the grease that you will be recording. Duane Dys 403-926-5182

回复
Rich Wurzbach

Innovator in Lubrication Optimization

7 年

There is still time to participate in this no-cost study of grease cleanliness. Send us your request to participate, and we will get the Grease Thief sampling kits to you at no charge for submitting three samples for our ASTM D7918 method for grease particle counting and moisture ppm analysis. So far, the results are eye opening, and we look forward to sharing our data anonymously to give a sense of the current state of cleanliness in new and in-service greases. Samples must be submitted by August 31st, so if you wish to participate, contact us now. [email protected] 1-717-843-8884

Paul Pollmann

Technical Sales Director at PAMAS Vertriebs GmbH & Co. KG

7 年

"But what about grease? We place grease into the same types of machines, lubricate the same bearings with grease that we lubricate with oil, yet little thought is given to the contaminants present in the grease and what that is doing to the life of our machines. ..." What classification standards will be used to measure the cleanliness of grease? The same as in oil like ISO 4406, SAE AS 4059?

回复
Pramod Kar

Industrial Sales | Key Account Management | Rotary Asset Management & Reliability Service | Strategic Business Development | Business Excellence | Mentoring & Coaching

7 年

Buyer should be careful during procurement from the right source. Also, proper handling & storage will help to minimize contamination.

回复
Troy Walls

Hot-Dip Galvanizing in Nashville, TN

7 年

This is interesting stuff. Thank you for expanding the frontier of knowledge for lubricant contamination control.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了